- 829
- 168
.Good morning / afternoon / night to all! I received permission from Antvasima to make a comment. And I ask you all to read carefully what I have to say, please. I know I've had questionable behaviors in the past, but I'm trying to improve.
SOME OBSERVATIONS
Well, I don't mean to go too far into this, other than give you an idea so that this can be resolved. But, obviously, I would just like to comment briefly on the points of Damage:
1 - I think Tata and Shadow, as well as Mindovin, already said what I was going to say.
2 - This shows that, practically all Mid Tiers are not able to dodge Kirin. And yes, this strongly contradicts the SPEED SCALE.
Let's read what Damage said in your favor:
" It's worth noting that Jugo has actually been managed to avoid Killer B's Lariat, and both he and Suigetsu and kept up with the Raikage and Killer B in combat to an extent."
" If Sasuke is stating he considers it impossible to evade (and he has no reason to lie here) and he knows how fast these other characters are, that absolutely implies that these characters are slower tha Kirin ..."
" That does not mean Sasuke is wrong when it comes to the unavoidable part of his statement, at least in terms of the characters whose combat speed Sasuke is familiar with..."
"... the point of Sasuke's statement is not to rule out the entire verse as being incapable of dodging or blocking Kirin. That's ignoring who made the statement and when. Instead we need to look at characters who Sasuke has knowledge of their combat speed at this time (as in, not Minato or Killer B, etc.) but characters like Orochimaru, Deidara, Itachi, Kakashi, Karin, Jugo, Suigetsu, etc..."
^ This does not contradict Lariat at any time. The same is a move used by a character much faster than Kirin itself, to the point of dodging Amaterasu at close range.
And as said by Sasuke, the owner of the technique himself... Kirin, like Amaterasu, is impossible to evade or block, which of course is comparing to its speed, just as the statement says. It is also noteworthy that ... Itachi was able to block him, not only with little chakra, blind and a serious illness ... But Zetsu himself said that Itachi's reactions were not at their maximum:
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0390-021.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0390-022.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0389-008.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0389-009.png
Konohamaru keep up with Pain.
Suigetsu and Juugo.
They are all outliers, quickly refuted soon after in the manga.
That is ... This point proves nothing but a SPEED SCALING error, as Damage said, while sustaining this point.
Using this to disqualify Lariat is an Association Fallacy. Discard a information because what they did with that information is wrong.
3 - This point only sustains the speed scale error. It proves that Mid Tiers like Shikamaru and co are barely able to react to a Raiton, and make it impossible for Kirin to be avoided by them.
But that does not affect Lariat or the High Tiers who are involved with the feat, such as Taka Sasuke, Ay and Bee, Naruto KCM and co.
4 - I'm sure the Lariat passed 3 CRT before being applied.
5 - It does not contradict Lariat (in fact, Lariat supports it) and these arguments were refuted by Jvando and Tata in the last CRT that involved this statement.
A LITTLE DOWNGRADE
The first thing I think is right to do, is to decrease the percentage of light speed of the Lariat. I think only 10% of SoL is extremely more consistent, as proposed by DarkDragonMedeus and I'm pretty sure Shadow agreed with that too (though if not, sorry!).
This would also make Kisame's feat somewhat Sub-Relativistic (Mach 21578.6 aka 2% of the SoL), which would still be consistent with what was presented on the verse, becoming about 3x faster than Adult Shino's or about 7x faster than Kakashi Immortal Arc. We have several feats MHS to MHS+ which were shown by extremely slow characters compared to any High Tier and even by some Mid Tiers, or feats MHS + casually acquired by High Tiers from the verse. These feats would be :
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/U...ou/Boruto'Calc_-_Sumire_responds_to_lightning
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/U...Kakashi_intercepts_Kakuzu's_Lightning_Release
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:AlexSoloVaAlFuturo/Sasuke's_Kirin_speed
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:TataHakai/Bit_Feat_from_the_Last
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:M3X/Boruto:_Shino_is_faster_than_you_think
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/U...ns_-_Konohamaru_Doing_Something_With_His_Life
Since we have a lot of casual High Tiers feats (Like Onoki) and a lot of MHS to MHS + Low-Mid Tiers feats... Decreasing the percentage of Lariat relative to the speed of light is one of the best ways to make the speed completely consistent in verse.
It also makes it much more consistent with Madara's dodge of Tenso no Jutsu :
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:AlexSoloVaAlFuturo/Naruto_-_I_Have_No_Comments
No mistery! If the Lariat have 10% of the SoL, Madara's feat will be extremely more consistent!
This will affect basically all the High Tiers and it would affect virtually no Mid Tier or at least, not that I'm remembering right now.
ISSUES WITH THE SCALING
Now, I will present an extreme problem with the current scale and as I think it could improve a little. And I will use my way of thinking about it, that is, as if the Lariat percentage downgrade is applied. Basically, the issues with the scaling is :
Although the statement contradicts moments ahead, it gives us the idea that no one at or below his speed level will be able to react or defend himself.
• Suigetsu and Juugo's feats reacting to Bee and Ay's Lariat are basically Outliers. And I will explain some contradictions that have happened in several scenes, to show that such deeds are at best extremely DOUBTFUL.
Juugo was completely and casually subjugated by Base Bee :
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0410-006.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0410-019.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0410-020.png
And even took a speedblitz of Bee in front of him, more of one time. He also reacted to Ay LCM, but easily took several Ay speedblitz, which is comparable to V1 Bee :
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-003.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-004.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-005.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-007.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-015.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-016.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0413-012.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0413-013.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0462-004.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0462-005.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0462-007.png
Even Sasuke will be subjugated with Base Bee in speed, and only reacted to Killer B because he has linear motions and his sharingan helped him :
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0411-017.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0411-018.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0413-010.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0413-011.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0413-014.png
Suigetsu is at most comparable to Juugo. So, it's also outlier for him.
SUPPORT FOR THE STATEMENT
Obviously, the statement comes from Databook, a source written and produced by Kishimoto. And it basically makes a difference between the Verse High Tiers, and all the lower Tiers.
Several characters, who easily are MHS+, classify the Raikages as "super fast / extremely fast" or as having extreme speed.
As a demonstration of this, we have several feats :
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0462-003.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0463-014.png
That is, we have a huge difference in verse speed, especially between the Mid and High Tiers. And Lariat is basically the one that defines the difference.
SUPPORTING CONSISTENCY
As stated above, we have also made Madara react and defend herself against Tsunade and Ay while wrapped in Tenso no Jutsu.
Madara, being one of the strongest Top Tiers on the verse, was able to fend off a jutsu that made the object go to speed of light.
Of course, this also shows that there is also a noticeable difference between Top Tiers and High Tiers.
Muu, one of the best sensors on the verse and being able to easily dodge Naruto KCM, being as or even faster than Ay Top Speed and Minato, was unable to catch him off guard and while his back was on, thanks to his great sensory capacity.
However, he was unable to defend himself from Ay Base and Madara was barely able to react to a Tsunade with several injuries.
This not only shows that Madara is much faster than them, but it also shows extreme difficulty defending against speed of light attacks, although it can.
CONCLUSION
With us downgraded a little the Lariat percentage to around 10% and fixing the obvious scaling error that we have today, removing the outliers and making a correct scale. All scaling can be done as accurately as possible.
And the scale would basically be accurate:
SOME OBSERVATIONS
Well, I don't mean to go too far into this, other than give you an idea so that this can be resolved. But, obviously, I would just like to comment briefly on the points of Damage:
1 - I think Tata and Shadow, as well as Mindovin, already said what I was going to say.
2 - This shows that, practically all Mid Tiers are not able to dodge Kirin. And yes, this strongly contradicts the SPEED SCALE.
Let's read what Damage said in your favor:
" It's worth noting that Jugo has actually been managed to avoid Killer B's Lariat, and both he and Suigetsu and kept up with the Raikage and Killer B in combat to an extent."
" If Sasuke is stating he considers it impossible to evade (and he has no reason to lie here) and he knows how fast these other characters are, that absolutely implies that these characters are slower tha Kirin ..."
" That does not mean Sasuke is wrong when it comes to the unavoidable part of his statement, at least in terms of the characters whose combat speed Sasuke is familiar with..."
"... the point of Sasuke's statement is not to rule out the entire verse as being incapable of dodging or blocking Kirin. That's ignoring who made the statement and when. Instead we need to look at characters who Sasuke has knowledge of their combat speed at this time (as in, not Minato or Killer B, etc.) but characters like Orochimaru, Deidara, Itachi, Kakashi, Karin, Jugo, Suigetsu, etc..."
^ This does not contradict Lariat at any time. The same is a move used by a character much faster than Kirin itself, to the point of dodging Amaterasu at close range.
And as said by Sasuke, the owner of the technique himself... Kirin, like Amaterasu, is impossible to evade or block, which of course is comparing to its speed, just as the statement says. It is also noteworthy that ... Itachi was able to block him, not only with little chakra, blind and a serious illness ... But Zetsu himself said that Itachi's reactions were not at their maximum:
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0390-021.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0390-022.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0389-008.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0389-009.png
Konohamaru keep up with Pain.
Suigetsu and Juugo.
They are all outliers, quickly refuted soon after in the manga.
That is ... This point proves nothing but a SPEED SCALING error, as Damage said, while sustaining this point.
Using this to disqualify Lariat is an Association Fallacy. Discard a information because what they did with that information is wrong.
3 - This point only sustains the speed scale error. It proves that Mid Tiers like Shikamaru and co are barely able to react to a Raiton, and make it impossible for Kirin to be avoided by them.
But that does not affect Lariat or the High Tiers who are involved with the feat, such as Taka Sasuke, Ay and Bee, Naruto KCM and co.
4 - I'm sure the Lariat passed 3 CRT before being applied.
5 - It does not contradict Lariat (in fact, Lariat supports it) and these arguments were refuted by Jvando and Tata in the last CRT that involved this statement.
A LITTLE DOWNGRADE
The first thing I think is right to do, is to decrease the percentage of light speed of the Lariat. I think only 10% of SoL is extremely more consistent, as proposed by DarkDragonMedeus and I'm pretty sure Shadow agreed with that too (though if not, sorry!).
This would also make Kisame's feat somewhat Sub-Relativistic (Mach 21578.6 aka 2% of the SoL), which would still be consistent with what was presented on the verse, becoming about 3x faster than Adult Shino's or about 7x faster than Kakashi Immortal Arc. We have several feats MHS to MHS+ which were shown by extremely slow characters compared to any High Tier and even by some Mid Tiers, or feats MHS + casually acquired by High Tiers from the verse. These feats would be :
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/U...ou/Boruto'Calc_-_Sumire_responds_to_lightning
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/U...Kakashi_intercepts_Kakuzu's_Lightning_Release
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:AlexSoloVaAlFuturo/Sasuke's_Kirin_speed
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:TataHakai/Bit_Feat_from_the_Last
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:M3X/Boruto:_Shino_is_faster_than_you_think
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/U...ns_-_Konohamaru_Doing_Something_With_His_Life
Since we have a lot of casual High Tiers feats (Like Onoki) and a lot of MHS to MHS + Low-Mid Tiers feats... Decreasing the percentage of Lariat relative to the speed of light is one of the best ways to make the speed completely consistent in verse.
It also makes it much more consistent with Madara's dodge of Tenso no Jutsu :
https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/User_blog:AlexSoloVaAlFuturo/Naruto_-_I_Have_No_Comments
No mistery! If the Lariat have 10% of the SoL, Madara's feat will be extremely more consistent!
This will affect basically all the High Tiers and it would affect virtually no Mid Tier or at least, not that I'm remembering right now.
ISSUES WITH THE SCALING
Now, I will present an extreme problem with the current scale and as I think it could improve a little. And I will use my way of thinking about it, that is, as if the Lariat percentage downgrade is applied. Basically, the issues with the scaling is :
- Kakashi is rated as Massively Hypersonic+ for a speed calc of his, but his justification also mentions him keeping up with Pain who is Relativistic for being comparable to Kisame.
- Kabuto is rated as Massively Hypersonic+ for keeping up with Tsunade, but Tsunade is Relativistic+.
- Deidara is rated as Relativistic for being faster than Hidan, but Hidan is Massively Hypersonic+.
- Sasuke is rated as Massively Hypersonic+ for keeping up with Itachi but Itachi is Relativistic.
- Danzo is rated as Relativistic for keeping up with Sasuke but Sasuke is Relativistic+.
- Tenten is Massively Hypersonic+ for fighting a clone of Kisame who is Relativistic.
- Sai Yamanaka is Massively Hypersonic+ for fighting Sasuke and Deidara who are all Relativistic.
- Hanzo is Massively Hypersonic+ for battling Jiraiya, Tsunade and Orochimaru who are all Relativistic+.
- Menma Uzumaki is Massively Hypersonic+ for keeping up with Naruto who is Relativistic.
- Kakashi scales to MHS+ on Immortal Arc. Must be Sub-Relativístic in Pain's Arc, as he keeping up with Tendo and for being comparable to Kisame.
- Kabuto must be MHS+ in its Base and Kabutomaru forms. Only your Sage Mode need to be Sub-Relativístic, for keeping up with Sasuke EMS and Edo Itachi.
- Deidara should be only MHS+, for keeping up with Hebi Sasuke. Edo Deidara also keep up with Onoki and could be Sub-Relativistic, but it is debatable and I don't know if it would be characterized as Outlier or not.
- Sasuke BoS and Hebi Sasuke should be just MHS+ for keeping up with a Sick Itachi and for react to Kirin. Sasuke Taka must be Sub-Relativistic, for keeping up with Killer B V1 and Casual LCM Ay. I would also think better to create a key for Sick Itachi. He is clearly not that fast and was declared by Zetsu to be with his extremely precarious reaction and speed.
- Danzo should be Sub-Relativístic for keeping up with Taka Sasuke.
- Tenten should be MHS+. Keeping up with a Kisame clone can easily be characterized as an Outlier, and yet, it has been said that he has only 30% of his power, which means that he was at speed or power at his peak.
- Sai should be only MHS+ for keeping up with Hebi Sasuke.
- Hanzo should be Sub-Relativistic, along with all the Legendary Sanins.
- Menma Uzumaki should be, at most, Sub-Relativístic for keeping up with Sage Mode Naruto.
- Suigetsu and Juugo should be MHS+, probably for by being comparable to Base Naruto and Kakashi Immortal Arc.
Although the statement contradicts moments ahead, it gives us the idea that no one at or below his speed level will be able to react or defend himself.
• Suigetsu and Juugo's feats reacting to Bee and Ay's Lariat are basically Outliers. And I will explain some contradictions that have happened in several scenes, to show that such deeds are at best extremely DOUBTFUL.
Juugo was completely and casually subjugated by Base Bee :
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0410-006.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0410-019.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0410-020.png
And even took a speedblitz of Bee in front of him, more of one time. He also reacted to Ay LCM, but easily took several Ay speedblitz, which is comparable to V1 Bee :
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-003.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-004.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-005.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-007.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-015.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0412-016.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0413-012.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0413-013.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0462-004.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0462-005.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0462-007.png
Even Sasuke will be subjugated with Base Bee in speed, and only reacted to Killer B because he has linear motions and his sharingan helped him :
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0411-017.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0411-018.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0413-010.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0413-011.png
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0413-014.png
Suigetsu is at most comparable to Juugo. So, it's also outlier for him.
SUPPORT FOR THE STATEMENT
Obviously, the statement comes from Databook, a source written and produced by Kishimoto. And it basically makes a difference between the Verse High Tiers, and all the lower Tiers.
Several characters, who easily are MHS+, classify the Raikages as "super fast / extremely fast" or as having extreme speed.
As a demonstration of this, we have several feats :
- Bee speeding Juugo and traveling hundreds of meters before anyone could notice him.
- We have Ay LCM casually being able to dodge Juugo FCS attacks at close range and attacking him quickly and saying that a mere Sharingan could not defeat him and this is confirmed by C :
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0462-003.png
- We have Ay Top Speed being able to avoid Amaterasu at close range, which is said to be comparable to Kirin and cannot be dodged or blocked :
- We have Ay Top Speed managing to escape Sasuke's vision:
https://**********.com/manga/Naruto/0463-014.png
That is, we have a huge difference in verse speed, especially between the Mid and High Tiers. And Lariat is basically the one that defines the difference.
SUPPORTING CONSISTENCY
As stated above, we have also made Madara react and defend herself against Tsunade and Ay while wrapped in Tenso no Jutsu.
Madara, being one of the strongest Top Tiers on the verse, was able to fend off a jutsu that made the object go to speed of light.
Of course, this also shows that there is also a noticeable difference between Top Tiers and High Tiers.
Muu, one of the best sensors on the verse and being able to easily dodge Naruto KCM, being as or even faster than Ay Top Speed and Minato, was unable to catch him off guard and while his back was on, thanks to his great sensory capacity.
However, he was unable to defend himself from Ay Base and Madara was barely able to react to a Tsunade with several injuries.
This not only shows that Madara is much faster than them, but it also shows extreme difficulty defending against speed of light attacks, although it can.
CONCLUSION
With us downgraded a little the Lariat percentage to around 10% and fixing the obvious scaling error that we have today, removing the outliers and making a correct scale. All scaling can be done as accurately as possible.
And the scale would basically be accurate:
- Low Tiers range from MHS to MHS+ at most.
- All the Mid Tiers will be MHS+. And none Mid Tier would range to Sub-Relativistic, with perhaps some exceptions to some Akatsuki's Edo versions (Debatable!).
- High Tiers would become Sub-Relativistic, with Bee and Ay having an attack that can be rushed at Relativistic Speed. None of them would become Relativistic in Combat Speed.
- Only Top Tiers and God Tiers at the very least would be Relativistic.