- 6,504
- 6,597
The narrative implication here is that Garou is trying to replicate a GRB, explaining what it actually is before hand to give us an idea of the feat Garou is displaying.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 11,606
- 10,785
- Thread starter
- #43,522
Yes, I know the average energy. I mean the SIZE, how big one is. We need that if we're going to proportionally scale Garou's to a real GRB.
- 19,360
- 16,979
Garou: Gains the power to control and understand the flow of energy and power of all things in the universe, and is stated to be able to harness said energy in his body
Also Garou: Copies the strength of power and speed of someone previously massively superior to him, and matches him using that understanding of flow
Garou right after: Does exactly what he was stated to be able to do, and harnessed the power of a GRB inside of his body, and shoots it out
Narrator: Tells us how powerful a GRB is
VSBW: Let's calc how strong a 20 meter GRB would be even though the manga stated that he can harness the power of a GRB in his body
Megaraptor149
He/Him- 2,177
- 741
But according to wiki, its radiation can ruin the molecule. What about Matter Manipulation via Radiation?
- 20,549
- 17,462
GRBs aren't like supernovas. The length of their jets depend on angle which can cause it to lose energy at different rates.
The only way to get a Tier from it would be to get the size of the black hole he makes and then compare it to one from a binary or large star supernova.
- 6,504
- 6,597
Yeah that was brought up last page. To be precise, Saitama said he got scratched. Which is still damage obviously, but a bit more precise with how much he took.
- 20,549
- 17,462
That's what radiation does. Like we don't give fire manipulation people heat manipulation despite fire making things hotter.
- 11,606
- 10,785
- Thread starter
- #43,529
I see, that seems fair. Well, I guess someone needs to calc the size of the black hole then.
- 11,532
- 8,030
I agree with this. The attack being scaled to a gamma ray burst of the same size is fine with me.
- 19,360
- 16,979
Or to not calc anything an give him whatever the average GRB is, as thats what the manga states.
- 5,668
- 4,895
from space battles:
Could calculate the Eddington Luminosity. That would form the upper end of how much energy a real black hole of that size can radiate.
Formula for Eddington Luminosity in watts is L-edd = 3 * 10^4 * 4 * 10^26 * (mass of black hole / mass of sun). A black hole of the size shown on the panel where the attack is first called Gamma Ray Burst would be 350 Earth masses, or about 1/1000 of a solar mass.
Plug that in and we get 1.2 * 10^28 joules per second, about 30 times the sun's output. This would actually take quite a while to scatter the planet.
Could calculate the Eddington Luminosity. That would form the upper end of how much energy a real black hole of that size can radiate.
Formula for Eddington Luminosity in watts is L-edd = 3 * 10^4 * 4 * 10^26 * (mass of black hole / mass of sun). A black hole of the size shown on the panel where the attack is first called Gamma Ray Burst would be 350 Earth masses, or about 1/1000 of a solar mass.
Plug that in and we get 1.2 * 10^28 joules per second, about 30 times the sun's output. This would actually take quite a while to scatter the planet.
- 6,504
- 6,597
I think Gamma Ray Bursts are actually somewhat small, looking into it. Relative to how large interstellar bodies usually are, I mean.
- 19,360
- 16,979
Why?
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 5,744
- 4,998
It doesn't have to fit the size criteria, so I'd say it's fine. The fact Murata went out of his way to make a comparison to a IRL one should be evidence enough,
- 11,606
- 10,785
- Thread starter
- #43,536
Uh... This is just the energy radiating from it.
Creating the Black Hole itself is a tier 5/4 feat.
- 5,668
- 4,895
if not mistaken, thats 3 exatons per second
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 5,744
- 4,998
It doesn't. It implies that regardless, a mere touch is enough, and the deal is sealed.
- 20,549
- 17,462
From what I can find, according to the TVO limits a star had to have at least 3x the solar mass of the sun to become a black hole (or at least consistently become one).
Which translates to a radius of 8,862 meters.
Earth has a radius of 9mm and Jupiter has one of like 2.82 meters. So if he breaks double digits there's a good chance he gets in upper 5-A or High 5-A for black hole creation.
- 25,022
- 27,033
- 20,549
- 17,462
- 11,606
- 10,785
- Thread starter
- #43,543
It is most definitely about 5+ meters. But could be bigger here.
- 20,549
- 17,462
If its 350x Earth then we have our tier already. Size wise it would 5-A due to the weight and if we assume E=MC^2 for mass-energy transfer it would be 1.8786409874582e+44 Joules for creating one out of existing energy.
- 11,606
- 10,785
- Thread starter
- #43,545
Funnily enough that value is nearly the exact same as an average GRB. Wow.
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 5,744
- 4,998
I believe we should still vouch for Garou scaling full on to the average GRB. High 4-C Garou is based, and makes sense.
Megaraptor149
He/Him- 2,177
- 741
High 4C Garou is better
- 5,668
- 4,895
regardless someone should create a calc for it
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 5,744
- 4,998
- 20,549
- 17,462
I can work one up Thursday when I get off work.
- 9,652
- 8,711
Garou's Height = 177 cm
Garou's Leg = 94 cm
Black Hole Length = 6 m
Black Hole Radius = 3 m
Black Hole Formula = ((299792458^2/(2*6.674*10^-11))/(5.972*10^24))*(2.487*10^32) * radius in meters = energy in joules
Energy = ((299792458^2/(2*6.674*10^-11))/(5.972*10^24))*(2.487*10^32) * 3 = 8.412*10^34 Joules, 20.10 Yottatons of TNT (Large Planet level)
- 16,270
- 10,714
Garou solos CellDidn't ppl mention it was 4-C or High 4-C when the feat was revealed?
Edit: Oh. 4-B. We get a Saitama vs Superman thread
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 5,744
- 4,998
Wouldn't a simplistic calc be enough?
In 40s, a GRB releases as much energy as the sun's entire lifetime. The Sun's lifespan is ~10 billion years
10 billion years is 315567360000000000s
The sun loses 3.78*10^26 joules every second.
Thus, 315567360000000000*(3.78*10^26) = 1.2 FOE (High 4-C)
- 20,549
- 17,462
Therefir already did it.
Anyways if we're doing Matt's suggestion then his Tier is currently "High 5-A (above Black Hole calc), likely High 4-C (Compared to a real Gamma Ray Burst which produces at least 1 foe or 10^44 joules of energy)"
Anyways if we're doing Matt's suggestion then his Tier is currently "High 5-A (above Black Hole calc), likely High 4-C (Compared to a real Gamma Ray Burst which produces at least 1 foe or 10^44 joules of energy)"
GodlyCharmander
He/Him- 5,744
- 4,998
If Matt suggested it, then I'm against it (jk, I just don't agree with likely)
The literal only reason why High 4-C is "likely" is due to size. I disagree. The context of Garou knowing all flows of the universe, being able to copy Saitama's abilities to perfection to the point he actually hurt him, and Murata going out of his way to tell us how power his attack is, should be very "definitive" for his tier, which makes the "likely" trivial.
Either way, this should be taken to a CRT so we can actually have a debate about it.
The literal only reason why High 4-C is "likely" is due to size. I disagree. The context of Garou knowing all flows of the universe, being able to copy Saitama's abilities to perfection to the point he actually hurt him, and Murata going out of his way to tell us how power his attack is, should be very "definitive" for his tier, which makes the "likely" trivial.
Either way, this should be taken to a CRT so we can actually have a debate about it.
- 7,350
- 3,748
Tbh in the second one it may have expanded and gotten even bigger.
Mephistus
Username Only- 1,034
- 794
lazily using the building storey as a measuring stick there (~3 meter)
storey = 3 px = 3 m
bh diameter = 86.4523 px = 86.4523 meters
Spinoirr
He/Him- 16,146
- 9,110
- 11,606
- 10,785
- Thread starter
- #43,559
Put this on a blog and have it evaluated.
- 16,270
- 10,714
well... at least it was Saitama strength that could hurt himself...
Saitamabros...
