They don't have emotions, Oda wrote them to quote Reiju "lack all emotions" and made it clear that was the case. During the wedding when they were about to be executed as Reiju said "even their own deaths won't get a reaction from them" due to judge taking all their emotions.
Yeah; no self-preservation on their part is what that scene is supposed to convey but it is clearly inconsistent as we also later see the Germa reacting strongly to their father being taken down by Big Mom. Something that wouldn't make sense if they were emotionless.
They lack self preservation for themselves due to lacking emotion, wishing to aid their "creator" isn't really proof of them now having emotions.
But PX are robots, not cyborgs- right? I always thought they were robots through and through
They were originally a human I think... But made to a full robot
Nah they're not robots, they're cyborgs just like Kuma. They're clones of him in the same sense that the Seraphim's are biological clones of the warlords + Lunarian DNA. We see this when they bleed etc.
Px bots are not humans they are 100% robots. Kuma on the other hand is half robot half cyborg but I think his emotions were removed.They were originally a human I think... But made to a full robot
I had it wrong then. Still, for things like cannonballs, Smoker's Jutte, swords (arguably transponder snails since they're asexual) her ability seems to just kinda work.
Nah, the animals like transponder snails and the snakes showed lust in their eyes when she turned them, that's social influencing. Weapons and cannon balls seem to just be turned to stone regardless.
Human weapon doesn't necessarily mean robot though. Not trying to rush you but they're clones of Kuma who's also a pacifista and a confirmed cyborg.
I thought I didn't work on luffy because he didn't care about lust. Because he's innocent. And his love for adventure blocked his love for lust. And plus hes stupid so.
He lacks lust towards her, but if we treated her kicks and slave arrow to turn anyone to stone regardless then she would have been able to turn him to stone when he tried to escape.
Well she did say another user can't break her spell, not that the ability is pointless entirely.
No, the point made by Hancock first was in response to Blackbeard wanting the power. She said the power in general is useless without her beauty; meaning he wouldn't be able to turn anyone to stone due to that.
From what we've seen stuff like weapons, canon balls, etc would just turn to stone regardless.
For now it's social influencing, from the dialogue she's hyped up as someone who can make anyone feel lust regardless of age, gender and even species. I don't think she has any hax that forces you to feel emotions for her as otherwise momonga and Luffy would have turned.
Hmm?
Misread who you originally sent the message too, sorry.
Updated the OP and sandbox regarding this.
Hmm
, I guess for now that's ok... If I haven't forgotten anything 
Thanks I've fixed it.
The change in the OP isn't proposing that she petrifies those she touches regardless of attraction, rather, that inanimate objects get turned to stone regardless of attraction but living things like people etc still require attraction regardless of the technique she's using.Hmm
Tho proving her touches, petrify without attraction will be insanely hard/annoying to prove
What about... I guess it's not a blunt blitz feat
I know...
I just said proving that she petrifies those she touches regardless of attraction, is hard/annoying to do I think
Just noticed I never responded to this, Blackbeard never says this. He only says that he came for her powers, Devon says she wants to kill her and Blackbeard said she can as long as he gets her power (we already know he can steal powers from dead people). Only the weird nose guy wants to keep her alive and neither of them responded to him.
Blackbeard responds to Catarina. She says she wants her head and Blackbeard says she can have her way with her after he takes her ability.
Yep. No solid confirmation for otherwise outside of a super vague dialogue
As Snook's said, Blackbeard did say that line in the fan translation of the chapter. Don't know what the official release says.
Most likely because the manga and anime states that once the user dies the devil leaves them and goes to something else. We see that when big mom ate mother carmel and obtained her powers. Or how blackbeard needed to kill wb to take his power.
Viz translation(official) says it too, and one of his people say boss can't we keep her alive but blackbeard most likely knew she would've turned everyone into stone and killed them. Which I think blackbeard ended up attacking the person.
I've added it to the OP and Sandbox.
Yee I agree with everything btw
Yee I agree with everything btw
... Be more like luffy, which luffy also acts like a monkey, it's easy if you truly want it to be 
