- 15,419
- 5,012
I'll start this with a heads up, as I was discovering some of this things my own internal bias briefly somewhat prevented me from being as reasonable as I could about this matter. With this in mind, I would like to mildly ask everyone evaluating this to try their best to remain partial about everything. That's all.
This blog explains why Save Files aren't timelines as some kind of rule in fiction, you can ignore the "Other uses" part.
Then this blog gives further reasons as to why the SAVEs in Undertale aren't timelines and why LOADing and Resetting does not leave behind the timeline where you were. It also explains why Asriel's Hyper Goner doesn't erase the timeline and everything wrong with P. Flowey. I would have made a part for Gaster if he still had a profile.
This was all actually almost accepted in another thread, but I always knew I needed to make a blog for people to see what happened to the stats, my attitude in that thread wasn't the best and I got like 5% of the things I said wrong. It would have also been preferable to have more staff evaluating the matter in the other thread but that never came to be, so starting over in a lesss messy thread should do the job.
The profiles would end up looking like this:
In-Universe Save Files
vsbattles.fandom.com
This blog explains why Save Files aren't timelines as some kind of rule in fiction, you can ignore the "Other uses" part.
Undertale: Misconceptions
vsbattles.fandom.com
Then this blog gives further reasons as to why the SAVEs in Undertale aren't timelines and why LOADing and Resetting does not leave behind the timeline where you were. It also explains why Asriel's Hyper Goner doesn't erase the timeline and everything wrong with P. Flowey. I would have made a part for Gaster if he still had a profile.
This was all actually almost accepted in another thread, but I always knew I needed to make a blog for people to see what happened to the stats, my attitude in that thread wasn't the best and I got like 5% of the things I said wrong. It would have also been preferable to have more staff evaluating the matter in the other thread but that never came to be, so starting over in a lesss messy thread should do the job.
The profiles would end up looking like this:
- P. Flowey: Unknown, at least 9-A (emphasis on how we don't know his tier, not that he's just 9-A)
- Asriel: Low 2-C when not holding back
- Chara: Low 2-C
- Frisk's peak Durability: Low 2-C if we scale them to Asriel, which we probably shouldn't but we can talk about it. Their AP would be downgraded