-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 26,437
- 30,771
1. Star level Boros is wrong
2. The anime isn't different enough to justify separate profiles unlike the webcomic.
- 22,476
- 18,726
They aren't the same. There's way different feats and different scaling. For example, Saitama's punch stopped the rain, and Mumen Rider withstood the shockwave from a few metres, which would make even the weakest B-Class 8-C.
Boros' attack is just another very good example. It's only stated to be surface wiping in the manga, but Boros explicitly says it'd destroy the planet in the anime.
Plus, Boros doesn't really even melt his ship with his speed alone in the manga.
They're differently mediums with vastly different feats.
Where are you even getting that they're the same? Can you provide a quote or interview statement?
Edit: I'm now convinced that I should make an anime sandbox for the profiles.
Boros' attack is just another very good example. It's only stated to be surface wiping in the manga, but Boros explicitly says it'd destroy the planet in the anime.
Plus, Boros doesn't really even melt his ship with his speed alone in the manga.
They're differently mediums with vastly different feats.
Where are you even getting that they're the same? Can you provide a quote or interview statement?
Edit: I'm now convinced that I should make an anime sandbox for the profiles.
Last edited:
- 26,437
- 30,771
Eh, I proposed it before but it was rejected. I'm really unsure if the anime truly deserves it, but if the majority agrees, I can help with it.
- 5,167
- 2,765
I don't mind the idea of there being profiles for the anime but I do believe that it shouldn't just differ in statistics but also have differences in the plot or abilities, so if there is anime-only content that can be used for those purposes to a sufficient degree it should be fine.
- 26,437
- 30,771
I'd say the webcomic has more than enough material for us to work with
- 26,437
- 30,771
Yeah this was the main point for rejection last time.
- 1,984
- 1,236
The one where Genos talks about EC's strength. The controversial panel.
- 5,167
- 2,765
Yeah, I do recall there being a thread for that.
- 22,476
- 18,726
There's some difference in plot and abilities, but it's marginal.
Edit: I tried, but I genuinely just don't have the effort.
Here.
Last edited:
- 6,072
- 2,846
What does he say about it?
- 1,984
- 1,236
That was what Therefir said, but he also said it was a rough translation so I wanted to make sure the statement was properly translated.
- 4,526
- 3,289
Boros didn’t melt anything with his speed in the anime either. It was his energy.
- 4,526
- 3,289
How much force did Garou have to leap off Sage’s antennae to cut his entire body in half without losing momentum?
- 8,155
- 4,141
Anime is separate canon, in an interview one confirmed he gave madhouse creative control to make changes. Just don't blur Saitama's character.
- 8,997
- 9,728
Yeah, that looks cool
- 10,201
- 9,957
Redraw time.
Last edited:
- 8,155
- 4,141
He comments on Orochi, this should be interesting.
- 334
- 309
Redraw of the saitama vs orochi redraw when?
- 8,155
- 4,141
Idk if it that lol
- 16,286
- 17,801
Redraw it back to the way it was before
- 22,747
- 23,481
Looks like a lot of the scary Nyan pictures were removed from those chapters.
The other kid also got like, his more sadistic scenes removed for some reason
- 8,155
- 4,141
Yeah probably some character(personality) retcons. Although the a class vs nyan was nice in the original.
- 4,388
- 3,346
They didn't want everyone to despise Waganma since he's the whole reason for the operation. I recall Murata stating how surprised he was by the strong negative reaction to the character.
And Nyan panels you're thinking about have been changed, yes. We went from this to this for example, and this to this
- 10,201
- 9,957
Nyan reflecting back One-Shotter's bullet was also censored, weird.
- 22,747
- 23,481
lol. "Why does everyone find this sadistic jerk of a child unlikeable???"
I don't know if it was censored or just cut for space. Murata has a "bad habit" of drawing out actions longer than needed, which can effect a printing in a major way. Its why he had to go back and redo all of the flipbook chapters in the first 40 chapters besides the serious punch.
EmilioRory10
He/Him- 941
- 1,131
this is the monster that will push Garou to his awakening
https://media.**********.net/attachments/833163034414940196/947177250879594496/unknown.png
https://media.**********.net/attachments/833163034414940196/947177250879594496/unknown.png
- 4,388
- 3,346
who is this "Lucas" you speak of?
EmilioRory10
He/Him- 941
- 1,131
it's from an AI generated sonic script
- 2,500
- 1,248
Opinions on the new redraws? Personally I like them, even the minor ones added to the Tats Vs Psykos fight with Tats and Amai.
Overall, imo, the Nyan Vs A class fight also was alot better despite already being good prior to the redraws anyways (and it looks like Gearsper could get upgraded depending on what the tornado he made could get).
Overall, imo, the Nyan Vs A class fight also was alot better despite already being good prior to the redraws anyways (and it looks like Gearsper could get upgraded depending on what the tornado he made could get).
- 6,775
- 3,686
Someone posted a link for the redraws ? Dunno why but sometimes I unfollow the thread out of nowhere >_>
Similar threads
