- 8,857
- 5,697
What's the argument against right now?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I'll search the Chouzenshuu for the statement ig.That doesn’t answer my question.
Sorry I’m just confusedHow? It’s still a universe, but isn’t infinite. How does that go against it being a universe.
It's whether or not the cosmology works.What's the argument against right now?
Not all universes are infinite?Sorry I’m just confused
if it’s finite then that would mean it’s not universe SIZED which is weird and would be like
a multi galaxy++ sized universe or something? Which kinda implies that Goku is only multi galaxy+ level or something…
We accept each universe in every fictional verse as the size of our observable universe [unless there is a contradiction]Sorry I’m just confused
if it’s finite then that would mean it’s not universe SIZED which is weird and would be like
a multi galaxy++ sized universe or something? Which kinda implies that Goku is only multi galaxy+ level or something…
Our universe isn’t infinite, tho…Sorry I’m just confused
if it’s finite then that would mean it’s not universe SIZED which is weird and would be like
a multi galaxy++ sized universe or something? Which kinda implies that Goku is only multi galaxy+ level or something…
The observable universe is universe level. Not multi galaxy++. The living world in dragon ball is this big at least.Sorry I’m just confused
if it’s finite then that would mean it’s not universe SIZED which is weird and would be like
a multi galaxy++ sized universe or something? Which kinda implies that Goku is only multi galaxy+ level or something…
Can you give a little more detail?It's whether or not the cosmology works.
Universes in fiction by default are rated as the same size as our known universe, which is not infinite, it only has about 93 billion light-years knowns, so, unless the verse stated to the size of the universe be lower or higher than it, all universes by default are 93 billion light-yearsSorry I’m just confused
if it’s finite then that would mean it’s not universe SIZED which is weird and would be like
a multi galaxy++ sized universe or something? Which kinda implies that Goku is only multi galaxy+ level or something…
Let me condense my argument against the OP :What's the argument against right now?
You can argue that the universe is tier 0 cause of cardinals and stuff.Universes in fiction by default are rated as the same size as our known universe, which is not infinite, it only has about 93 billion light-years knowns, so, unless the verse stated to the size of the universe be lower or higher than it, all universes by default are 93 billion light-years
Thing is, they’re never implied to being far away from the universe and seem to be right next to it, so that argument doesn’t really work.Let me condense my argument against the OP :
Claim : the Living Realm and the Outer Realm are dimensionally separate spaces which makes their simultaneous destruction Tier 2 because of the unquantifiable distances involved
Contradiction : Goku can casually teleport from King Kai planet (inside the Outer Realm) to Earth (inside the Living Realm) but he can't casually teleport from Beerus' planet (inside the Living Realm) to Earth (also inside the Living Realm)
Therefore, the quantifiable distance between Beerus'planet and Earth is greater than the unquantifiable distance between King Kai's planet and Earth, meaning that the basis of arguing Tier 2 is invalid
That was never the main argument for BoG be Tier 2, it the fact that each universe had its own separated space-time.Claim : the Living Realm and the Outer Realm are dimensionally separate spaces which makes their simultaneous destruction Tier 2 because of the unquantifiable distances involved
AKM already commented here, but it would be good if he comment againSomeone definitely needs to message more staff members for this by the way. AKM and DarkDragon especially.
AKM already talked here, but I bet he is willing to do it again.Someone definitely needs to message more staff members for this by the way. AKM and DarkDragon especially.
Wow, you typed faster than me, lol....AKM already commented here, but it would be good if he comment again
Unquantifiable distances are quite literally the basis upon which the you'd build the argument that destroying separated spacetimes should be Tier 2 ... Without the unquantifiable distances, the tier 2 argument just doesn't workThe unquantifiable distances its not the main argument (or an argument at all) for BoG be Tier 2, it the fact that each universes had its own separated space-time.
This is because different universes are treated to possess different space-time continuums by default. So if you are destroying 2 universes, it is assumed that you are also breaching the 4-D axis, because without that, it wouldn't be possible.However, there is a reason that their feat is considered a Tier 2 feat, in spite of time never being mentioned. This is because the two of them were threatening to destroy two universes simultaneously. The assumption is: "Since their destruction would extend to an entirely separate dimension, logically they would have to affect their space-time continua"
No. Because U7 is treated to be a single universe. In a destruction of one universe, the above logic doesn't apply. We don't assume by default that time is also destroyed in the destruction of one universe.for the same reason Beerus and Champa's feat is considered Tier 2, Goku and Beerus' feat should be considered Tier 2 rather than 3-A
There is no difference between the two statements. A statement like the latter is also considered to be 3-A unless time is mentioned or evidenced. The former just hits the nail in the coffin even further.he went from "The two of them would reduce every planet and galaxy to space dust" to "The universe is completely done for".
That only for 2-C and beyond, it isn't a requirement for Low 2-C.Unquantifiable distances are quite literally the basis upon which the you'd build the argument that destroying separated spacetimes should be Tier 2 ... Without the unquantifiable distances, the tier 2 argument just doesn't work
I don't even think we assume this for Dragon Ball though. Pretty sure I've seen CRT's get denied for this same reason.This is because different universes are treated to possess different space-time continuums by default. So if you are destroying 2 universes, it is assumed that you are also breaching the 4-D axis, because without that, it wouldn't be possible.
I see, well I will spectate.Let me condense my argument against the OP :
Claim : the Living Realm and the Outer Realm are dimensionally separate spaces which makes their simultaneous destruction Tier 2 because of the unquantifiable distances involved
Contradiction : Goku can casually teleport from King Kai planet (inside the Outer Realm) to Earth (inside the Living Realm) but he can't casually teleport from Beerus' planet (inside the Living Realm) to Earth (also inside the Living Realm)
Therefore, the quantifiable distance between Beerus'planet and Earth is greater than the unquantifiable distance between King Kai's planet and Earth, meaning that the basis of arguing Tier 2 is invalid
Thing is, even the mortal universe is 3A, the other realms are separate realms as shown in the OP, and it should be Low 2C.Oh my. I just realized how badly this thread has been made.
60% of this thread focuses on the cosmology as how the DB universe has different realms. Well, that's common knowledge. I thought that was being used to make a 2-C argument lol.
But the thread is about BoG being Low 2-C, which means 60% of the OP is useless. Anyway,
This is because different universes are treated to possess different space-time continuums by default. So if you are destroying 2 universes, it is assumed that you are also breaching the 4-D axis, because without that, it wouldn't be possible.
No. Because U7 is treated to be a single universe. In a destruction of one universe, the above logic doesn't apply. We don't assume by default that time is also destroyed in the destruction of one universe.
There is no difference between the two statements. A statement like the latter is also considered to be 3-A unless time is mentioned or evidenced. The former just hits the nail in the coffin even further.
The distance between a place in the mortal universe (Earth) and a place in one of the major other realm (King Kai's planet) is provably less than the distance between two places within the mortal universe (Beerus' planet and Earth) so the destruction of other realms is also 3AThing is, even the mortal universe is 3A, the other realms are separate realms as shown in the OP, and it should be Low 2C.
A little late, but his planet is "beyond the universe", so perhaps it is not located in the Living World.On the other hand, God of Destruction Beerus who finally woke up after 39 years beyond the universe, was striving when the name of an unknown identity that is suppose to be his rival on his foresight dream came to mind. What is the name of the identity!
The argument of this thread i.e. destruction of separate realms gives tier 2 results implicitly uses 2-C logicThat only for 2-C and beyond, it isn't a requirement for Low 2-C.
That doesn’t make much sense when you critically think about it. Even if they were dimensionally disconnected from each other, they could still be extremely close to each other, no reason why this contradicts anything.The distance between a place in the mortal universe (Earth) and a place in one of the major other realm (King Kai's planet) is provably less than the distance between two places within the mortal universe (Beerus' planet and Earth) so the destruction of other realms is also 3A
........I don't even think we assume this for Dragon Ball though. Pretty sure I've seen CRT's get denied for this same reason.
I mean, this boils down to if you consider them being spatially separate as being temporally separate as well. Which is not something we do. But this is a cosmology argument, and since the OP isn't trying to change that, it would be derailing.Thing is, even the mortal universe is 3A, the other realms are separate realms as shown in the OP, and it should be Low 2C.
You are just assuming.......A little late, but his planet is "beyond the universe", so perhaps it is not located in the Living World.
Do you have evidence to suggest otherwise then?You are just assuming.......
And do you have evidence to suggest otherwise?....Do you have evidence to suggest otherwise then?
I think that doesn't matter since despite the distance being quantifiable, the attacks destroying the universe are still crossing seperated realms which means that they should be effecting space time, at least that's what I think the original poster intended.The distance between a place in the mortal universe (Earth) and a place in one of the major other realm (King Kai's planet) is provably less than the distance between two places within the mortal universe (Beerus' planet and Earth) so the destruction of other realms is also 3A
To be fair, this has more wide-ranging issues because it puts into question the MFTL+ travel speeds of Beerus and Whiz in BoG as wellA little late, but his planet is "beyond the universe", so perhaps it is not located in the Living World.
A lot of things are built on assumption, including cosmology. The fact is beyond (at or to the further side of, referring to the latter in this case) implies it isn't in the mortal world. Which makes sense because Beerus isn't a mortal.You are just assuming.......
They will be crossing a space-time that is provably smaller than the cross-Universe space-time so it's still 3A regardlessI think that doesn't matter since despite the distance being quantifiable, the attacks destroying the universe are still crossing seperated realms which means that they should be effecting space time, at least that's what I think the original poster intended.
The Wiki, as far as I know, does not acknowledge those feats anymore.To be fair, this has more wide-ranging issues because it puts into question the MFTL+ travel speeds of Beerus and Whiz in BoG as well
Then those just need to be fixed. That shouldn't take away from this.To be fair, this has more wide-ranging issues because it puts into question the MFTL+ travel speeds of Beerus and Whiz in BoG as well