• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Status
Not open for further replies.
The calc isn't inflated just because you think so, sorry.

We've already debunked that too. The meteor is plainly shown coming in after the warning. There's zero reason for it not to. You're just repeating yourself at this point.
 
Came into view doesn't mean that's when he sent it for the last time. Hell, I can calc that and prove that when we see the meteor come into view, it's not the same distance as the moon.
 
Cal, you know full well that this isn't a good argument when talking about fiction. How else were we supposed to see a meteor coming?

By it taking much longer than the inflated calc assumes, because it has zero showings of "relativistic" speeds aside from that literal one second. It makes far more sense for him to send it prior to his warning, because he's still casually chilling in the moon talking to himself afterwards. Also, a warning shot always comes before the words.

Except the movie shows the meteor start coming after he dissapears. Try watching the scene at 0.25x. It doesn't matter if it makes sense or not when the movie shows it after he dissapears. It's just ad hoc at this point.
 
@Cal

Burning is also arguing for it. Several knowledgeable members agree with it. You're downplaying Naruto. Sorry to break it for you, but calling the fans biased and then trying to get a downgrade passed while I was asleep is just as dishonest.

Also, thanks for proving you have to appeal to popularity now.

@Matt

Incorrect. I've posted proof it was after; both BMW and I have. Until you post proof it wasn't, it stands.
 
All your last post did is make me realize how desperate you are at this point. You have realized you no longer have any way to lessen a solid feat by analyzing the scene.

Sorry, but the water isn't getting past the firmament's floodgates.
 
Alright, you want me to use the movie as proof? How about the fact that when we see the meteor past that initial five seconds, it's going nowhere near relativistic speeds. Or how about if any of you decided to calculate how far that meteor was from the planet, you'd see that the meteor wasn't at the moon by the time we see it. Meaning that via calcs, that meteor was sent before the illusion ended.
 
The real cal howard said:
Alright, you want me to use the movie as proof? How about the fact that when we see the meteor, it's going nowhere near relativistic speeds. Or how about if any of you decided to calculate how far that meteor was from the planet, you'd see that the meteor wasn't at the moon by the time we see it. Meaning that VIA CALCS, that meteor was sent before the illusion ended.
If that was the case then the moment Toneri's body started becoming translucent we would had seen the meteor coming down but no that wasn't the case
 
Are you seriously using Cinematic Time as an argument? Are you really this desperate?

How about the fact this meteor was a lunar fragment and confirmed to have come from the Moon?

I have zero idea of how you came to that last idea, but I do have an idea of why you haven't addressed any of the relevant arguments and just repeated that bit.
 
BlackeJan said:
Actually I'm finally doing fine we honestly don't need 2 make another thread unless we r making a vote
450+ Comment is largely enough for a thread, also, the thread glitch...
 
450+ Comment is largely enough for a thread, also, the thread glitch...

Ah that's true....so I guess the momen we get 2 a certain comment number we close this & make a new thread?
 
The real cal howard said:
BlackeJan said:
THE way I'm seeing it is this....the people screams outlier or false every chance they get r people who don't like the series AT ALL
Yeah, nice ad hominem there, buddy. And if any shounen has the right to complain about spite, it's Fairy Tail, not Naruto.
I disagree with this heavily.

there are a ton of times Fairytail got upgrades for the sake upgrades... it took forever for someone to notice that they were wrong.

for all the wank Naruto does get it gets the same amount of downplay in fact due to it's popularity it gets far more downplay that FT
 
Look, I'm gonna calm down. Sorry for getting heated.

Firstly, @Lephyr. Star Wars blasters would be subsonic if it wasn't for statements saying they're higher. The same scene shows the meteor much slower than the calc is saying. Secondly, @Kep. Remember, the calc was originally denied due to cinematic timing. Anyway, it shows that the meteor, like most meteors we treat here, aren't the same speed within the earth's atmosphere. What I was saying before was that with the knowledge the meteor came from the moon, a calc would prove that said meteor would have to have came before the illusion ended.
 
For the upgrade: Shadow, Kep, Blacke, Lephyr, BMW, Hindzolia, Ricsi, Omimi, Rocker, Astral, Final, Burning

Against: Dark649, Cal, Matt, Sera, Griffin, Knight, Blue, Tata
 
The real cal howard said:
Look, I'm gonna calm down. Sorry for getting heated.
Firstly, @Lephyr. Star Wars blasters would be subsonic if it wasn't for statements saying they're higher. The same scene shows the meteor much slower than the calc is saying. Secondly, @Kep. Remember, the calc was originally denied due to cinematic timing. Anyway, it shows that the meteor, like most meteors we treat here, aren't the same speed within the earth's atmosphere. What I was saying before was that with the knowledge the meteor came from the moon, a calc would prove that said meteor would have to have came before the illusion ended.
we have calcs that put blasters anywhere between Hypersonic to MHS+

so no not subsonic
 
It doesn't show anything about the meteor's true speed. It's Cinematic Timing. If this logic were to be accepted, the meteor wouldn't be a thousandth of the speed of a real meteor, which is 100% false in any case. Your argument isn't an argument.

The calc was originally denied before we debunked the arguments against it. Then it was deemed fine.

No, it wouldn't. If your logic were true, that meteor would have taken years to arrive at the Earth's surface as opposed to the few extra seconds that would add. Seriously, don't use Cinematic Timing as an argument. Every single feat in this wiki will receive the same treatment.
 
Everybody please calm down. Staff members should be able to disagree with each other about fictional statistics without being disrespectful. It creates a bad mood in the wiki. Cal is usually very friendly and Kepekley is usually very helpful. They are both valuable parts of our community.

Anyway, this thread almost has 500 posts, at which point it will automatically close. As such, some staff member should immediately start a new thread and link to it here.
 
please for the love of god close this thread now. I cant tell you how stressful it was to read the comments going back and foward to downgrade Naruto verse speed when everything Kep said is logically correct. Can we please make a rule to not downgrade naruto verse speed. We even got calcs from Gwen for madaras speed and people try to downgrade it. Sorry but its annoying
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top