Ok, ehhhhhhhhh
Alright, What does she normally start with in a fight?
Maki don't really have much of combat feats, because she never fights people in the game, and when she talks about her past, she don't mention anything regarding combat prowess, she just say how many people she killed, all the weapons she can use(Which is said to be all of them), and she know jiu jutsu and that's it. So like, she don't have a start move.
As a assassin, unless she got a reason, she usually tries to kill people pretty fast. Since I give knowgelement to her about the fact Ayanokoji is stronger and more skilled than her in combat, she most likely gonna shot him with a crossbow from a distance, than gonna go run to her research lab to get the rest of her weapons.
I mean, grenades have pretty much just a 10-20-meter range, meaning that Ayanokouji cannot only escape them via AnPr, but he can also escape the detonation range quite easily.
It depends, If like, the grenade have a time detonation of 10 seconds, and Maki trows the thing far from where he is, i can see he escaping.
But since grenades don't take that long to explode, and Maki is not stupid and knows how to aim, even if Ayanokoji sees the grenade coming, he not gonna escape the blatius range unscatched. Even if don't kill him right away, is still gonna demage him severely. She also have bombs that can turn 5 story building into a 4 story too by controling the explosion, so she can also wipe a whole floor if she wants.
About escaping the bullets, Ayanokouji does have the knowledge of Maki, which would allow him to use his AnPr against Maki without doing the analysis which he does in the fight.
How does that help in anyway to escape bullets, even if he knows her talent, dodging bullets is still super difficult, even with aim dodging. Like, she don't have just a pistol, she also have assaults rifles, if ayanokoji don't have cover, he kinda screwed. And even with cover, she can just trow a bomb on him to make him get away.
Because considering she ain't that smart, Koji can bait her into any traps he wants
When did you take she is not that smart, she totally is, she not the Ultimate Assassin, like the best assassin of the world, without being smart, she not gonna fail for a basic trap, and in the game she usually pretty sharp with noticing how a crime can occur. And what kinda bait Ayanokoji gonna do anyway? As i said, she usually don't take chance, if she don't know where Ayanokoji is, she gonna bomb the whole floor with a bomb. If Ayanokoji hiding somewhere, is better be way closer to her.
He can conceal his presence which Maki has no response to which in turn Koji has (Koji knew Kushida and Ichika were following him without even looking and can sense presences)
Koji can also tase her while also concealing his presence
True, I can see how he wins by doing this. Les't see, when she runs to get her weapons, Ayanokoji can follow behind her to attack while he conceal his presence. But they start 50 meters apart, and following someone that far, while being in this maze of a school, and Maki knows the school, while Ayano don't, so she could dismiss him by going into hiding. Ayano could also found her depending where she hides, since most room lands to closed places. Maki does know about the secret passages in the bathroom and in the libraly, so she could go there to escape from him, and run to her Lab.
How far would be the research lab from their initial positions?
The lab is in the third floor, and they are in the first.
Do they start when they are facing and aware of each other's positions?
Yes, SBA.
And the biggest question, can Ayanokouji ultimately get to the research lab and get all her weapons and use it for himself?
No? First, i doubt Ayanokoji can use even use 90% of the stuff there proficient like Maki, so that useless. If he tries to use a weapon there, he gonna get killed.
Second, he don't actually know about what's in the research lab. He have a map, and the map does tell the name of the rooms in the floor, but he not gonna know what's inside the lab if he don't go there, so he kinda don't have a reason to go there.
AP and LS - Useless, They are fighting with weapons
Not really, since Ayano can break things that she can't.
Like, doors, if Maki tries to run into a room and close the door, Ayano can open that shit super easy.
He can conceal his presence to attack her from blind spots to which she has no response to
She can go in the Courtyard, and Ayano would need to get out by the front door or the other side door, since is the only exits, and she could ambush him there. Since he can't go invisible, manting his eyes on him is a thing she can do.
Easily Koji, He will strategize, Create traps using forniture or anything he can get his hands on, He can bait and lure her into any place he wants,
She probally gonna explode the whole floor with a bomb if Ayano waste time to make traps.
If anything Koji can also Social influence her into tricking her which shouldn't be too hard for him considering she can be easily manipulated
She probally not gonna listen, she usually don't hear people out if she don't knows them, the only people she got tricked by are her friends, people she trust, and Kokichi.
I do agree he have big IQ, but basic traps not gonna work on her, especially when he does't know the school so well to make so many traps.
Anyway, Ayano can win if he sneaks up on him, and Maki can win if she gets her weapons.