- 2,941
- 1,409
hi
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 4,128
- 4,351
UeTa
She/Her- 426
- 569
- 2,280
- 1,850
- 8,154
- 4,141
You guys peep the sketches in the background
Looks like flying garou from last chapter
UeTa
She/Her- 426
- 569
You guys peep the sketches in the background
- "Feathered version of Garou"
You even see the wings on the sketches. So either that or Garou next form have wings too.
- 4,128
- 4,351
im looking at the legs, the background sketch has tong like legs which is why i assumed it to be differentThis is probably just gargoyle's Garou in the background that he uses as a reference for his clay bust.
- "Feathered version of Garou"
You even see the wings on the sketches. So either that or Garou next form have wings too.
- 22,476
- 18,726
And what does a drawing tell you? Do we see them red and blue-shifting. Not really. The best we have is Tatsumaki's spear being green, but that's obviously her psychic powers.
Honestly, this should simply be the reason why we keep the statements as possibly ratings rather than removing them outright.
He outright expressed that it's just his opinion many times in both statements.
- That's what I think. (he repeats this several times)
- Well... I drew it with the thought that it is right, but I don’t know whether the thought is the same with ONE sensei’s official setting.
Also, you could apply this logic to anything because he doesn't always say this. The fact is, he blanketed the opinion statement over all his past claims that weren't directly supported by ONE, and this is one of those statements.
What he's referring to here is the setting he based his drawings on.
- Geryuganshoop's psychokinesis can eliminate the friction between objects and air, the rocks will fly at sub-light speed*, that's the setting I based my drawing on.
- Well... I drew it with the thought that it is right, but I don’t know whether the thought is the same with ONE sensei’s official setting. Anyway, I draw enemies as powerful as possible when they appear, so there is a possibility that I overstated him a bit more than ONE sensei’s setting, so at the time I drew the Geryuganshoop’s pebble throwing, I wanted him to be more powerful than her in some way.
Those don't look the same at all. Tatsumaki's beams aren't glowing, they're just straight lines, and even the straight lines don't remotely group together. Not to mention, Geryu's aren't surrounded by a star-shaped psychic aura across their flight time.
Even if they did look the same, they explicitly aren't at all supposed to. Gery's aren't supposed to generate friction, and Tastumaki's rocks are supposed to evaporate before ever reaching similar speeds.
- If Tatsumaki throws rocks like he does, her output will be too powerful, the temperature increase due to friction and pressure, and evaporate the rocks in an instant.
UeTa
She/Her- 426
- 569
No? You just ignored the question the guys asked to Murata before he say that :
Q: "So the pebble throwing of Geryganshoop is stronger than Tatsumaki’s?"
A: "Well... I drew it with the thought that it is right, but I don’t know whether the thought is the same with ONE sensei’s official setting. Anyway, I draw enemies as powerful as possible when they appear, so there is a possibility that I overstated it a bit more than ONE sensei’s setting, so at the time I drew the Geryuganshoop’s pebble throwing, I wanted it to be more powerful than her in some way."
That's what he said. And it was in Japanese. Stronger could have mean "better", "greater". Many things in those cases. Also, they were talking about a "pebble".
(Also, his setting DID make it in the manga anyways. And ONE knows about it and didn't ask any redrawn or anything (which he did for many fights: Boros vs. Saitama, vs Orochi, the tons of Pheonix man fight)
So yeah, he just tho back then (and so ONE to a point, just look at all the interviews) that Tatsumaki was not that strong. But we can clearly see that current Tatsumaki can perform similar attack speed feats. Except if you totally negs his statements about the pressure augmenting and rock evaporating in an instant. (Which if you do, just prove my point)
- 22,476
- 18,726
I'm not ignoring it, it's just that he's also talking about they way he drew it and the different settings.
Again, his setting made it in a way that's not actually indicative of speed. From a canonical aspect, this also has no bearing.
In what way does that negate my statement? If anything, it just completely and utterly annihilates yours in every capacity because Murata's beliefs are contradicted by the source material.
Again, his setting made it in a way that's not actually indicative of speed. From a canonical aspect, this also has no bearing.
In what way does that negate my statement? If anything, it just completely and utterly annihilates yours in every capacity because Murata's beliefs are contradicted by the source material.
UeTa
She/Her- 426
- 569
Meh, I'll guess the langage barrier hit me on this one. :/
- 22,476
- 18,726
- 2,673
- 2,260
Here it isOk, so I looked through every frame I could with higher resolution than what the calcer used.
I checked if he moves faster over time or in one part of a frame, and the absolute most he ever moves in the shortest amount of time (as well as faster than any overall amount of time, naturally) is 703.025 m/s. And that was assuming it was 4 px, even though 5 px (meaning 562.42 m/s) is far more common even for the upper body.
This gets 0.971321977215 megatons, which increases to just under 3.9 megatons if we assume each portion of the carapace is 2 pixels.
Here's the pictures. The red line on EC's body in the second image is 5 px, while the blue line below it is 2 px.
Big Note: Remember, while the distance is much shorter, this is happening in a space of time 30x lower than what the calcer used. If he moved this entire speed for half a second, EC would have literally passed former position to the edge of the panel 4.5x over, meaning he'd be out of sight in the first 7 frames at 60 fps.
I'm calling bs.
- 26,436
- 30,769
I get the feeling Murata may make Garou look like Devilman
- 26,436
- 30,769
- 7,897
- 3,859
Unrelated but I went to check the reddit to see if any post was made about this and smurf dude announced he’s been working on licensed statues of opm with Murata’s approval. Kinda interesting, to me at least.
- 16,968
- 11,315
Oh God, I hope that it will be Final Form Garou, and then, he uses his moveset like his WC version did against Saitama
Murata is working on Garou's 3D model.It seems the rumors about slim final form Garou were true.
- 7,897
- 3,859
Probably just rumors from people who dont favor him.
I think season 3 is highly possible it will probably be done by the same guys who did season 2.
- 199
- 234
Platinum Sperm Monster Garou
Murata is working on Garou's 3D model.It seems the rumors about slim final form Garou were true.
- 8,868
- 9,552
The calc is 5-B+ btw so if the high end gets accepted then we could potentially get 5-A.
- 23,409
- 21,143
This page
https://cdn.**********.com/attachments/865400122136854539/970578823227785266/unknown.png
- 2,673
- 2,260
The high-high end is roughly 1.6x away from 5-A. Saitama definitely upscales but moderators might not accept it
- 16,272
- 24,976
Pretty sure there was already a long discussion on that page’s translation
- 8,868
- 9,552
Even better. It only benefits Saitama to have an AP advantage in the majority of match ups.
Last edited:
- 23,409
- 21,143
Can you send the thread it was discussed in? Also, someone else translated it.
The thing that was translated was the Manga statement from Boros, saying he would explicitly destroy the surface of the Earth. I've never seen this brought up.
- 16,272
- 24,976
From Boros’ page. The databook isn’t new info
- 3,414
- 2,489
And since the calc is 5-B, it's consistent
UeTa
She/Her- 426
- 569
Oh there a calc already?
Similar threads
