- 7,836
- 14,855
I'm inclined to agree. I don't think it is explicitly wrong to interpret the Negative Zone as infinite-dimensional, but I think the evidence for it is somewhat unclear, and we have a body of work which portrays it as being as being a normal anti-matter universe. It's clear there is an element of subjectivity about what is to be done, and I think both sides have made their thoughts on the matter clear enough that we don't need to beat a dead horse.
The important question to ask now is: If we are to accept an infinite dimensional interpretation for this realm, who and what would we scale to that? And once that is answered, we should try to reach a consensus or majority vote on the matter so that we do not have to go in circles on the subject in perpetuity. I don't think either side of the Negative Zone discussion is arguing in bad faith, unlike some of the other subjects that have been brought up here, so we should be able to reach a satisfactory conclusion now. Perhaps it would be worth branching to another thread to discuss the subject since this one has become such a mess.
The important question to ask now is: If we are to accept an infinite dimensional interpretation for this realm, who and what would we scale to that? And once that is answered, we should try to reach a consensus or majority vote on the matter so that we do not have to go in circles on the subject in perpetuity. I don't think either side of the Negative Zone discussion is arguing in bad faith, unlike some of the other subjects that have been brought up here, so we should be able to reach a satisfactory conclusion now. Perhaps it would be worth branching to another thread to discuss the subject since this one has become such a mess.