Its a game which can do only so much to portray a series in the form of gameplay, so giorno moving with him doesnt debunk it at all, afaik you cant independently control the stand and not the user, even with stand out, they still have both perform basic stuff unless its something specific to the stand
It actually does dude, also you really useing ******* ALL STAR BATTLE as your main argument now? Like come the **** on. You want to even bring that up? Then actually use what we see and treat it as it is, don't start inserting a bunch of hypotheticals in play here to suit your argument. The game isn't main canon, it's based on it, but only so far as people at bandai taking their own interpretations on things and trying to make a cool fighter out of that. the notion of GER>MIH is correct, but the why is wrong and the way it plays out isnt the way youre acting like it is, made even worse as your other example you used is a complete 180 of the ASB example, your examples lowkey contradict each other.
Simple, GER resists Fate, nothing else.
And if he did then just means he wasn't fast enough to defend.
Him being superior to MiH in speed in base is even proved from both effortlessly blitzing Diavolo more times and from the fact that he was casual af the whole time.
Did you just say him blitzing a MFTL is proof of him being superior to something literally infinitely above that? That's, not how it works, casual or not. Him blitzing a MFTL will NEVER be Infinite by itself, there needs to be actual supporting evidence, and there is, but said evidence is a 50/50 at best in proving him itself to be infinite and then couple that with an actual example of him not being infinite and then 50/50 becomes a 0 and we know what it refers to now.
Him getting both Resista to Fate Hax due to be able to oppose his pre-written one + infinite speed in base is supported from both Manga and Databook.
It isnt, I'm LOOKING at guide book right, I looked through the scans, I even went through the original japanse manga to see what's said exactly in reference to every single interaction. It's not supported, it's made extremely dubious by the manga and the guides dont clarify.
Not how it works, like it or not, GER was going to be tagged by King Crimson, yes he's way ******* faster, but a Hypersonic+ character can still be hit by a bullet if the bullet started off literally touching them from behind as a surprise, hell, you ever read Flashpoint? That's an example and it's not even as bad as this one but the notion still stands. The infinite base speed is directly CONTRADICTED by the manga and the guidebook just says SOMETHING is infinite, it doesn't say specify and given we know that RTZ>GER and can even act when he can't, and that speed can and has referred to ability speed, why is this even an argument?
The only argument that actually needs to be made is why the Epitaph scene doesnt count, all this other shit doesn't matter, I'd wager to say it's even objectively wrong, and just an fyi, if we give him fate resistance, the only argument I cant think of to say otherwise fails to work. You can't have it both ways here.
Best case scenario is, even if we ignore Epitaph's scene, there's only a 50/50 he scales anyway as said, the scaling doesn't even clarify if it's explicitly his physical speed so best case scenario it's a coin flip, but due to the existence of RTZ outright reacting to something GER couldnt, and seemingly without consent all the while GER has a anti-feat that isn't contradicted by higher feats (because blitzing a dude aint a contradiction to it), I'm inclined to say that, it's likely RTZ being referred to. We went over this early on in the thread, idk why we doing it again.
Best I can do is toss out the planned fate resistance and say at best it's a 50/50, but thinking on it, I'd rather deal with things we know for certain rather then assumptions and guesswork.
