- 5,107
- 1,786
(No, I'm not back)
It has come to my attention (repeatedly the past couple weeks, nonstop) that the One Piece profiles have undergone some major revisions, and that the scaling has been tampered with to use/dismiss calculations that have either been debunked, edited, or simply ignored.
Time to put my input.
Planet Size
Stick with EARTH size until we get confirmation, better scaling, or EoS content that shows how big the OP planet actually is.
Subject over.
Whitebeard Quakes
I'm keeping this one short:
Again with this?? Really? I'm pretty certain that this calculation has been debunked over several reasons. The most prominent ones being an assumed time-frame and an assumed distance, rendering the entire calculation null. (and while the distance CAN be argued for due to the map drawing in other chapters, the scaling of the map comes from yet another assumed speed of the boats utilized by the marines, making it shaky at best)
We see an island of unknown location hit by what seems to be at least 4.0 richter scale quakes after Whitebeard lands an attack on Vice Admiral Lonz. Here's where the issue lies.
To keep it concise, this feat can easily be argued as a High 7-A feat just as easily as it can be argued to be a 6-A feat. There's is a severe lack of information here, thus the calculation, AGAIN, CAN NOT BE USED.
Doflamingo's Bird-Cage AND Fujitora's Meteorites
Doflamingo's Bird-Cage being separated from his personal scaling is quite ridiculous for a multitude of reasons. He summoned up all of those threads to encompass the entirety of Dressrosa with no preparation implied, and with no wasted energy. To suggest that this is the limit of his power, especially when it is not even one of his actual attacks, let alone an awakened ability, is at least ridiculous. Not a single character with the exception of Luffy had been capable of breaking Doflamingo's threads, and any weaker character was messed up by it.
If the Bird-Cage needed to be prepared through some sort of timed-prep or other means that left Doflamingo debilitated, it would be necessary to separate it from his key, but due to it being made from millions of threads he simply popped out of no-where, it's heavily supported that he is capable of such feats through normal means.
Scaling to Zoro's Daisen Sekkai is a poor move considering that the energy required for Pica to move the statue around Dressrosa and throw punches is considerably higher. Not to mention how he shifted the entire geography of the island in a short period of time.
I'm not interested in prolonging this more than I have to, and only brought up the points that I felt necessary to mention or even go into full detail with.
TL;DR: here's how the scaling should look
God Tiers (Yonko, Admirals, Similarly powerful characters): At least High 6-C scaling from Fujitora's full known destructive capacity with meteorites, and also due to Kaido no-selling Gear 4th and one-shotting him with casual effort
Tier 1 (Luffy, Commanders, Doflamingo, Fujitora and similarly powerful characters): Varying from 6-C+ to High 6-C using the same scaling from Doflamingo's Bird Cage, Luffy's Gear 4th giving him a stated 3x multiplier in attack power, and Doflamingo's Awakening and Yonko Commander-tier fighters competing with Gear 4th with varying success. Some of these characters (Marco, Vista, and Jozu as examples) momentarily fending off the God Tiers as well.
Tier 2 (Dressrosa Zoro and similarly powerful characters): 6-C. If I have to explain why, i'll be shocked due to the topic being repeatedly discussed ages ago.
Tier 3 (Elizabello's King Punch): High 7-A (The same)
Tier 4 (Executive-tier and Coloseum Fighters): 7-B (Same)
That's all I got to say. Later.
It has come to my attention (repeatedly the past couple weeks, nonstop) that the One Piece profiles have undergone some major revisions, and that the scaling has been tampered with to use/dismiss calculations that have either been debunked, edited, or simply ignored.
Time to put my input.
Planet Size
Stick with EARTH size until we get confirmation, better scaling, or EoS content that shows how big the OP planet actually is.
Subject over.
Whitebeard Quakes
I'm keeping this one short:
Again with this?? Really? I'm pretty certain that this calculation has been debunked over several reasons. The most prominent ones being an assumed time-frame and an assumed distance, rendering the entire calculation null. (and while the distance CAN be argued for due to the map drawing in other chapters, the scaling of the map comes from yet another assumed speed of the boats utilized by the marines, making it shaky at best)
We see an island of unknown location hit by what seems to be at least 4.0 richter scale quakes after Whitebeard lands an attack on Vice Admiral Lonz. Here's where the issue lies.
To keep it concise, this feat can easily be argued as a High 7-A feat just as easily as it can be argued to be a 6-A feat. There's is a severe lack of information here, thus the calculation, AGAIN, CAN NOT BE USED.
Doflamingo's Bird-Cage AND Fujitora's Meteorites
Doflamingo's Bird-Cage being separated from his personal scaling is quite ridiculous for a multitude of reasons. He summoned up all of those threads to encompass the entirety of Dressrosa with no preparation implied, and with no wasted energy. To suggest that this is the limit of his power, especially when it is not even one of his actual attacks, let alone an awakened ability, is at least ridiculous. Not a single character with the exception of Luffy had been capable of breaking Doflamingo's threads, and any weaker character was messed up by it.
If the Bird-Cage needed to be prepared through some sort of timed-prep or other means that left Doflamingo debilitated, it would be necessary to separate it from his key, but due to it being made from millions of threads he simply popped out of no-where, it's heavily supported that he is capable of such feats through normal means.
- The only argument that can be made here is that the Black Knight was decapitated by Kyros and later by 2 fodder, which is already suggested to be used as a shock value for both the characters and the audience. For example, Kyros decapitating the first Black Knight was a way to make the characters drop their guard, and allowed Doflamingo to ambush and nearly kill Kyros with a single strike had Luffy not noticed the attack coming.
- This also brings up an issue considering how Doflamingo's profile still lists him as being a threat to the likes of Jozu, who could hurt Aokiji and actually fended him off for some time off-panel, yet there is a VAST disparity between their tiers. Doflamingo being lower end High 7-A, Jozu being around baseline 6-C, and Aokiji being somewhere mid High 6-C. Strange...? Yes.
- Are we really going to suggest that Kaido, Big Mom, Akainu, Kizaru and others of this respective level of power are unable to cancel out or even annihilate a single one of the many meteorites nearing this level of power that Fujitora can bring down with consummate ease? That'd leave a major plot-hole and severe inconsistency with the powers of each character.
Scaling to Zoro's Daisen Sekkai is a poor move considering that the energy required for Pica to move the statue around Dressrosa and throw punches is considerably higher. Not to mention how he shifted the entire geography of the island in a short period of time.
- The profile even states that Pica is "Higher with stone golems", yet a punch from one of these things did little more than scratch Zoro, and was promptly destroyed.
- There's also a massive circle-scaling now if anyone can catch it from Zoro to all 4 top executive profiles due to this change.
I'm not interested in prolonging this more than I have to, and only brought up the points that I felt necessary to mention or even go into full detail with.
TL;DR: here's how the scaling should look
God Tiers (Yonko, Admirals, Similarly powerful characters): At least High 6-C scaling from Fujitora's full known destructive capacity with meteorites, and also due to Kaido no-selling Gear 4th and one-shotting him with casual effort
Tier 1 (Luffy, Commanders, Doflamingo, Fujitora and similarly powerful characters): Varying from 6-C+ to High 6-C using the same scaling from Doflamingo's Bird Cage, Luffy's Gear 4th giving him a stated 3x multiplier in attack power, and Doflamingo's Awakening and Yonko Commander-tier fighters competing with Gear 4th with varying success. Some of these characters (Marco, Vista, and Jozu as examples) momentarily fending off the God Tiers as well.
Tier 2 (Dressrosa Zoro and similarly powerful characters): 6-C. If I have to explain why, i'll be shocked due to the topic being repeatedly discussed ages ago.
Tier 3 (Elizabello's King Punch): High 7-A (The same)
Tier 4 (Executive-tier and Coloseum Fighters): 7-B (Same)
That's all I got to say. Later.