-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
One Piece - Questionable Statistics
- Thread starter CinCameron20
- Start date
- Status
- 2,047
- 778
I wouldn't say that Kaido is above people like a Prime Whitebeard and Gol D Roger. Shanks is also probably stronger since he's the man closest to the Throne of the Pirate King as confirmed in the Databook.
Although I do see Kaido beating a old Whitebeard but then again we've never seen Old Whitebeard go all out either
I also agree with Dr Fix on doing away with BB's time skip key.
Although I do see Kaido beating a old Whitebeard but then again we've never seen Old Whitebeard go all out either
I also agree with Dr Fix on doing away with BB's time skip key.
- 659
- 207
Please read above posts on the matter. Kaido>any other On Peice character by feats and lore.
Please read One Piece. Kaido has been defeated 7 times and is known as the "Strongest Creature Alive". Both Roger and Whitebeard are dead. Not to mention the fact that he is considered comparable to the other Yonko and is still, himself incapable of becoming Pirate King. Please only try to dispute my posts if you have evidence, because it gets really tiresome and frustrating when I have to keep stating what should be obvious.
Please read One Piece. Kaido has been defeated 7 times and is known as the "Strongest Creature Alive". Both Roger and Whitebeard are dead. Not to mention the fact that he is considered comparable to the other Yonko and is still, himself incapable of becoming Pirate King. Please only try to dispute my posts if you have evidence, because it gets really tiresome and frustrating when I have to keep stating what should be obvious.
- 14,575
- 5,877
Now that Damage and Ugarik redid the calcs regarding Dressrosa we can't say that everyone scaling Aokiji and their mothers can tank the meteor. That if the calc gets accepted which is very likely.
- 14,575
- 5,877
The 6B came when OP Earth was sized 2x bigger than Jupiter. Now we're using standard Earth's size due to inconsistencies.
And Luffy is actually 6-C+ with High 6-C in Gear 4th.
Those calcs were redone cause the size of Dressrosa is much smaller than what we had accepted before.
And Luffy is actually 6-C+ with High 6-C in Gear 4th.
Those calcs were redone cause the size of Dressrosa is much smaller than what we had accepted before.
- 659
- 207
It was because they couldn't decide on things like planet size. A calc has One Piece's earth bigger than the sun and no one wanted to accept it, since it seems pretty insane. Now, they are trying to use our earth size (despite it being obviously bigger) and are changing the calcs around to match it.EverWrink said:
- 2,047
- 778
Everyone knows the planet is bigger than earth, we just don't know the exact size of it at the moment. The current stats are a temporary low ball so you shouldn't really take them as 100% accurate.
- 14,575
- 5,877
As someone said (Damage I guess) that timeframe isn't so useful since it doesn't take into consideration that the Strawhats didn't went on a straight line. And they were in many islands for many days so I don't know if that actually helps the scaling but we could try to calculate how many days they travelled discounting the days they spent on islands.
I think I saw a video from this but I'll try to dub it before.
I think I saw a video from this but I'll try to dub it before.
- 1,526
- 229
Besides, the only calculation OP's true planet size would affect is Fujitora's meteor. Every other calculation depends on Dressrosa's size, which was recalced by Damage.
- 14,575
- 5,877
But that's important tho. Going by what Arabasta seems to be it could upgrade the verse to MHS+ again and with that speed the KE would be upgraded as well. Who knows how it would end.
- 2,047
- 778
Inb4 Ussop gets a 5-C feat. :^)
- 21,390
- 2,978
ninja'd reeee
Stefano4444
He/Him- 6,206
- 5,338
The Going Merry is a caravel while the Thousand Sunny looks like a brig sloop ship, if we don't have anything for calculate the speed of those ships we can utilize the average speed of real life caravels and brig sloop ships.EverWrink said:
- 5,357
- 730
There was a calc on Narutoforums that had a Relativistic result regarding the skirmish between Rayleigh and Kizaru
I can't find it though...
I can't find it though...
- 31,404
- 27,702
Should probably be brought up in a separate revision thread.ZackMoon1234 said:
Right now we should get back on topic.
- 2,047
- 778
No thread needs go be made about it. Everyone agreed it was an outlier and that we'd use it once we get better feats.
But yes, let's get on topic.
But yes, let's get on topic.
- 14,575
- 5,877
Right.
Now Fuji's meteors are 13 gigatons which is laughable against Aokiji's feat. Both of them were made casually.
So there's no doubt that Kaido scales to that now.
Now Fuji's meteors are 13 gigatons which is laughable against Aokiji's feat. Both of them were made casually.
So there's no doubt that Kaido scales to that now.
- 31,404
- 27,702
Well, we need to re-evaluate what Gear 4 is valued at now - and IMO Kaido should scale to that for completely withstanding it.
Of course, everyone else thinks Kaido should scale to the meteors but I won't argue that point anymore because everyone else is in agreement.
Of course, everyone else thinks Kaido should scale to the meteors but I won't argue that point anymore because everyone else is in agreement.
- 2,047
- 778
Well the meteorite is irrelevant now due to it being lower than the Kuzan feat. I think we should do my suggestion before and calc Doffy's speed feat with a time frame since there's no way he took 60 seconds to react.
- 5,357
- 730
Shouldn't the meteorite scale to Doflamingo?
He destroyed one when one of them came at him when Law redirected the meteorite to him
He destroyed one when one of them came at him when Law redirected the meteorite to him
- 2,047
- 778
Ugarik said:
There's still Oven's feat so no.
- 31,404
- 27,702
Doflamingo already has a speed calc for reacting to the meteor.ZackMoon1234 said:
And the half a meteor he destroyed would be way, way less than 13 Gigatons.
- 2,426
- 476
You should not start out a response this way. It is disrespectful to declare someone has not read the material, especially when you have not read their points thoroughly.Sword guy Z said:
"Kaido has been defeated 7 times and is known as the "Strongest Creature Alive". Both Roger and Whitebeard are dead."
You left out the fact that he has only ever been defeated by being ganged up on. One on one, he wins. Neither Roger nor WB have eve hurting Kaido, let alone defeating Kaido on their resume
"Not to mention the fact that he is considered comparable to the other Yonko and is still, himself incapable of becoming Pirate King."
Flase. Kaido is not considered comparable to other Yonko in the series. Becoming Pirate King has never once been said to be about being the single strongest character.
"Please only try to dispute my posts if you have evidence, because it gets really tiresome and frustrating when I have to keep stating what should be obvious."
Likewise. Remember your initial post was: "Kaido is not God Tier. He is comparable to other Yonko. He is not stronger than WB or Roger."
- 14,575
- 5,877
The current scaling goes like this:
- 7-A coming from Pica due to Cin's reasonings and the new values.
- 7-A+ coming from Oven's feat (Sanji is stronger than Zoro lol).
- 6-C coming from Aokiji's feat.
- High 6-C should come from Luffy's 3x multiplier. Cin said that Base Doffy scales to Aokiji so at least Gear 2nd Luffy should do it aswell.
@Rin what was your suggestion?
- 7-A coming from Pica due to Cin's reasonings and the new values.
- 7-A+ coming from Oven's feat (Sanji is stronger than Zoro lol).
- 6-C coming from Aokiji's feat.
- High 6-C should come from Luffy's 3x multiplier. Cin said that Base Doffy scales to Aokiji so at least Gear 2nd Luffy should do it aswell.
@Rin what was your suggestion?
Stefano4444
He/Him- 6,206
- 5,338
There is also Pica's feat which is still technically 7-A and Aokiji feat with is 6-C+.Rin The Dragon Empress said:
- 2,047
- 778
@Calaca
Remember the previous calc you made for Doffy's speed? Remember you forgot to re do it using 7000m instead of 7000Km.
Remember the previous calc you made for Doffy's speed? Remember you forgot to re do it using 7000m instead of 7000Km.
- 31,404
- 27,702
> - High 6-C should come from Luffy's 3x multiplier. Cin said that Base Doffy scales to Aokiji so at least Gear 2nd Luffy should do it aswell.
I don't think we should scale Luffy directly to Aokiji like this. Not to the point of multiplying Aokiji's calc to get Luffy's G4 rating...
I don't think we should scale Luffy directly to Aokiji like this. Not to the point of multiplying Aokiji's calc to get Luffy's G4 rating...
- 2,047
- 778
Doffy broke free from Kuzan who had no reason to hold back. And Kuzans feat was extremely casual so he a lot stronger than just 6-C+. And Gear Forth was able to stomp Doffy, and Kaido can one shot Gear Fourth. High 6-C is still valid.
- 14,575
- 5,877
It'd end in an end even lower than the current speed going with 30s.
With the 10km and 30s it wouldn't even be Mach 1.
@Damage
Again with this? We discussed this for days in the CRT regarding the feat and the only argument against scaling Base/G2/G3 Luffy is that if we do so the scaling would be messy with the WB and Fuji's calcs. Both of these calcs has been debunked/downgraded so we have no ceiling.
Even Cin stated that Base Doffy scales to Aokiji and Luffy was able to harm him. That's scaling.
With the 10km and 30s it wouldn't even be Mach 1.
@Damage
Again with this? We discussed this for days in the CRT regarding the feat and the only argument against scaling Base/G2/G3 Luffy is that if we do so the scaling would be messy with the WB and Fuji's calcs. Both of these calcs has been debunked/downgraded so we have no ceiling.
Even Cin stated that Base Doffy scales to Aokiji and Luffy was able to harm him. That's scaling.
- 31,404
- 27,702
> And Kuzans feat was extremely casual so he a lot stronger than just 6-C+.
Just repeating that he did it casually doesn't necessarily mean he is capable of much higher attacks.
And Kuzan's reason to hold back is that he doesn't want to provoke a serious fight between himself and Doflamingo at the time; not when Smoker needs medical attention. He froze him as a warning.
Gear 4 stomped Doffy, sure, but Doffy still took numerous G4 hits to go down and was able last 20 minutes against him IIRC.
Right now we have Gear 4 as Island level, likely higher with King Kong Gun - which seems reasonable to me.
> Even Cin stated that Base Doffy scales to Aokiji and Luffy was able to harm him. That's scaling.
Upgrading Gear 2 Luffy to Island level+ is not good scaling.
Just repeating that he did it casually doesn't necessarily mean he is capable of much higher attacks.
And Kuzan's reason to hold back is that he doesn't want to provoke a serious fight between himself and Doflamingo at the time; not when Smoker needs medical attention. He froze him as a warning.
Gear 4 stomped Doffy, sure, but Doffy still took numerous G4 hits to go down and was able last 20 minutes against him IIRC.
Right now we have Gear 4 as Island level, likely higher with King Kong Gun - which seems reasonable to me.
> Even Cin stated that Base Doffy scales to Aokiji and Luffy was able to harm him. That's scaling.
Upgrading Gear 2 Luffy to Island level+ is not good scaling.
- 31,404
- 27,702
They're saying Kuzan's calced feat is extremely casual.Dr.Fix said:
- 14,575
- 5,877
Kuzan has no reasons to hold back if he see Doflamingo attempting to kill Smoker.Damage3245 said:
Then Doffy's durability scales to Gear 4th instead of otherwise.
And that rating comes with Luffy being baseline 6-C without the Aokiji's feat into consideration. Even if you disagree with it a CRT was made and the majority agree. Nothing has changed.
- Status
