Bro, i kinda forgot i had to answer to this older post you did back in page 1, sorry.
To explain this... Well, basically if Mikoto is ever in a verse match, and she is limited to her 8-A stuff, she can never use any of her lightning despite it being a major part of her attack moveset, for lack of a better word. If she is limited to her 7-C stuff, she can't use anything below that... not because it is locked but because it is useless and can't harm her opponent or defend against their attack due to the massive AP & Dura gap.
About this, this is really just a vs matches problem and not something that should affect how her profile is written, given even in a vs match her iron sand/Railgun still wouldn't be scaling to the same tier as her lightning so things don't really change that much.
Will you give that about the Carissa thing. However, for the thing that came from the second round with Accelerator I won't. Both Touma and Accelerator were at the literal ground zero of the event, in both the
novel and in the
anime, so there is no reason to assume that Touma didn't endure all of the shockwave's force. I intensely studied this scene in particular to make sure that this was the case.
Sure, but it's still an outlier for Touma, it is MUCH higher than any of his other feats and even guns/falls aside (which authors constantly wank, but we know these 2 would **** Touma up btw) Touma has been beaten by completely normal people in the series and normal humans being tier 8 in any series is sus at best.
On this topic, I... actually started look into it... And I don't actually think Awaki was damaged to badly. Here. From Volume 8 of the Index OT LN.
She was still damaged and thus wouldn't scale, in the anime version she is even KO'ed + recovering fast doesn't really mean much as it's Academy City we're talking about, the city that has already made it clear that only death can't be reverted, and even that isn't exactly true as we saw with Kagun.
Again, Junko's own 8-C feat was a fairly casual one and one that she did in order to disable Iruka's equipment. It also doesn't help that she doesn't have much fights in her own manga - she literally only fights Iruka and Arei (and Gunha, but it wasn't serious), and both times it was more or less stated that she wasn't fighting at full-power, and once she actually did so, she overpowered and blitz Arei and was only knocked out due to her full power's strain and everything else that had happened to her.
Which chapter did this happen, btw? I will need to take a closer look to give my opinion.
And Naruha - I honestly forgot her name, thanks for reminding me - is in the same boat as Junko in where she did her 8-B extremely casually - but instead of Junko's case where she was holding back for various reason, Naruha did her 8-B feat to show-off her strength in front of everybody, for lack of a better way to explain it. Which should give her, and people at a similiar level like Junko, a likely Far Higher rating to whatever rating they end up getting.
For this feat, i don't remember any character that would actually scale to everyone else taking attacks from Naru's Paper Armor so you'd have to explain how this scales to everyone else, but again, this was done with an esper power.
Man, this is much harder than I thought. Other verses just need one or two calcs, and everybody can scale to it with no issue. Moi, I chose this for myself, so I can't complain.
No, only small verses with few supporters are actually like what you described (which is wrong, but I'd have to actually know these verses to do a CRT pointing flaws in the scaling) the Big 3, DB and many other verses have several feats
Could remove the 8-A thing entirely. And replace it with say... At Least 8-C, Likely/Possibly 8-B.
Honestly, i wouldn't mind an 9A, possibly 8B rating being i thing, i just don't think the 8B feats are consistent enough for such a jump.