- 165,895
- 73,617
Should we postpone this discussion until later?I would hold off until the Tiering System revisions are formally applied for this.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Should we postpone this discussion until later?I would hold off until the Tiering System revisions are formally applied for this.
I believe the “tiering” aspect is all that needs to be holt, not the subject matter of the split or not.Should we postpone this discussion until later?
I mean if you want Ant, you could be the first to give your opinion.Okay.
Does that mean you've switched from agree to neutral?I would prefer to see what other well-informed members have to say first.![]()
@ProfectusInfinityAt the moment, yes. What do you think about this suggestion btw?
If you're talking about whether to postpone this for later, I believe only the tier proposals should be evaluated later, while the cosmology split proposal in itself may keep being discussed now.At the moment, yes. What do you think about this suggestion btw?
He means what of the OP and the information presented for the split.If you're talking about whether to postpone this for later, I believe only the tier proposals should be evaluated later, while the cosmology split proposal in itself may keep being discussed now.
Yes, that is correct.He means what of the OP and the information presented for the split.
Unless I've missed something, the intro paragraph is the only place where the justifications for the cosmology split in itself are being explained, right?Yes, that is correct.![]()
The reasoning here is very brief, and doesn't actually elaborate on how the differences between this and the mainstream cosmology are necessarily irreconcilable. But overall, going strictly off the reasoning I've directly seen, I think it's reasonable to split the Divine Creator, Oblivion, and the original characters like the Fallen Stars. I need clarification on what makes the physical cosmology incompatible first.As some of you may understand I have been advocating with Ultima after this tiering system revision was being applied that DeMatteis's story isn't very congruent with the main Cosmology. While authors like Hickman, Ewing, and many others seem to at least follow a certain contunity with their storytelling by incorporating the works of others, that can't really be said for DeMatteis. J.M. DeMatteis usually always writes his story specific to his belief and on story that focuses on “Creation” does it really show.
Thus, this thread is intended to split J.M. DeMatteis's work from the main Marvel continuity and @Ultima_Reality will be in charge of overseeing the change in the main system rating for Marvel after this change.
J.M. DeMatteis heavily focuses on elements that he knows from his journey in life. This is a big example of his “God” character as a being that is not meant to be tied to just the comics, but a holistic fountainhead that is not tethered to just one religion though it's heavily Hindu-based. Now, J.M. DeMatteis writing is very flowery and hard to understand especially when he was experimenting more with the Cosmology. This means some interpretation can be put for these scans.
I would say the entire CRT is a contrast to Cosmology considering the idea of everything being a dream with a dream from God being the conscience that brought it all together.The reasoning here is very brief, and doesn't actually elaborate on how the differences between this and the mainstream cosmology are necessarily irreconcilable. But overall, going strictly off the reasoning I've directly seen, I think it's reasonable to split the Divine Creator, Oblivion, and the original characters like the Fallen Stars. I need clarification on what makes physical cosmology incompatible first.