• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

One Piece General Discussion: Egghead

Twitter after Lucci stabs the shit out of Garp with Yamato freezing his ribs and Marco warming up his corpse for sea king dinner

F1X9J2nXgAARIjj.jpg:large
 
Honestly, if the fight took place on an Island, is there anything stopping Garp from just chucking Yamato into the ocean-

He did something similar to Sanjuan off-screen, and I feel like he could certainly win a 2v1 at that point.
 
Post-Timeskup Kizaru > Pre-Timeskip Kizaru.

Yamato also had Greenbull pissing and ******** after 1 hit.
Greenbull absolutely tanked a Hao infused attack from Yamato that left her huffing with barely any damage to show for it. It's okay to say a character is strong without calling them Admiral level.
 
Saying Garp loses a 3v1 against Admiral or near-Admiral level combatants is not downplay.
They're not close to the Admirals
You could only really argue Yamato is
Lucci has proven to have worse AP than them as well as worse endurance stamina and durability/defense
Marco... Lol. Dude's only fought the Admirals when they were casual or weakened
They're all strong but not top tiers or near top tiers
 
Greenbull absolutely tanked a Hao infused attack from Yamato that left her huffing with barely any damage to show for it. It's okay to say a character is strong without calling them Admiral level.
Injured Base Yamato hit him and he went "WOWZA, that's strong."
Marco... Lol. Dude's only fought the Admirals when they were casual or weakened
Marco is literally stated to be able to fight evenly with them.
 
Marco is literally stated to be able to fight evenly with them.
Wrong. The databook said that Marco fought evenly with the Admirals during Marineford which never actually happened. Databooks are secondary canon. If they contradict the manga they get discarded.
Injured Base Yamato hit him and he went "WOWZA, that's strong."
He tanked her attack but complimented her Haki.
 
Wrong. The databook said that Marco fought evenly with the Admirals during Marineford which never actually happened. Databooks are secondary canon. If they contradict the manga they get discarded.
He fought them, he damaged them, he's stated to have fought evenly, I really don't see the contradiction.
He tanked her attack but complimented her Haki.
He was clutching his head, he said "man, that hurt" and he said "that's some strong Haki you got there," I don't see the contention.
 
He was clutching his head, he said "man, that hurt" and he said "that's some strong Haki you got there," I don't see the contention.
I'd imagine that getting hit off-guard would deal at least a minimum amount of damage to him. The fact that all Aramaki said was "that hurt" from her attack proves that she shouldn't be in the same conversation as him, especially considering she felt it was necessary to call the Straw Hats to win.
 
I'd imagine that getting hit off-guard would deal at least a minimum amount of damage to him. The fact that all Aramaki said was "that hurt" from her attack proves that she shouldn't be in the same conversation as him, especially considering she felt it was necessary to call the Straw Hats to win.
Injured + Base. Yamato's Hybrid form is gonna hit way harder.
 
Injured + Base. Yamato's Hybrid form is gonna hit way harder.
Doesn't change the point that she felt it was necessary to call on the Straw Hats to have any chance of beating him.

On top of that, Admirals are stated by Aramaki to be far above the likes of commander level fighters like Yamato. This shouldn't be a discussion.
 
Doesn't change the point that she felt it was necessary to call on the Straw Hats to have any chance of beating him.

On top of that, Admirals are stated by Aramaki to be far above the likes of commander level fighters like Yamato. This shouldn't be a discussion.
"Commander level fighters" isn't a thing. Benjamin Tenjamin Beckman is a commander. MIHAWK is a commander.
 
"He was stated to be on par with them."

"When did he hurt them?"

"When did they hurt him?"

"STOP SHIFTING THE GOALPOSTS!"
You're avoiding my question by asking a completely different question. If you know you made a mistake when saying that Marco harmed them just say it. No need to ignore my question.
 
"Commander level fighters" isn't a thing. Benjamin Tenjamin Beckman is a commander. MIHAWK is a commander.
Stop acting obtuse. Both of us know the context. Aramaki defeated King and Queen, stating that Admirals can't lose to people like them. Yamato is on their level, meaning he's far above her as well.
 
You're avoiding my question by asking a completely different question. If you know you made a mistake when saying that Marco harmed them just say it. No need to ignore my question.
I don't think either of them significantly harmed the other without hax/duraneg stuff.
 
I don't think either of them significantly harmed the other without hax/duraneg stuff.
The difference is that Marco has actively attacked 2/3 of the Admirals with nothing to show for it while the inverse never happened so reversing the question is a false equivalence.
 
Stop acting obtuse. Both of us know the context. Aramaki defeated King and Queen, stating that Admirals can't lose to people like them. Yamato is on their level, meaning he's far above her as well.
Yamato is superior to King and Queen, and frankly, the argument that Yamato is somehow "Nowhere near" Greenbull's level because he said he can't lose to them is odd.
 
The difference is that Marco has actively attacked 2/3 of the Admirals with nothing to show for it while the inverse never happened so reversing the question is a false equivalence.
I mean, I guess he cut a chunk out of Akainu's throat, but that might've been Vista.

That said, if you have proof of the Admirals actually harming him off raw AP, that's all I'm looking for.
 
Yamato is superior to King and Queen, and frankly, the argument that Yamato is somehow "Nowhere near" Greenbull's level because he said he can't lose to them is odd.
Even if you think that Yamato is stronger than King and Queen, it's inarguable that she's in that tier of power, which was my point.

Except it's not because that's the entire point of Admirals. They are 3 monsters that help maintain the balance of the world. Them being anything higher than a mid diff away from people on Yamato's tier is ridiculous.
 
Back
Top