- 4,187
- 1,484
I wonder if the Lord of Chaos is to the Frenzied Flame what the Elden Beast is to the Greater Will.
Last edited:
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I disagree with some of this, but I suppose I'll wait for a thread to argue about whether the flowery language of "shaping the world" is "literally conceptual manipulation bro".
Not who you're replying to, but if I had to rank emDisregarding the feat stuff, how do you like the game so far? Like, out of 10, and compared to other soulsborne games?
DS2 be basedNot who you're replying to, but if I had to rank em
Elden Ring > Sekiro > Dark Souls 2 > Dark Souls 1 > Dark Souls 3
All of them are amazing, and yes, I have shit taste.
For me, it's Elden Ring > Sekiro > Bloodborne > Dark Souls 1 > Dark Souls 3 > Dark Souls 2 > Demon's SoulsNot who you're replying to, but if I had to rank em
Elden Ring > Sekiro > Dark Souls 2 > Dark Souls 1 > Dark Souls 3
All of them are amazing, and yes, I have shit taste.
I am actually planning to get those, since I think both of those are backwards compatible with the PS2.Wow none of you people have played King's Field 1 for the PS1 (The JP-only one not the US King's Field 1 which is actually King's Field 2, not to be confused with King's Field 2, released as King's Field 3 in the west) and you dare to call yourselves Souls fans? Disgusting
HhmmMMM. Well I don't see why the statement should be flowery language, like, there's no reason to be so in first place (plus is something saw in the game). But welp.I disagree with some of this, but I suppose I'll wait for a thread to argue about whether the flowery language of "shaping the world" is "literally conceptual manipulation bro".
I am a King's Field fan, for I too enjoy dying in the first minute of a game.Wow none of you people have played King's Field 1 for the PS1 (The JP-only one not the US King's Field 1 which is actually King's Field 2, not to be confused with King's Field 2, released as King's Field 3 in JP) and you dare to call yourselves Souls fans? Disgusting
Just having a sun-like body in the sky doesn't prove that the world is equal to ours. If we have no reason to assume its different, then yes we could assume it is star-sized. But in this case, we do have a reason to assume it's different since we have seen many "stars" that are very clearly not star-sized.Several spells states how stars are real and are indeed of great scale (see Stars of Ruin for example), and seeing the very sky imply it. The very existence of the sun is enough to prove that the world is equal to ours. Saying that they aren't real stars is actually the biggest assumption one can make here, and funnily enough, there's nothing indicating that the cosmos isn't that big (and something you should need to prove in fact).
Regarding the Radahn stuff, remember that he was holding the stars with gravitational magic, which is clearly related to meteors. Meteors, that holds the same hierarchy of the stars (as stated in the Meteor spell), so that's why the one that fell into the Eternal City was called like that (and from what I remember is was actually called like a falling star). Even so, we still see how there are more stars in the sky besides the ones that fallen, that started to shine after Radahn's defeat.
Stars that I already explained that aren't real stars, but instead, meteorites, so I don't see your point.Just having a sun-like body in the sky doesn't prove that the world is equal to ours. If we have no reason to assume its different, then yes we could assume it is star-sized. But in this case, we do have a reason to assume it's different since we have seen many "stars" that are very clearly not star-sized.
As for Stars of Ruin, all it says is "great star cluster". This can mean many things, and it seems like a leap of logic to assume that "great" means as big as a star when we have literally seen a star fall in the game. For all we know, the size of this "great star cluster" could have just been as big as a city or something.
For more evidence that these "stars" aren't like stars in our own world, there is many references to stars moving. While stars in our own world do move, it seems to me that in this situation they mean stars moving in an astrological sense. Meaning, how the stars move across the sky. In real life, the stars "movement" is actually the Earth's movement changing what we see. In Elden Ring, since Radahn stopped the movement of the stars, it likely means that the stars were quite literally moving around the world. Therefore, they are not real stars, and are something else. This is just speculation, but it's something to think about.
You never proved that they were meteorites and not stars though. You just gave your headcanon that they are actually meteors. The characters called it a star, the lore implies it to be a star, and we see other stars that are not star-sized which supports an object of this size being a star in-universe (like in the nebulas and constellations within the Elden Beast and other bosses). The game very clearly intends the stars to not be star-sized.Stars that I already explained that aren't real stars, but instead, meteorites, so I don't see your point.
The next arguments here are actually based purely on speculations or on the old good "it can mean many things," which by themselves doesn't provide anything real. Again, if you can't provide a real evidence for your claims instead of the falling star (that I already explained) then we can't assume that.
And no the stars irl doesn't move solely for Earth's movement. It also helps in the perspective of the sky, of course, but it doesn't have a direct relationship with the movement itself for the stars (and surprise: the universe is in constant movement)
I mean, even if it's an assumption that one is more consistent with the general lore of the game and many of the statements there. Assumption, that I also explained better honestly. Regarding the nebula stuff... how it proves anything at all? The Elden Beast is basically an embodiment of the Golden Order, so it doesn't have to create within it something of a real scale or anything like that. I don't see the point here (and well I still didn't reached to that part of the game yet so I can't say much). And which other bosses are you talking about? Astel? Because with him the sky of his arena it's directly stated to be false and created by the Greater Will, something pretty different to the real cosmos.You never proved that they were meteorites and not stars though. You just gave your headcanon that they are actually meteors. The characters called it a star, the lore implies it to be a star, and we see other stars that are not star-sized which supports an object of this size being a star in-universe (like in the nebulas and constellations within the Elden Beast and other bosses). The game very clearly intends the stars to not be star-sized.
Of course the universe is in motion, but astrology is based mainly on the movement of the earth.
BumpAnyone know where I'm supposed to go after the Avenue Balcony Grace?
I just want to know where I go after, considering I took two paths that led me to the same area.Where do you want to go exactly?
However, I think you should go downstairs the second ladders iirc
Ahhh okI just want to know where I go after, considering I took two paths that led me to the same area.
Also there's a downstairs area?
Ah, I should have expected there to be at least one tree climbing section.Ahhh ok
Well just go forwards until you saw a big branch in the path. Jump there, and keep ascending. Then you will reach a camera, and the rest I'll leave to you~
A possible interpretation about Radahn holding the stars and holding Ranni's fate is the meteor. We know From Software games have this kind of mysticism.
So, Radahn isn't literally holding Ranni's fate, not like a metaphysical way. He was just blocking her way to Nokron, where she'd need to do her stuff for her ending in the game.Radahn is holding meteorites, and one of them had its direction towards Nokron, where Ranni would like us to go and do some stuff for her, not her fate, but her desire. Radahn isn't literally manipulating her fate but actually not letting Ranni get access to Nokron where she would do her stuff
5-A Downgrade?Rom moving the Moon in Bloodborne wich is bullshit
Barack Obama when he has conceptual manipulation (he changed the world)HhmmMMM. Well I don't see why the statement should be flowery language, like, there's no reason to be so in first place (plus is something saw in the game). But welp.