-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 24,976
- 26,824
- 15,351
- 22,177
- 22,343
- 18,529
That's in the process of getting changed.
- 19,224
- 16,839
I have an issue with that reasoning.
- 19,224
- 16,839
In the blog, you said that due to the Martial Artists being able to talk while Suiryu and Choze were moving fast, the full distance can not be used.
I may be wrong, but this seems like an Appeal to Reality Fallacy.
Across multiple manga, comics, and shows (One-Punch Man included), characters have been able able to say entire sentences while having other characters be FTE to them.
One-Punch Man and One Piece just to name a few.
Characters being able to speak does not mean that calcing the distance can't be used. If that were the case, tens possibly hundreds of feats across the site would need to be scrapped and redone. The logic behind your reasoning seems very fallacious to me.
- 22,343
- 18,529
That's not an appeal to reality fallacy. It's literally the opposite, if anything.
The timeframe within the manga itself doesn't line up with the timeframe drawn from real life.
Like what? Where is someone who can't keep up speaking in between a massive blitz.
The timeframe within the manga itself doesn't line up with the timeframe drawn from real life.
Like what? Where is someone who can't keep up speaking in between a massive blitz.
- 19,224
- 16,839
Your logic not being appeal to reality doesn't counter anything I said.
- 4,425
- 3,125
Oh yeah. I’m perma-banned from the Baki subreddit because someone made a Deku vs Yujiro thread, and I said Deku wouldn’t get stomped. 
- 4,425
- 3,125
Hmm.
Since God decides what a limiter is and literally creates them according to Genus, and Garou is now his ”avatar”, does that mean Garou probably doesn’t have a limiter right now?
Remember, removing a limiter doesn’t automatically grant infinite power. It’s just a cap of the POTENTIAL growth they can achieve by training. But Garou now seems pretty confident in being able to get stronger and stronger simply by copying Saitama with no apparently downsides yet.
Hmmmm.
Since God decides what a limiter is and literally creates them according to Genus, and Garou is now his ”avatar”, does that mean Garou probably doesn’t have a limiter right now?
Remember, removing a limiter doesn’t automatically grant infinite power. It’s just a cap of the POTENTIAL growth they can achieve by training. But Garou now seems pretty confident in being able to get stronger and stronger simply by copying Saitama with no apparently downsides yet.
Hmmmm.
- 22,343
- 18,529
Your first comment above doesn't even counter anything to begin with.
Give an example of those 'tens, possibly hundreds' of FTE feats.
Also, it kind of does if you're explaining that fiction is different from reality.
Last edited:
- 6,229
- 6,504
- 19,224
- 16,839
If we go by this then Garou and Platinum Sperm's light constellation manga timeframe of 1.3 milliseconds shouldn't be used, as it's contradicted by King noticing it happen, even though Normal Human Perception peaks at 130 milliseconds
- 6,229
- 6,504
Another W I’m liking this threadOh yeah. I’m perma-banned from the Baki subreddit because someone made a Deku vs Yujiro thread, and I said Deku wouldn’t get stomped.
- 24,976
- 26,824
All the stars disappear
- 19,224
- 16,839
Garou's limiter was kinda stated to have been broken already...Hmm.
Since God decides what a limiter is and literally creates them according to Genus, and Garou is now his ”avatar”, does that mean Garou probably doesn’t have a limiter right now?
Remember, removing a limiter doesn’t automatically grant infinite power. It’s just a cap of the POTENTIAL growth they can achieve by training. But Garou now seems pretty confident in being able to get stronger and stronger simply by copying Saitama with no apparently downsides yet.
Hmmmm.
- 22,343
- 18,529
Firstly, that's not based on a timeframe drawn from real life and applied to the manga. This is you attempting to create a contradiction by drawing comparisons to real life. If anything, this would actually support my point.
Secondly, he didn't notice them move, he noticed the glowing beams made by the constellation. The previous constellation also lasted longer than their movements alone, which is why everyone and their mums noticed it.
- 4,425
- 3,125
To be fair, didn‘t Flashy, Garou and PS’s light constellation last a lot longer than just the timer? Seems the timer only started and stopped at certain times. Normal people were watching it, even on TV I think. I need to reread.
- 19,224
- 16,839
- 4,425
- 3,125
The entire constellation lasted a long, long time. People were watching it on TV. Saitama and Genos had a casual conversation with it in the background. Etc etc…
- 19,224
- 16,839
That just helps my point even more.
If we were to go by the notion that Garou and PS' timer was only showing the amount of time that it took to create the constellation, then we could do the same for Suiryu and Choze's.
Suiryu and Choze were completely FTE to the Martial Artists in that page. The part of the feat I calced was only on that page, and did not include the extra distance Suiryu and Choze moved afterwards.Thus, calcing the entire distance moved can and should be used.
- 4,940
- 1,841
The shockwaves generated by their attacks were frozen in place 
maybe that should be used for the timeframe of the first feat
maybe that should be used for the timeframe of the first feat
- 4,940
- 1,841
I agree with this, i have no idea why this wasn’t done beforehand.
They moved that entire distance AND THEN we got a reaction from the crowd.
- 22,343
- 18,529
This doesn't help your point even remotely. It likely does the exact opposite (showing that real life timeframes can't be applied to fiction), at best means the light generated constellation itself lasted longer than their movements (something evident by the fact that there's a constellation to begin with), and has literally nothing to do with the mechanics of the Suiryu and Choze feat (based on a real life timeframe that's contradicted by the story).
The crowd moved during the event, and spoke while they still moved at FTE speeds. This is not retroactive.
- 19,224
- 16,839
1. PS and Garou moved a specific distance in 13 milliseconds
2. Choze and Suiryu moved a specific distance in enough time to be FTE to the Martial artists in that moment (1/220 of a second)
They spoke after than page. I'm calcing the distance they moved during the moment they were FTE before the Martial Artists could speak.
- 22,343
- 18,529
1. Choze and Suiryu didn't, and we're trying to draw a timeframe specifically from the characters themselves. So this is not relevant, especially since King only noticed the light generated by the constellation, not their movements.
2. Which is contradicted by them reacting to the events.
They still spoke while FTE shit was occurring, and moved at least a little during the feat itself. One part of the feat happening before they spoke doesn't change the fact that they could still speak during a part that was also FTE.
I know what you're calcing, bruh. I already calculated it. What we disagree on is them scaling to the entire distance.
- 4,940
- 1,841
They moved? When?
They didn’t speak at all when they moved the initial distance, they traveled that entire distance, and then we get them questioning what just happened and then them stating they can’t see them at all.
Them speaking doesn’t suggest this doesn’t happen in a small timeframe, they could be making thousand more movements while they’re talking if anything. Point is, talking during the feat doesn’t suggest the initial distance happened while they could perceive the area
- 19,224
- 16,839
After the moment that's being calced.
?
The reason you disagree on calcing the entire distance is due to the Martial Artists speaking entire sentences. This is not an issue because they weren't able to speak during the moment that's being calced due to their speed and the timeframe they moved the distance they did (1/220 of a second).
- 4,940
- 1,841
You’re confusing yourself, them talking doesn’t contradict much of anything, a bullet is fte to a human but we can still make actions during that timeframe, why? Because it’s still traveling overtime and at some point it has been moving for so long that the time has amounted to something we can perceive.
The reason this is different is because they moved a set amount of distance before they let off any form of reaction or sign they could perceive the area. That’s the entire point of this feat, to showcase how fast they were in comparison to the other heroes. Nothing alludes to this happening while they could perceive the area
The reason this is different is because they moved a set amount of distance before they let off any form of reaction or sign they could perceive the area. That’s the entire point of this feat, to showcase how fast they were in comparison to the other heroes. Nothing alludes to this happening while they could perceive the area
- 22,343
- 18,529
They clearly move at least a little
For the last time, explicitly FTE shit was still going on while they were talking. Both events would supposedly happen in a 1/220th timeframe.
Perception speed is significantly faster than reaction speed, let alone speaking entire sentences that the other characters could react to.
This isn't about tiny movements, it's about responding to stimuli and shit.
Repeating irrelevant points doesn't make them less irrelevant.
- 19,224
- 16,839
That doesn't show them moving. I'm confused.
- 22,343
- 18,529
Look at the first panel. In the third, they're reeling backwards a bit from the clash and not exactly where they were in the second.
Anyway, I don't see a point in listening to the same arguments.
@Therefir @Damage3245 What do you think?
Anyway, I don't see a point in listening to the same arguments.
@Therefir @Damage3245 What do you think?
Last edited:
- 31,256
- 27,479
The movement is more noticeable on the guy with the tall hair than the others.
- 31,256
- 27,479
At the moment I think your arguments make more sense.
- 19,224
- 16,839
How?
- 4,425
- 3,125
Could Tatsumaki replicate/replicate a portion of the Serious Table Flip feat if she was on Io?
