- 3,395
- 3,199
Battle's still ongoing, but PUI Goku even being comparable to Beast Gohan is not a good sign for Orange Piccolo scaling.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Dragon Ball Super Discussion Thread 100
- Thread starter Warren_Valion
- Start date
- 15,938
- 11,956
Beast Gohan vs Cell Max was using a Special Beam Cannon, that scales above his physicals. Doesn't mean Piccolo can't keep up. He certainly isn't below SSJBKK
- 255
- 90
Cell max couldn't make Gohan flinch, the same Gohan is Equal to MUI Goku so Piccolo definitely doesn't scales to Goku
Eden_Warlock99
She/Her- 10,245
- 3,775
Didn't Beast somewhat struggle with Cell Max in the manga?
- 1,658
- 1,289
Only with that final energy attack, not physically, his aura tanked cell max hits just like the movie
- 255
- 90
Physically ? Not really
Eden_Warlock99
She/Her- 10,245
- 3,775
Nullflowerblush
He/Him- 9,799
- 8,614
- Purification (Type 2; Via Stardust Breaker; Purified the evil Ki within Janemba, destroying Janemba)
- Transmutation-based Energy Purification (Type 2; Converted Omega Shenron's Minus Energy Power Ball into "plus energy" upon contact, thus neutralizing the negative energy that enveloped the planet's atmosphere with its inverse)
- 12,179
- 6,116
I didn't even know type 2 purification existed '-'
- 6,504
- 6,597
I think Piccolo is def stronger than Blue Goku but the way it's shaping up right now and the way I've already felt about it, I doubt he's equal to UI Goku or even on par. I wouldn't use Toriyama statements too credibly. This is the same guy that forgets his own characters existing and some of the most iconic transformations in the series, who literally makes shit up in interviews to explain questions he doesn't have actual answers to all the time. Not saying that any statement Toriyama makes is unusable, but that taking his exact words so literally is probably not wise. "on par" is also pretty vague to begin with and we don't know if the translators were precise.
The way it'd probably go from a narrative standpoint is that Orange Piccolo would give UI Goku some trouble and impress him but still be well below actually managing to beat him or even make him really struggle. Goku'd be like "Wow Piccolo you've really gotten a lot stronger, it's like a whole new you!".
Spinoirr
He/Him- 16,082
- 9,050
I'd say Piccolo is UI Omen level
- 1,658
- 1,289
I mean, in that particular instance, gas fodderized him.
Gas kinda did that against Granolah, don't think they were too far apart?
In their second fight, ot was explained that gas couldn't properly use his new powers which was why granola was able to fight him, once he did get control of his powers with Elec's help, it wasn't much of a fight anymore
Also iirc, a databook stated that in order to completely no sell an attack like that your ki needs to be at least 2x your opponent
Spinoirr
He/Him- 16,082
- 9,050
Honestly
Yeah, also remember TFS has the Xenoverse lets plays as cannon, as Dumplin is popo just in the past
- 3,250
- 2,046
Was that stated in the episodes or anything? At least Low 1-C Popo can be real lol
Should Cell be stronger than Broly in Toei Canon? And should we use guides for multipliers
Spinoirr
He/Him- 16,082
- 9,050
Yeah use the guides for multipliers
Spinoirr
He/Him- 16,082
- 9,050
Mr popo tfs lore goes crazy as hell
Dumplin
Mr. Dumplin Popo (ミスター・ ダンプリン ポポ, Misutā Danpurin Popo) is a Majin Time Patroller created by Team Four Star as their mascot and first created character (after Spudz). He is the main protagonist of their playthrough Dragon Ball Xenoverse and returning protagonist in Xenoverse 2 as the Toki Toki...
teamfourstar.fandom.com
- 1,700
- 683
No, if you do TSF profiles, you should deliberately ignore the guides
The only multipliers used in the Abriged canon are the Ozaru and the Kaioken (up to 4), another Kaioken number is never mentioned, so all multiplier scaling in the Goku vs Frieza battle does not work
There are direct mentions that it does Grade 3, by percentage, then you won't be able to use multipliers at all after the first appearance of Perfect Cell
Come on, anything pre-destruction of the moon by Piccolo will be totally different, because although Roshi's feat probably happened in that canon, it is never mentioned and therefore, it didn't happen (also I think Abriged is much more ambiguous about how much time has passed between every time we see Gohan and Piccolo)
Also changes in feats, the feat for the destruction of the Moon by Piccolo I think is accelerated, the feat for the destruction of the planet Vegeta is the version of Bardock's special and Vegeta has a casual planetary feat thanks to the use of fillers
Star feat in Cooler's movie
There is no mention of destroying a solar system in the battle vs Cell.
We are never told the theme of the quadrants of the universe (we are only told galaxy of), so Broly's feat is probably considered galactic only.
Buu is mentioned directly galactic, but because his saga is covered in shorts, we never see Goku being comparable, making it likely that we can't scale them.
It is implied that the events of Super have passed towards the end, but I doubt we can scale them to this
And a few other minis etc. that make me think that if possible, any scaling that the original medium has does not matter in Abriged, you should only use what Abriged gives you
- 3,250
- 2,046
There's plenty of feats way above solar system level before that point
- 15,938
- 11,956
If you check Joke Battles Wiki, they have Vegeta's scream throughout time as a Tier 2 feat iirc.
- 12,179
- 6,116
This Majin Buu has an extremely scary face '-'Dumplin
Mr. Dumplin Popo (ミスター・ ダンプリン ポポ, Misutā Danpurin Popo) is a Majin Time Patroller created by Team Four Star as their mascot and first created character (after Spudz). He is the main protagonist of their playthrough Dragon Ball Xenoverse and returning protagonist in Xenoverse 2 as the Toki Toki...
- 12,179
- 6,116
I don't think, Broly Toei is said to be Toei's most powerful villain by the screenwriter.
- 3,250
- 2,046
Same writer who says he's Beerus level please
- 12,179
- 6,116
The same writer who gave him multi-galaxy and Universal quotes, lol
- 6,763
- 6,988
Just clarifying:
"Orange Piccolo can keep up with MUI" ≠ "Orange Piccolo is stronger/equal than MUI"
Piccolo could still endure multiple punches from Cell Max
Last edited:
- 6,763
- 6,988
According to Toei itself he ins´t even in the second place
Nullflowerblush
He/Him- 9,799
- 8,614
Same writer who wrote Broly being defeated not only by a weakened Super Saiyan Goku with the energy of weakened, base form Z-Fighters; not only by a combination Kamehameha from Super Saiyan Goku, Gohan, and Goten; not only by a combination Kamehameha from Super Saiyan Goten and Trunks and Krillin; but also off-screen by Goku and Pikkon.
- 2,522
- 2,954
To be FAIR, energy sharing in Toei Continuity gives you an ENORMOUS buff in comparison to your standard power. Like, if I had 5 energy, and then an identical copy of me had only 5 energy, but it was all from someone else, it would be worth an absurdly larger power value of 1000 or something. So SSJ Goku beating Broly with the Energy of the Z-Fighters, while striking him in his gut in the same area he was stabbed as a child, WHILE Broly already claimed his power was so overflowing he needed to release his power to survive before he like, blew the **** up, makes total sense.
And Second Coming Gohan also didn't stop training, so he's at least as strong, if not stronger, than his Cell Saga self and still lost, so that also isn't much of an issue because we genuinely couldn't guess the power they had in that film (same with Goku). Bio-Broly has no excuse, though.
Killerdrone123
He/Him- 2,055
- 1,766
Ki sharing is exponential an energy from weakened and beaten vegeta was enough for goku to transform into ssj blue to fight jiren
- 2,562
- 1,459
I wonder why did they make Goku make a ritual for SSG, if they could've just given energy of SSJ3 Gotenks, Piccolo and Vegeta then to make him reach Beerus tier.
- 321
- 487
Because that would be far from enough to match Beerus.
- 2,562
- 1,459
Supposedly, Broly = Beerus.
BoG Saga Goku + SSJ3 Gotenks, Vegeta and Piccolo energy > Pre-Cell Saga Goku + 3 almost dead ssj punch > Broly > Beerus
BoG Saga Goku + SSJ3 Gotenks, Vegeta and Piccolo energy > Pre-Cell Saga Goku + 3 almost dead ssj punch > Broly > Beerus
Eden_Warlock99
She/Her- 10,245
- 3,775
Nah, Koyama said that Beerus was stronger than Broly
- 2,562
- 1,459
Wait, we're talking about Koyama? The same guy who people purposedly asked questions to wank DB like "Does Afterlife trascend the concept of dimensionality?", "Does DB world have an infinite hierarchy with each one trascending the one below infinitely?", and stated that all his tweets are only his opinion and nothing factual of the show?
- 321
- 487
Even though Beerus should stomp Broly, I don't think we should be using standalone Koyama statements unless they prove the obvious anyway, although it does here.
- 6,763
- 6,988
- 6,763
- 6,988
Tbh that was more of a "Power of Friendship" moment than Vegeta´s actual power, also, Goku needed UI to even harm Jiren
Killerdrone123
He/Him- 2,055
- 1,766
a badly beaten goku who was lying down and can't even walk suddenly had enough energy to go blue just by getting a beaten up vegeta energy I was never implying it was enough to beat jiren ,I don't think it was a power of friendship movement but more so vegeta giving his everything to goku
- 6,763
- 6,988
He got motivated to fight Jiren from seeing Vegeta being eliminated, in the same way he did against the Pretty Black Hole (In relation to his getting motivated)
This was more of a "SSB was useless in this fight tbh" comment not necessarily associated to your comment
Agree to disagree
Similar threads
