-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 12,034
- 15,550
No there really isn't. Saying context without evidence doesn't mean anything.
There is nothing factual here, Boros was impressive via regeneration. Saitama would've killed him or caused fatal damage to him with his first punch out of the armor, and even with the armor and regen he could've one shotted him with zero effort at anytime. Saitama himself even states there isn't anyone he can't beat in one punch.
Trying to scale characters to each other via Saitama is a bad call. Because someone needs to provide proof that if Saitama fought someone as strong as Boros again, he'd actually call them strong and wouldn't just be bored out of his mind and treat them like a joke like he did Orochi.
If Boros had happen first, then no duh he'd be stronger for wiki scaling. But right now this scaling is speculation, no factual evidence or 100% certainty in anything.
He isn't thinking about Boros, and someone of Boros' strength would bore him in the same situation he fought Orochi in as well. Because they're all nothing compared to himself. Can someone actually provide proof that Saitama wouldn't be bored, even though he can effortlessly one shot both of them?
This is all speculation, and the fact that people don't want Orochi>Boros. Which I understand, I don't think that makes sense either. But personal opinion doesn't mean much in terms of scaling on this wiki.
There is nothing factual here, Boros was impressive via regeneration. Saitama would've killed him or caused fatal damage to him with his first punch out of the armor, and even with the armor and regen he could've one shotted him with zero effort at anytime. Saitama himself even states there isn't anyone he can't beat in one punch.
Trying to scale characters to each other via Saitama is a bad call. Because someone needs to provide proof that if Saitama fought someone as strong as Boros again, he'd actually call them strong and wouldn't just be bored out of his mind and treat them like a joke like he did Orochi.
If Boros had happen first, then no duh he'd be stronger for wiki scaling. But right now this scaling is speculation, no factual evidence or 100% certainty in anything.
He isn't thinking about Boros, and someone of Boros' strength would bore him in the same situation he fought Orochi in as well. Because they're all nothing compared to himself. Can someone actually provide proof that Saitama wouldn't be bored, even though he can effortlessly one shot both of them?
This is all speculation, and the fact that people don't want Orochi>Boros. Which I understand, I don't think that makes sense either. But personal opinion doesn't mean much in terms of scaling on this wiki.
- 26,423
- 30,748
Did anyone fix the hollowness on that Boros ship calc?
I think we've discussed before on why hollowness being 90 percent is nonsensical
I think we've discussed before on why hollowness being 90 percent is nonsensical
- 2,280
- 1,850
In my above points I already discussed why I think the scaling is valid.
- 8,997
- 9,728
Not yet. But 90% hollowness is definitely nonsense
- 8,997
- 9,728
Boros doesn't use his regeneration at all until his right arm was smashed off by Saitama, and even then he continues fighting for a long time before actually regenerating. Saitama called Boros strong after experiencing his true power and before his regeneration. In the entire fight, Boros is only shown using his regeneration twice.
I'm still not entirely convinced that all of the current Boros and Garou statements are not applicable, but maybe that's just me
I don't see how this is a bored face
Last edited:
- 12,034
- 15,550
Can someone explain why that means he scales to Orochi beyond personal opinion/speculation.
Can anyone provide in universe factual evidence?
- 12,034
- 15,550
I have no intention of changing OPM stats.
This is merely me explaining my dissatisfaction with the current scaling. If you have an issue with me talking about this subject you can tell me if I'm not allowed to speak of it. I wouldn't want to cause any problems between users either, so if this is causing problems please tell me. I don't mind not bringing the subject up again if there is an issue.
If I'm allowed to speak of this, and it doesn't bother you, I don't see why you'd have to response to me. So I'm certain I'm causing some kind of issue for you.
I do not mean to cause issues or trouble, my apologies if I was bothering anyone.
- 2,280
- 1,850
Saitama looked shcoked at MB boros, he lands more hits, Boros is called strong multiple times, and keeps up with and surpasses normal Saitama throughout their fight. He is casually above Gery, Melz, and Gror in his armored form, who had a slim chance of beating Orochi working together, a weaker Garou who is not comparable to Boros is able to dodge some of Orochi's attacks. Saitama did not think Orochi was the monster king, but rather the monster rince, and called him a child. Saying he was just powerful enough to vent some anger. Even thougn much larger, his body is torn to shreds by normal punches, and his Gae Canon is countered by a serious squirt gun, a weaker attack than a serious punch.
- 12,034
- 15,550
Disagree, I do not see how that relates to any scaling whatsoever as explained above.
However I'll drop the topic. As I do not want to cause issues or any arguments for something I'm not fighting for.
However I'll drop the topic. As I do not want to cause issues or any arguments for something I'm not fighting for.
- 8,997
- 9,728
To be fair, Gyoro Gyoro did tell Orochi not to kill Garou, so Orochi was somewhat holding back in the fight
- 2,280
- 1,850
But not wanting to kill would not be a reason to not use your full speed. I understand the point though.
I think you have some good points, I enjoy the discussion. Don't feel pressured into stopping if you don't want to.
Although I do think the facts I just provided give multiple scaling avenues which place Boros a notch or two above Orochi.
- 435
- 266
Actually there would be a reason since we learn that orochi had been purposefully concealing his strength
- 2,280
- 1,850
I will concede on that point then, but the Gery, Mel, and Gror scaling, Saitama being shocked at MB Boros's speed/attacks, Orochi's far larger body being shreded by normal punches, a clearly weaker serious move being used, Saitama calling him the Monster Prince and a child, and Boros' unleashed form almost matching a casual saitama, and Saitama calling Boros strong all put him above Orochi.
- 6,774
- 3,686
So that's your suggestion ? We accepting stuff based on offsite users believing on it ? That was never the case, and even then, the CRTs were closed, it's not 100% rejected, it's on stand by until the next fight is over
- 13,154
- 4,811
i don't mean that they get too complicated with something that is simpler to understand, saitama did all that effortlessly
- 13,154
- 4,811
Bro everyone know that
- 8,874
- 5,709
- 13,154
- 4,811
I love when I do something unusual, because I feel like I'm unique, and stupid, and unique proceeds to get into a warehouse with a lot of papers and one of them ismurata says seriously
- 13,154
- 4,811
hell I stole the kill
- 8,874
- 5,709
he says I don't know. that implies nothing like you say.
- 13,154
- 4,811
It's a 'I don't know' I don't know who could win, if Saitama or Goku
- 16,286
- 17,800
“I don’t know” doesn’t mean they’re even, it just means that he doesn’t know.
- 6,034
- 2,797
Theendzero13
He/Him- 2,785
- 1,331
you created WW5 buddy , for real though i will take a look
- 6,774
- 3,686
Even if he said with all the words "Saitama defeats Goku" that would mean nothing as he is no authority for Dragon Ball characters, and we don't know how much he knows (and scales) Goku
Even One's quote about Tatsumaki Vs Mob was rejected
Even One's quote about Tatsumaki Vs Mob was rejected
I think it's a matter of standard procedure, no character would've been upgraded for a higher Tier with a battle right at the corner, and there's the fact that not everyone consider Saitama's current case as simple, there's room for debate
- 2,280
- 1,850
Why tf was that? He made both series, he knows better than any of us...
- 13,154
- 4,811
wait saitama shouldn't have the same abilities as garou,like fast leerning or copy
- 540
- 867
From Tatsumaki's profile: "Please do not attempt to scale Mob to Tatsumaki or vice versa. The statement from ONE about this is old and outdated, and both characters have since gained very different levels of feats in terms of both speed and strength."
- 13,154
- 4,811
It is like saying that you contradict the author if there is a way for him to contradict himself, when he does not contradict himself, we are only looking for an excuse for contradiction
- 16,286
- 17,800
Tbf it was rejected for the manga, it could potentially be usable for the webcomic.
Similar threads
