• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Metal Gear Discussion Thread

What are you even talking about, water cutters cut through pressure of water crashing against the surface of a material which accelerates erosion or outright just induces shear failure.
Yes, tiny micro water jets, not huge ones? They exploit area BECAUSE they have so little mass behind them? It's the same principle behind a bullet, but like, imagine if a bullet had 10000x more mass, yet only 10x slower, you gonna argue "nah the bullet can't rip through a person because it needs to be at least [speed] to", because that's literally what you've been going off about.
If the nozzle is larger in diameter so would be the surface of the material being hit by the water which conversely increases the total amount of force needed to induce failure on it, but the pressure aka N/m2 or Pascals would remain a constant in this equation because otherwise the materials won’t give in.
Except that's just wrong? It's a mix, velocity, area, and mass effect it.
At a certain point the area becomes less relevant because the mass is like, literally orders of magnitudes higher while still retaining some semblance of velocity?

If Ray's jet was moving at like 1mps and outputting say, 40 tons of water a seconds, youre right, it wouldnt cut through steel, but 40 tons at half the speed of sound almost? Yeah, it would, and does, many times over.
The speed has to be a constant as well because it’s water crashing at those speeds that create pressure in the first place.
No it doesn't? If you drop a sextillion tons of water on a steel plate at 0.1mps, what do you think is gonna happen? Rhetorical, that steel is going to split wide open.
Except that it just wouldn’t, much less at the speed you think it would, even the water jets with abrasive material and focused on tiny ass nozzles( so you know the water is focused on a real small point) can only cut a 6 mm plate at a rate of 6 inches per minute, which is pretty damn slow compared to what we see happen.
I literally calculated it, what the **** are you on about? The minimum speed that a water jet with the area of Ray's would need to output, in order to have a sufficient volume of water and speed ratio, given speed also affects flow rate, aka how much water it's outputting, is about 78.9 mps, in order to shear a steel plate about 1m2 that's a few inches thick like a tanker hull.

Like, I don't think you understand the energy behind even a slow af jet at Ray's size, it's essentially the equilavent of a dozen massive trucks at subsonic speeds, like no shit it's cutting through steel.
Please drop the gotcha arguments,
Well, sucks dude but it is what it is.
the speed you calculate
The speed I calculated is the speed it's shown, it is what it is.
simply doesn’t give water enough pressure to do what its shown it does and is canonically meant to do much less when you consider it’s meant to actually damage military grade armor plating outfitted to REX knockoffs ,the kind that requires a hypersonic copper jets/ or supersonic dense penetrators to reliably penetrate.
Yeah, hypersonic if it came from say, a 1mm jet.
You're actively ignoring how the flow rate increases exponentially, leading to exponential mass inflation. It doesn't NEED to be that high in velocity, because the increase in total mass outweighs the decrease in speed, it's offset by orders of magnitude.

Like, do you even actually know how strong this steel plating is? REX's armor uses ceramic composite often used in tanks, which, while strong, don't require a million tons of water at hypersonic speeds to damage dude speaking realistically, but that's beside the point, I don't know how to explain this to beyond, shit has so much extra mass behind it that it being a bit lower in speed isn't going to change it shredding metal.

On the other hand even 20 m/s for the water still would have RAY shooting double full volume in water or even that, so again wether it could realistically hold that much water was never really an issue.
That isn't even true, 20mps with a 1m2 nozzle would have a flow rate that comes out to 200m2 of water over the course of 10 seconds of sustained usage. Like, I pray I don't need to remind one that Ray itself is over 20m, tall. A few seconds of sustained usage isn't outputting as much as you think at such low speeds.

Buuut.... This doesn't matter because when Ray cuts through the tanker, it's standing in a massive pool of water due to Ocelot's bombing flooding the hangar.

And looking into it, I was literally right, Ray's jump into the water to refuel water after using the water cutter in the boss fights. They're equipped with pressure pumps to take in water, the hangar case of slightly longer sustained usage as opposed to the 2-3 seconds in the boss fight, is literally because the room is filled with like 10m high in water so Ray has like thousands and thousands of cubix meters to draw upon.

Which, goes back to the prior point actually, if even the verse itself acknowledges how dumb this is, and even has it be a point in the boss fight you can exploit where theyre vulnerable, are you really arguing "just ignore just because"?

Also thinking on it, given the Ray's can only sustain a few seconds of it, we could probably even get a volume that way based on flow rate.
We don’t need to see the water extending a km away because it’s a constant flow of water, you’re already seeing all of the mass there is of it because it is constantly moving, you’re just affirming that because we don’t see your preferred POV that it can’t be that much.
Dude. If the water moves at 1kmps, and it only moves a FRACTION of that in a second, it isnt 1kmps. Do you not understand how speed works? If you argue it moves at 1kmps, yet it only moves say, 80mps, newsflash, it ain't 1kmps, it's 80mps. The pov means **** all, what matters is the speed it's going at, you're wrong. Not much more to say, we literally see the speed it comes out as in cutscene, in the very scene you're yapping about.

So yes, it can't be that much because by your own admittance that scene is in real time meaning you can't even argue there was slow down or some shit affecting the perceived speed.
??? Except when charcters are outright blocking bullets?
Except not even, have you ever actually framed by framed this stuff? I have, Raiden actively blocking bullets, for example, is still slower than said bullets, his arms mopve like 5x slower.
Why would it be unreliable at all to say RAYs water gun is meant to be pretty fast when clearly portrayed as such more times than it wasn’t.
Because uh, we see it isn't that fast? There's nothing to debate here.
Solar gun, who the heck even thought it should be anything but subsonic, it just fires magic blobs of sunlight that behave nothing like light at all.
Because it's sunlight that has light based properties?
No shit REX’ actual laser is hitscan, its an actual unironical laser weapon.
Yeah, yet we also have times where they dodge beams too.
It’s not really inflated,
It's not only omega inflated, every argument you've put forth is either just flatout wrong, ignoring how shearing isn't just a product of speed but area x mass x velocity and even if one is lowered, any of the three being exponentially higher can offset the decrease if the increase in that value outweighs the decrease, which, it does, or blatant handwaving of common sense which, apparently, even the verse takes into account so that's not exactly up for debate, or just flatout ignoring how we see the beam fire in the actual cutscene, it's super fast, but it ain't no 1kmps, takes like 3ish frames to cover the screen.
it’s just what happens when technology that is tiny is scaled up in size,
You realize if you scaled up a water jet cutter as is, it wouldn't even work properly anymore? In fact, it's the same as how downscaling tech like REX's railgun, wouldn't make it the same speed anymore because that isn;t how mechanics work. Which yes as an aside, Fortune's railgun isn't accepted at triple digit mach, that was changed in a CRT like well over a year ago now, by Abstractions I think? We don't even accept this logic as it is for that, why would RAY be any different? That isn't even how it works irl.
and you’d be hard pressed to scale it to anything effectively because it’s only ever used against REX for a fraction of a second and depletes around half its health bar.
Yeah so it scales to REX? You can skip the need for a wanked calc by just scaling it to him instead.
Meaning it’s an anti feat for its durability at best.
I mean, I don't really care WHAT it is, I'm just telling you calcing it with a hyperinflated speed is wank, and wrong, because it isn't that speed, like not really up for debate, it just isn't shown that fast.
 
It's one of the tanks you get later on.

None of the tanks, or even weapons, in MGSV actually exist due to, unironically, copyright and branding.

but, every tank IS based off an actual irl equilavent, that tank in question is about 21-22 tons, I've checked and looked into it before.
 
460847247_966496772157254_8011051948860030097_n.jpg
 
There is a calculation that could replace the level 8-B given by Volgin, although I don't know if they have seen it before (or if it was even approved).

The problem with that is more like
We really gonna scale them to Sahel? Because mind you thats a low end, Sahel is double that at least.
He has a few other decent feats about thst high as well.
 
The problem with that is more like
We really gonna scale them to Sahel? Because mind you thats a low end, Sahel is double that at least.
He has a few other decent feats about thst high as well.
Isn't there a way to scale it without it being considered strictly anti-hax or an atypical case?
 
The problem with that is more like
We really gonna scale them to Sahel? Because mind you thats a low end, Sahel is double that at least.
He has a few other decent feats about thst high as well.
The crazy thing is that Venom can take hits from Sahel without getting One-Shot and yet he's in one of the lower sections of the scaling chain. 😭
 
The crazy thing is that Venom can take hits from Sahel without getting One-Shot and yet he's in one of the lower sections of the scaling chain. 😭
Yeah but that's be a clear outlier when goons die to a lot less consistently, Rex stomp is an insta kill to solid snake after all. I wouldn't put too much stock into this
 
Yeah but that's be a clear outlier when goons die to a lot less consistently, Rex stomp is an insta kill to solid snake after all. I wouldn't put too much stock into this
Sahel is significantly inferior to Rex though. Besides, Big Boss has been shown outright overpowering giant mechs so Venom being able to downscale from Sahel isn't absurd or anything.
 
The problem with that is more like
We really gonna scale them to Sahel? Because mind you thats a low end, Sahel is double that at least.
He has a few other decent feats about thst high as well.
Idk seems fine for their weapon scaling
Sahel is significantly inferior to Rex though. Besides, Big Boss has been shown outright overpowering giant mechs so Venom being able to downscale from Sahel isn't absurd or anything.
Sahel was stated to basically make all previous mechs look like toys in comparison, and to even surpass ZEKE in everyway

I don't think it's fair to say that "Big Boss overpowering Cocoon and Peace Walker" supports Venom downscaling from Sahel, as Sahel is far above the previous AIs anyway
 
Idk seems fine for their weapon scaling
Some weapons will still be 8-A and stuff let alone 8-B. The weapons scale to Sahel yeah.
While true, they kinda suck. Every feat ive calced for them is sub High 8-C. BB prob does scale to those ones tho given, well he literally on screens in QTEs.

I don't think it's fair to say that "Big Boss overpowering Cocoon and Peace Walker" supports Venom downscaling from Sahel, as Sahel is far above the previous AIs anyway
The Cocoon feat is 8-C and PW's Jump is about that too so yeah a lil. Legit might be where they end up.
Isn't there a way to scale it without it being considered strictly anti-hax or an atypical case?
Weapons obviously scale. I just mean Venom physically, himself, prob dont scale.
Uh, I guess MAYBE with battle suit you could make an argument for durability?
But that'd just be stone walling and nobody he scales to would scale to that suit anyhow, but, ig that's still a stat to be listed.
The crazy thing is that Venom can take hits from Sahel without getting One-Shot and yet he's in one of the lower sections of the scaling chain. 😭
nothing in game actually one shots on normal, ive had him take the ******* railgun before.
Inversely, most shit ***** him up on hard.
Which reminds me, that mf can heal broken bones so fast it's legit regen.

Yeah but that's be a clear outlier when goons die to a lot less consistently, Rex stomp is an insta kill to solid snake after all. I wouldn't put too much stock into this
REX is > Sahel, despite what the calc says too, REX is way bigger than Sahel. When Sahel folds up into "REX mode", he's actually not even half as big as the actual REX. The REX mass in the blog is just like, wrong tho, iirc it's from a non-canon american guide. It's just, Sahel is also kind of dumb and has some statements implicating incomparability to Venom. Or even TMOF, whom mauls Venom.
 
Snake should have hammer space with his infinity bandana right? Like it legit grants him an infinite amount of ammo for (conveniently) every gun he has seemingly out of nowhere
 
Wouldn't that just be extremely limited reality warping?
I mean that's one way of interpreting it? But hammerspace/dimensional storage has a very fitting description that suits the infinity bandana just fine
Dimensional Storage (also called Hammerspace or Magic satchel) is the ability to store as many items as one wishes in a sort of "storage area" without any regard for running out of room. Users are then able to summon the desired item(s) at their whim, making it seem as if they pulled each object out of thin air.

This ability is typically not used with any canonical explanations in fictional works.
 
Back
Top