• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!

Tetsucabrah said:
Wait how does it not scale to his durability?
He sucked up the energy himself and funneled it through his body.

If he was way weaker than that the KE would destroy him.
Click to expand...
I mean by that logic we'd be scaling CSRC to Boros, and we don't
 
Out of curiosity what would happen if ONE said Boros would stop the Gaia cannon with a punch?
We're arbitrarily gimping Boros because "he can't be stronger" than the likely lowballed values we're giving his ultimate attack.
 
Tetsucabrah said:
Honestly Saitama did still treat Orochi like a joke in the original.
He even didn't even contemplate that he could've been the monster king he was looking for later on in the arc.
Click to expand...
I mean in the sense of Orochi not even being treated as a Monster.

Saitama barely acknowledges his presence or intent to harm him, treats Orochi like some kind of poorly behaved home-owner, and cancels out his strongest attack (which is calced to apparently be the strongest shown attack in the series) by literally squirting some water or magma towards it. At least in the original Saitama barely talks and can understand that Orochi is a full fledged Monster that he needs to kill, and there's none of that ridiculous bath tub nonsense.
 
Tetsucabrah said:
Out of curiosity what would happen if ONE said Boros would stop the Gaia cannon with a punch?
We're arbitrarily gimping Boros because "he can't be stronger" than the likely lowballed values we're giving his ultimate attack.
Click to expand...
Then I guess take his word for it.
 
Tetsucabrah said:
Out of curiosity what would happen if ONE said Boros would stop the Gaia cannon with a punch?
We're arbitrarily gimping Boros because "he can't be stronger" than the likely lowballed values we're giving his ultimate attack.
Click to expand...
Word of God (Especially when applied to a top tier whose strength was largely undemonstrated)>>>This feat and previously determined scaling.
 
RinneItachi said:
Why would he lie about Boros being impressive when Boros can't even hear him? He said it in space and to Genos. He was lying about it being a close fight and Saitama himself having a good time, not about Boros being a genuinely powerful opponent.

Saitama says directly that he can't tell how strong most people are due to the gap between them. Like how he has no idea how strong Gouketsu was, because to Saitama, Gouketsu was fodder. Saitama generally only calls people strong when they can impressive. Another main example is with Awakened Garou. After Garou attacks him, Saitama specifically says that he can tell Garou is strong, immediately noting that Garou isn't like most other opponents. With Orochi, Saitama never addressed his strength even remotely. Hell, in the original version it was somewhat similar, he didn't treat Orochi like a joke, but Saitama said that he doesn't care about Orochi's title nor how strong Orochi thinks he is, and in the end he still kills him effortlessly without regarding Orochi as a strong opponent. I doubt Saitama could've used the same old Normal Punch to cancel out CSRC. I'm not saying the Serious Punch was his full power or even necessarily close to it, but Saitama did not view Boros as another random opponent, that much is undeniable.
Click to expand...
What would you say the minimum percentage of Saitama's full power Boros would scale to, 1% or 0.1%?

What if God gives a say, 3-C feat and Saitama beats him handily? If Boros is 0.1% of Saitama's full strength, he'll be either 3-C or very high end 4-A. It's all high speculation but my perspective on Boros's importance is entirely speculative- I judge him based upon where he falls in the grand scheme of things in OPM, and though we don't know everything we do know that God should be tiers above the earth cutter and therefore probably tiers above CSRC.

If Saitama was able to tell how strong Boros was but couldn't with Gouketsu that means that Boros was somewhat in his league and Gouketsu wasn't. Boros being in Saitama's league puts a cap on Saitama's possible strength that Boros himself would argue is illegitimate.

Alternatively, we can say that Boros's strength far surpassed any opponent Saitama had seen up until that point and Saitama was able to note the difference. Saitama isn't a complete idiot so he doesn't necessarily need to be comparable in strength to make that judgment. Likewise he can still admire Boros's strength relative to others and convey that to Genos as a token of respect to an opponent who worked hard to get where he was and really became one of the strongest.
 
I'm tired of arguments like we shouldn't just wait for non-existent hypotheticals like "what if the author says so". They haven't, and it's also possible that they don't mention it or outright deny such possibilities.

That being said, Garou is probably going to surpass Orochi.
 
Let's say Awakened Garou happens to scale above Orochi's Gaia whatever, would that mean Boros can't scale since his physicals would scale above an attack stronger than his CSRC which is meant to be much stronger than himself lol?
 
SemiRaedi said:
Let's say Awakened Garou happens to scale above Orochi's Gaia whatever, would that mean Boros can't scale since his physicals would scale above an attack stronger than his CSRC which is meant to be much stronger than himself lol?
Click to expand...
No
 
SemiRaedi said:
Let's say Awakened Garou happens to scale above Orochi's Gaia whatever, would that mean Boros can't scale since his physicals would scale above an attack stronger than his CSRC which is meant to be much stronger than himself lol?
Click to expand...
The current CSRC calcs are a little lowballed, so it's not necessarily a contradiction.

The problem I have with default scaling Boros above this is that we need to agree that Boros is definitely above Orochi for narrative reasons and not solely on the old AG Boros statement. That statement was made years ago, back when most of these feats had not been thought up by Murata or ONE. Hell, this new feat probably wasn't even planned until sometime last year when ONE decided to start the redraws, so the scaling chain definitely didn't exist when the statement was made.
 
Tetsucabrah said:
If we're just going to be hesitant to scale Boros to new feats that's fine.
I just don't like the logic in artificially capping Boros at a certain value and saying "he can never scale to anything above this"
Click to expand...
Agreed.

What I would like is a new statement about Garou and Boros. If we get that statement, I'm all for low 5-B Boros.
 
Tetsucabrah said:
Out of curiosity what would happen if ONE said Boros would stop the Gaia cannon with a punch?
We're arbitrarily gimping Boros because "he can't be stronger" than the likely lowballed values we're giving his ultimate attack.
Click to expand...
Pretty sure it would be called death of author
 
Ourosboros said:
The current CSRC calcs are a little lowballed, so it's not necessarily a contradiction.

The problem I have with default scaling Boros above this is that we need to agree that Boros is definitely above Orochi for narrative reasons and not solely on the old AG Boros statement. That statement was made years ago, back when most of these feats had not been thought up by Murata or ONE. Hell, this new feat probably wasn't even planned until sometime last year when ONE decided to start the redraws, so the scaling chain definitely didn't exist when the statement was made.
Click to expand...
Yeah, personally I don't really like using the older statements from Murata considering the fact that he was probably stating them from the pov that the manga is done similar to the webcomic which obviously isn't the case.

I know for sure that people on the Reddit will scale Golden Sperm to Orochi's Gaia to make Golden Sperm stronger than Psykorochi
 
Ourosboros said:
What would you say the minimum percentage of Saitama's full power Boros would scale to, 1% or 0.1%?

What if God gives a say, 3-C feat and Saitama beats him handily? If Boros is 0.1% of Saitama's full strength, he'll be either 3-C or very high end 4-A. It's all high speculation but my perspective on Boros's importance is entirely speculative- I judge him based upon where he falls in the grand scheme of things in OPM, and though we don't know everything we do know that God should be tiers above the earth cutter and therefore probably tiers above CSRC.

If Saitama was able to tell how strong Boros was but couldn't with Gouketsu that means that Boros was somewhat in his league and Gouketsu wasn't. Boros being in Saitama's league puts a cap on Saitama's possible strength that Boros himself would argue is illegitimate.

Alternatively, we can say that Boros's strength far surpassed any opponent Saitama had seen up until that point and Saitama was able to note the difference. Saitama isn't a complete idiot so he doesn't necessarily need to be comparable in strength to make that judgment. Likewise he can still admire Boros's strength relative to others and convey that to Genos as a token of respect to an opponent who worked hard to get where he was and really became one of the strongest.
Click to expand...
Minimum as in the least amount I think he would've used? Cause idk. I'm not trying to apply specific numbers to the gap between them. There is still a huge gap, but what I doubt is saying Saitama could deflect CSRC into space by breathing too hard.

This is all reaching deep into speculation and doesn't really effect the actual narrative implications that Boros was someone Saitama considered impressive. And again, Saitama considered Boros a powerful foe whereas he didn't ever comment on Orochi's strength, not even when it comes to the Gaia Cannon, that alone suggests Boros is still meant to be stronger than Orochi even with his most powerful attack.

Just because it puts a cap on his strength doesn't mean it isn't true. Yeah, he could show feats massively above High 6-A or even massively above planet level, but we literally don't know. Boros only said that Saitama was still holding back and that it wasn't a real fight, that doesn't mean he thinks Saitama was a million times stronger than him. Even a 10x difference can create a one-sided mismatch.

Yet Boros genuinely surprised Saitama on multiple occasions (I'd even say "shocked" with Meteoric Burst) and was regarded to be almost a real fight. Whereas in every other instance of Saitama encountering someone in the entire series, including Orochi himself, he doesn't once say that they're strong, apart from Garou of course. In fact, that brings me to the next point. Boros and Garou are still narratively meant to be the 2 strongest villains thus far (apart from God most likely), and likewise, they're the only villains to make Saitama note that they're strong and different from the rest (also likewise, they're the only ones to last after or even counter his attacks). It seems to be a theme that these near but not confirmed God level foes are the ones that make Saitama impressed. The fact that Orochi isn't one of them means he's still below Boros and Garou.
 
SemiRaedi said:
Yeah, personally I don't really like using the older statements from Murata considering the fact that he was probably stating them from the pov that the manga is done similar to the webcomic which obviously isn't the case.

I know for sure that people on the Reddit will scale Golden Sperm to Orochi's Gaia to make Golden Sperm stronger than Psykorochi
Click to expand...
 
Will Tatsumaki and Gyoro Gyoro/Psykos need a redraw too since Psykos getting absorbed by Orochi will be different? I'm a fan of the esper characters getting new additions, maybe Tatsumaki will show off new hax against Psykos since she definitely won't do any big feats inside the MA base.

If Psykos can shoot eye beams and control gravity then surely a superior esper can do other cool stuff too
 
What if Psykorochi absorbed the entire core of the Earth and fired it at Tatsumaki, who proceeds to no diff the attack and instantly fix the planet with a flick of her wrist.
 
Saitama flies across the universe at absurdly high MFTL+ speeds and throws countless millions of galaxies at Garou, who effortlessly destroys them, commenting that such small objects is no more than house dust to him now.
 
Ourosboros said:
You know what though guys? Even if you didn't like the redraw, you can't deny that it's overnight revived interest in this thread. We have enough material to keep chatting for weeks.
Click to expand...
I liked it. I think it gave Orochi more personality.
Also all I really wanted from the redraws was more Orochi backstory and that's what I got.
 
On a serious note I think that some of these upgrades aren't really necessary lol, while I doubt Murata was thinking that he was in the process of drawing the strongest attack in the series (besides serious water gun) I feel like apart from shock value it doesn't add much.

If Saitama took the Gaia beam seriously (idk like thinking that the beam would destroy his home) then it would feel alright but it seems a bit random and sad for Orochi to get spiked up in power just to get "magma GG" by Saitama downplaying the attack.

If Psykorochi (or anyone else) gets upgraded (which I personally don't think is necessary) then I hope the attack has some meaning behind it besides just being a bigger cool laser that surprises Tatsumaki.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

EnderLord8
STRONGEST One-Punch Man (Anime version) Discussion Thread
2
Replies
64
Views
8K
Anonymous_Learner
Anonymous_Learner
Recon1511
One Punch Man: Major Timeframe Upgrade
2
Replies
61
Views
8K
Raiden38
Raiden38
Lightning_XXI
Flash Vs Psykos & Gouketsu (OPM)
Replies
2
Views
1K
Recon1511
Recon1511
Farfetchedx
One Punch Man: Mid Tiers Scaling Revision
Replies
29
Views
4K
XSOULOFCINDERX
XSOULOFCINDERX
LIFE_OF_KING
  • Locked
One Punch Man - Willpower is weird
2
Replies
66
Views
8K
LephyrTheRevanchist
LephyrTheRevanchist
Back
Top