rwby.fandom.com
Arrowfell is canon story-wise yeah, but Rubys Invulnerability, like a game has suddenly levelled up Ruby's semblance off-screen, and the latest volume downright proving shes not invulnerable in her petal burst form, is clearly incorrect. We shouldn't take game mechanics over main source.
Ik but if im honest, the whole 'Petal Burst+' lile its evolved at all, when Ruby didnt even know the specifics of her power apparently, just sorta makes it unnecessary to have on the page in the first place. Its clearly just game-mechanic enhancement, and its been contradicted so it should be removed.
Problem is Kerry outright said the RWBY x JL comic is canon
Jinx, NONE of the extended media is brought up in the show, but it is still canon. Arrowfell, Ice Queendom, the novels, Grimm Eclipse, none of it is ever brought up in the show, that does not make it non-canon.
Jinx, Marguerite has written all of the RWBY comics published by DC, with the writers of RWBY working alongside her. None of the comics contradict the show at all, just because they arent directly referenced in the show does not make them non-canon.
no they literally havent though. You're using a statement for the RWBY DC Comics.
The DC comics contradict the show loads. The whole Cardin Weiss arc instead of Jaune, Tai being fine with Ruby leaving, Willow Schnee's entire character etc.
First DC comic is canon. JL one isn’t.
Arrowfell, Ice Queendom, Grimm Eclipse etc. were made AFTER the fact, so of course they wont bring it up.
How many 'versions of the justice league' are Team RWBY gonna exactly meet, and never mention again, for you to stop trying to make a crossover canon
Yes i know, but theres still major contradictions in that one regardless.
They have, yes.
Not really? The first comic is a direct continuation of the end of volume 3 which leads directly into volume 4.
Neat, so was the JL comic.
Both are canon as confirmed by the rwby writers. If you think otherwise you're free to ask them yourself
S o u r c e ?
Yeah, with major plot inconsistencies and alternate takes to the show.
Proof?
Source: Trust me Bro
I'm not defending anything, I acknowledge that its goofy, but also acknowledge that it is still canon in spite of its goofiness, as series with lore that is built up by wide-branching extended medias tend to be. At the end of the day though, the rwby writers made it very clear that this is canon.
RWBY x JL is set between volumes 2 and 3. The comic came out in 2021. Volume 2 came out in 2014. Ergo the comic was written seven years after the place in the timeline it is set, and thus obviously wouldnt have been referenced in the volume itself.
Again, I dont have an answer to this yet as the film hasnt dropped. All we know at the moment is that the film is in fact canon.
What so they met these essentially identical strangers to ppl they've met before but cant remember them.
And they WONT run into this problem with the movie coming up, taking place apparently in V8-V9 RWBY? If thats 'canon', which i fr doubt it is.
No, its more you just REALLY like tryna scale RWBY to DC characters lol
???
No we dont what???? How on Earth is both the comic AND the film is canon
For someone who has never posted a source or scan for anything ever in their entire history on this forum, you demanding sources that have already been posted as though they havent already is laughable.
Are you thinking of a different comic? Because the RWBY x JL comic from 2021 doesnt have any actual DC characters in it. They're just RWBY characters loosely based on DC characters.
Jinx, real talk, are you okay? I've explained this premise to you several times today alone.
Keep telling yourself thatIts a DC crossover Weekly. Its fanfiction.
The fact that only one of them could possibly be canon lol. The designs for the vaguely like DC characters (They're DC characters), are exactly the same as the ones they would have met for the movie.
Y'know what? Let's flip the script: why don't YOU provide a source saying the crossovers AREN'T canon? And no "lol it's so obvious" malarkey, ACTUALLY PHYSICAL PROOF from either the people involved or the crossover itself that proves without a shadow of a doubt that they are, in fact, NOT canon. If you can't even prove that, then you're no better than Weekly in this situation.
Its a DC crossover Weekly. Its fanfiction.
Im aware theyre the 'Remnant' variants but a crossover is a crossover. And an extremely poor one at that. But that doesnt make it canon, again. Batman would have solved the Grimm problem easily
The fact that only one of them could possibly be canon lol. The designs for the vaguely like DC characters (They're DC characters), are exactly the same as the ones they would have met for the movie.
You really think Weiss gets kissed by Batman and Cyborg and then...forgets she met the guys that look identical
Didn't Weekly show a clip of the authors blatantly stating that the crossovers are canon? Or am I on drugs?
Thats not how it works bro?
No, that was only in regards to the RWBY comic published by DC, not the RWBY x Justice League crossover comic. They arent the same, the clip was made 2 years before the crossover.
Ohhh-
I'm just sayin', "it's a crossover" is a pretty flimsy excuse to say it's not canon. Ever heard of one-sided canonicity?
I think you need to brush up on your definition of 'crossover'. Its fanfic yes, but it is factually not a crossover as the character in the comic arent the actual justice league, they're a bunch of OCs from remnant who are loosely based on them.
Why would only one of them be canon? They're not connected in any way.
Clarification, it was one of the writers for RWBY confirming that the rwby writing r
Are you referring to the RWBY x DC Comics crossover you're talking about currently with Jinx? Or was it the one Jinx mentioned previously to me?
Batman realistically solves the Salem problem in an afternoon. This is a dude that has taken on Darkseid, Salem is nothing. Keep dreaming though
The exact same character designs and no ones gonna bring up how these guys are practically identical to the versions on Remnant they apparently met before like you claim?
They're the same characters from an existing IP reimagined. That doesnt make it any less a crossover. RWBY arent original for it lol.
