- 2,338
- 1,833
- Thread starter
- #201
This thread is not to discuss Buddhist scaling. That thread has already passed and would require a separate CRT to unpass. This thread is about the application of abilities stemming from the passing of the ontology thread (which is why said thread is necessarily pre-cursory). So "disagreement with Buddhist scaling" doesn't make any sense here. You're essentially trying to hold a vote for results that have already passed in a different thread. So none of those votes bar Dereck, count as applying to any specific aspect of the blog, outside of those one would prove would be extrapolating from Buddhism. Which they themselves would also have to clarify as to which abilities count for such, given once again, my thread is already passed.The total vote tally so far is:
Agree: @Dr._whiteee @LordGinSama @TheGunsFinalWrath @azontr @LIFE_OF_KING @Arkenis @Sir_sun_man
Disagree: @Maitreya (disagrees with Buddhism scaling) @Tatsumi504 (disagrees with Buddhism scaling) @Deagonx (disagrees with Buddhism scaling) @BasedNecoScaler69 (disagrees with Buddhism scaling) @Spinoirr (disagrees with Buddhism scaling) @Dereck03 (disagrees with Buddhism scaling) @Maverick_Zero_X (disagrees with Buddhism scaling) @SunDaGamer (agreed with most besides conceptual manipulation) @Vietthai96 (disagrees with Buddhism scaling) @ImmortalDread (disagrees with Buddhism scaling) @BestMGQScalerEver (disagreed with Buddhism scaling) @Dalesean027 (disagreed with Buddhism scaling) @TOAAPRESENCE1 (disagrees with Buddhism scaling).
Officially there are 3 evaluating staff disagreements for this thread and no staff agreements in regards to the proposed abilities utilizing Buddhist roots as foundation for scaling.
None of the Moderators have expressed the slightest notion of having read anything. They have only clarified that they disagree with "1:1 scaling based off of vague mentions that are not found in the verse." There are umpteen abilities in the OP and not one has even been mentioned by a mod outside of maybe Dereck (I don't recall him outlining anything specific just agreeing with others)? Everything else has been a parrot of the aforementioned quote, and yet, not one person can identify an ability that not has been using JJK scans for direct correlation (not counting you).
Also I would really like to highlight this post because it urked me
This is just outright not true and kind of points towards your intentions. You are literally using staff's "Can't use vague terminology to give 1 to 1 scaling without context" as the basis for trying to list them as disagrees for a topic passed in another CRT, all the while championing the fact that "You shouldn't have to read a whole blog in order to ""understand the evidence""". That not only undermines your point that the mods agree with (as the blog would indeed contextualize things) but also outlines your bias as you are somehow correlating more evidence to contextualize and ability with "a good indication the points aren't well founded within the series itself".You shouldn’t have to read a whole blog in order to “understand the evidence” since the evidence should speak on its own and be presented for the point being argued against. If you have to say “you gotta understand the context bro” in order to try and prove your points…then that’s probably a good indication the points aren’t well founded within the series itself.
Is that the case on this wiki? Let's take a look:
DMC has two threads which contextualize the verses scaling and powers.
Twin peaks has multiple blogs contextualizing the verses powers.
Megami Tensei passed a large scale upgrade and began by posting a precursory blog.
Unsong had a huge cosmology blog for it's ratings and abilities and cross matches between Kaballah
Marvel just recently had an upgrade thread which required a pre-cursory blog
Elder Scrolls has entire books on the context behind its ratings and abilities
Blazblue has blogs that indeed act as the foundation for the powers of the verse.
These are off the top of my head. Given the scope of some of those powers and the recurrent theme of blogs preceding and/or acting as the foundation for verse upgrades, I fail to see how your conclusion follows from your premises or the contentions you have given thus far.
Last edited: