Question about Statemates and Calcs

[The_Causality]

Well, it's a bit strange how we treat some calcs:

For exemple, Mio Takamiya is 6-B+ when she destroyed a large part of the eurasia alongside somes countries Such as soviet union and china at the same time, the feats in the Light Novel is clearly at least Large Country level but we treat this feat as 6-B+ with calcs assumption.

My point here is, can we use the author statemate from the light novel instead of a calc for assuming the tiering?

 

[Kepekley23]

If the calc is High 6-B, why is she even 6-B to begin with?

 

[Kaltias]

I'm not sure if I understood what you mean?

Ikaros is 6-B because she has a 6-B calc.

I also have no idea how you found only 6-B+ for nuking China and the Soviet Union at once, it should be far above that

 

[The_Causality]

@Kep No, the calc is currently 6-B+ to 6-A but has been accepted as 6-B

My point is that the LN said that this explosion destroyed dozen of countries at the same time but the assumed calc of the visual feat has value which varie to 6-B to 6-A

So my question is can we use the LN statemate instead of a calcs?

@Kalt Yeah i've made a mistake about Ikaros, that why i've removed her from OP (but you are too fast) Well, what we do then?

 

[Kepekley23]

Imean, if the energy required to perform the feat is 6-B+, then there is no discussion.

 

[The_Causality]

Imean, if the energy required to perform the feat is 6-B+, then there is no discussion.

The problem i've is we used a vague panel of the manga, not really the LN infos about that. (but anyway i'will try to calc this again)

 

[Kaltias]

If the LN and the manga portray it differently, use the primary canon.

If that explosion is Russia + China sized it's definitely not 6-B+, and the size of explosion that you got from the manga isn't even as big as the USA, so the scale is definitely not the same

 

[The_Causality]

The Primary Canon is the Light Novel so i guess i can use it for recalc this feat.