- 11,002
- 9,790
- Thread starter
- #56,601
What Recon said does not make sense. Saitama reaches that level of power via Accelerated Development. It shouldn't be listed as explanation for "likely far higher".
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 369
- 97
I think I quoted the whole thing by mistake. What I was agreeing with was the "likely far higher" with AD, and the last part of his post.
- 369
- 97
That would be for pre-time travel Garou, I guess.
- 11,002
- 9,790
- Thread starter
- #56,604
There is not a need for "likely" because we know for an absolute fact he becomes higher with AD.
- 204
- 68
ohhh ok
- 369
- 97
Then just "far higher" would be more appropriate, I feel like. I left the likely in case there's a dispute between higher and far higher.
- 11,002
- 9,790
- Thread starter
- #56,607
I don't think "far higher" is necessary. "Higher" works just fine since it's very unquantifiable and completely dependent on how much the person he fights pushes him.
- 369
- 97
It's just that the way the tier would be written would make it seem like Garou and Saitama are in the same ballpark when that's not the case.
- 15,297
- 15,481
It really doesn’t though.
- 369
- 97
For both, it would be 4-A, Higher via Accelerated Development, right?
- 2,254
- 388
Btw I do agree with Saitama having acausality type 4 while using the time reversal technique. It's already been pointed out that the feat is supposed to have been achieved by Saitama becoming retrocausal via quantum retrocausality, which is a wacky idea I had no clue about before tbh (apparently Feynman suggested it at one point lmao).
- 3,062
- 1,133
- 656
- 663
What is Saitama's tier is gonna be after fighting God? I will say at very least Low 2-C
- 369
- 97
You mean what would his tier be? Or has he already fought him in the web-comic?
- 2,254
- 388
Why m8?
- 2,254
- 388
The webcomic has been a massive hiatus, so nah. Currently the manga has much more in the way of feats than the webcomic as well.
Lugh_Tuathe_Dé
He/Him- 3,706
- 2,075
The secrets of the universe
- 11,002
- 9,790
- Thread starter
- #56,619
High 3-A, Low 2-C, or 2-A I think. Maybe even Low 1-C if God is a higher dimensional entity and just uses avatars to interact with the 3-D world.
- 204
- 68
I believe the God that has been shown so far is just an imitation and the real God is in a higher realm and will get TIER 1. Hold my word
- 2,254
- 388
Why 2-A lol? Wouldn't 2-C be more likely given the fact that we know of the existence of a limited number of alternate universes?
- 5,079
- 2,569
The one whom I originally quoted before you started this conversation with me was Zillerthebucko and their comment looked like this:
- 11,002
- 9,790
- Thread starter
- #56,623
What are you referring to?
CosmicWreck
He/Him- 674
- 385
In the audiobook series there's an alternate universe where Saitama and co are middle school/high school children. It was amusingly enough stated to be a parallel universe.
- 13,902
- 5,396
but uh, 4d is higher dimensional, which is tier 2 at best so....
- 5,079
- 2,569
CosmicWreck
He/Him- 674
- 385
God can still be Low 1-C.
Because of Garou and Blast we know Hyperspace exists.
Depending on how One and Murata build on this concept, higher dimensions can reasonably said to be introduced eventually.
For example, space would be 3 dimensions, hyper space (similar nature to the gates, but significantly bigger) the fourth and time, the fifth dimension. Or at least that would be the ideal.
Personally, instead of hypotheticals like these I'm kind of more interested in how many people here would even be interested in Saitama reaching higher dimensional levels of power at all.
Most people I've seen seem to take the tiers beyond 2-A as confusing and "bullshit".
Because of Garou and Blast we know Hyperspace exists.
Depending on how One and Murata build on this concept, higher dimensions can reasonably said to be introduced eventually.
For example, space would be 3 dimensions, hyper space (similar nature to the gates, but significantly bigger) the fourth and time, the fifth dimension. Or at least that would be the ideal.
Personally, instead of hypotheticals like these I'm kind of more interested in how many people here would even be interested in Saitama reaching higher dimensional levels of power at all.
Most people I've seen seem to take the tiers beyond 2-A as confusing and "bullshit".
- 13,902
- 5,396
only thing I really consider bullshit is that time is seen as a dimension
- 23
- 4
we wait
Recon1511
He/Him- 6,886
- 5,550
Maybe I didn't explain myself correctly, I think that his current AP (if he retains it after merging with past Saitama that is) should be listed as 4-A likely far higher as he clearly grew far beyond his previous feats after fighting Garou and then higher with accelerated development.
English is my second language so maybe it's not worded in the best way but Imo it should be made clear in the profile that Saitama is high above his listed AP.
- 2,280
- 1,231
Hasn't Murata seen God fanon Manga, where there were 11+ higher dimensions? If God battle is at that scale or higher, we may have a stronk God
CosmicWreck
He/Him- 674
- 385
Yeah. I've seen other people with this opinion too.
- 5,079
- 2,569
It works out in physics, so there is no reason why it wouldn't work for feats especially if a character can affect the future and/or the past with their power in a way that would be relevant for Attack Potency.
- 13,902
- 5,396
I’ve never actually seen any justification for it
even worse is when people think that time itself replaces the 4th dimension when time can easily exist in any dimension
- 2,619
- 544
Very profound.
- 5,079
- 2,569
Is that so? It should be possible to look up why exactly time is used as a 4th dimension but if I recall correctly the origin of that view has something to do with relativity and how time can be viewed as an additional axis to the three spatial dimensions we can perceive.
- 369
- 97
Yes, it's called a temporal dimension. While the others are spatial. It's a way to measure change.
