- 31,637
- 34,656
DontTalkDT makes sense to me as usual.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I wonder in which translation it says it starts from tloid. I read the series from about 3 different sites and translations and all of them were that the tloi would always be at the top, starting with the dreamer and going to the tloi, and this is the most logical and consistent with the series. Yoshie's narrative, which starts with "you hate fiction but you live in fiction" in the series, again supports that this is true from the bottom up.I don't have the time to read this completely or make a big response right now, but let me make this clear: at the very least a downgrade to 1-A/1-B should be absolutely guaranteed even if the "layers" are assumed to be transcendences. I asked for the raws on the previous thread as well, but since no one provided them we should give the official translation preference, where the dream hierarchy mentioned in context of the law of identity is downwards starting from it, instead of being upwards like the fantranslation. And honestly that makes 100% more sense than the fantranslation as well. Law of identity as an entity in the series is represented as the first being in existence who dreamed the first dream and started the hierarchy. It would make sense to give the example of an infinite downward hierarchy and how it can always be traced back to the top.
Oh and the multi layered fiction mentioned in volume 13 was referring to 4th wall breaking in context. I already talked about that on the original thread. It had nothing to do with the dream hierarchy in the journal.
Hence at best it would still be 1-C/1-B. I may try making a bigger post if I get the time,though honestly the writing of this verse is repulsive to me.
It is true, but with your logic, I will prepare a crt so that cthulhu downgrade will be downgrade, and then a group of people will say I agree regardless of whether it is right or wrong, and cthulhu will fall.
By "starting" I meant LOI is at the top. It is represented as the first being in existence who started the hierarchyI wonder in which translation it says it starts from tloid. I read the series from about 3 different sites and translations and all of them were that the tloi would always be at the top, starting with the dreamer and going to the tloi, and this is the most logical and consistent with the series. Yoshie's narrative, which starts with "you hate fiction but you live in fiction" in the series, again supports that this is true from the bottom up.
When you take away everything from the Law of Identity except itself, you are left with yourself, facing your law of identity. That person is the first. Imagine a dreamer dreaming of a world wherein a dreamer dreams of a world where in a dreamer dreams... and so on, and so forth for infinity, but as long as one person is there, facing his own law of identity, that person is the first. And that person has swallowed up all of existence and all life
“A story that’s revealed to be a story. The deus ex machina that appears at just the right moment isn’t there for the sake of catharsis. It has appeared to tell us what it is that we were thinking is a story, and tell us that is fictional. What that god tells us is the pleasure of a story, and its limits. And now, we’ve become the deus ex machina. We ourselves have become the god.” Boichiro pointed to himself, and then back to Brave.
Even then, I think what DT has shown serves as some kind of evidence of R>F layers in the verseWe never actually see any explicit R>F hierarchy show up in this volume.
If 20 people come out and say that this universe must be 10b, should it be like this? While low 2c feats are flying in that universe, you take what I want to tell elsewhere.Imagine using that as an example against something I(the one who already attempted a Cthulhu downgrade before) said.
I don't think that this prevents him from having an infinite hierarchy to reach it. As a creator, that is the beginning of everything. and in the same way, no matter how high you go, it will be the person you meet.By "starting" I meant LOI is at the top. It is represented as the first being in existence who started the hierarchy
Yoshie's words and words have nothing to do with the 4th wall. tells what is described in the dream hierarchy in a different way, with the same result. I mean, I'm extremely surprised how you read that quote and made a sense of breaking the 4th wall.The "dream hierarchy" mentioned here is downwards, and is logically more consistent since it's talking about how LOI is at the top and no matter how many layers the downward hierarchy has, you can always trace it back to the origin at the top.
And the stuff in Volume 13 was talking about breaking the 4th wall in context, not transcendence:
I agree with DT. First of all, let's discuss whether there is a r>f hierarchy or not, if there is, we will discuss the amount.Let me suggest again that we should preferably talk about the amount of reality-fiction layers in its own thread once we have established that the reality-fiction layers that there are (however many) are legit.
I will try to read the entire post later when I get time. Kinda busy with college rn.Even then, I think what DT has shown serves as some kind of evidence of R>F layers in the verse
The sad thing is, if you can get majority support for that argument it would actually be like that. Since that's how this website works. Exaggerated example but you get the meaning ofc.If 20 people come out and say that this universe must be 10b, should it be like this? While low 2c feats are flying in that universe, you take what I want to tell elsewhere.
We have to look at the context. The translation I posted uses a downwards infinite hierarchy.I don't think that this prevents him from having an infinite hierarchy to reach it. As a creator, that is the beginning of everything. and in the same way, no matter how high you go, it will be the person you meet.
Yoshie's quote comes in the next page of the quote I posted, and it clarifies that the "multi layered" fiction is talking about breaking the 4th wall in context, with them realising they are fictional(story that is revealed to be a story).Yoshie's words and words have nothing to do with the 4th wall. tells what is described in the dream hierarchy in a different way, with the same result. I mean, I'm extremely surprised how you read that quote and made a sense of breaking the 4th wall.
Personally I would prefer moving in a sequential manner with the downgrade (aka firstly removing High 1-A and 1-A) and moving onto the layers after that. Mainly because I am a bit busy these days and would like to finalize the aspects of the downgrade that are easy to discuss before moving onto the more tedious aspects, since these kind of threads are quick to be closedLet me suggest again that we should preferably talk about the amount of reality-fiction layers in its own thread once we have established that the reality-fiction layers that there are (however many) are legit.
this is how this wiki worked i am sure i will see 2A naruto low 1c bleach. In fact, at the end of the day, the mods decide the decision, not the members' fra. This is what I've seen during my time on this wiki.The sad thing is, if you can get majority support for that argument it would actually be like that. Since that's how this website works. Exaggerated example but you get the meaning ofc.
I didn't know there was an official translation of this series. If so, can you send me the official translation link?We have to look at the context. The translation I posted uses a downwards infinite hierarchy.
And even if we assume it's an upward hierarchy, it would still be High 1-B since in context it's just the top of the hierarchy.
that is, yoshie talks about the first fiction that Akuto destroyed. He talks about not one, but infinite ones. so there are infinite 4th wall layers? Also, do you call the world Akuto destroyed as actually breaking a 4th wall? They are told as higher versions of fiction destroyed by akuton? it completely contradicts everything you said and creates an extremely illogical situation. I am in a box and when I destroyed it but realized there is another box. The one next to me said that there are infinitely many of these boxes. but you say that after the 1st box is to break the 4th wall, it is defined as the larger version of the first box that I destroyed, while the 2nd box makes no sense whatsoever you look at it.Yoshie's quote comes in the next page of the quote I posted, and it clarifies that the "multi layered" fiction is talking about breaking the 4th wall in context, with them realising they are fictional(story that is revealed to be a story).
If I want I can technically call the conclusion that the "multi layer" story is referring to R>F layers a non sequitur since it never elaborates what these layers are. That's why the quote that talks about a story revealed to be a story is important since it contextualises these layers.
The thing is: I don't really agree with your estimate that these would be easy to dicuss. We had a thread on the subject of the amount of layers not long ago and IIRC it took literally months to conclude.Personally I would prefer moving in a sequential manner with the downgrade (aka firstly removing High 1-A and 1-A) and moving onto the layers after that. Mainly because I am a bit busy these days and would like to finalize the aspects of the downgrade that are easy to discuss before moving onto the more tedious aspects, since these kind of threads are quick to be closed
I don't think this discussion will last long.The thing is: I don't really agree with your estimate that these would be easy to dicuss. We had a thread on that subject not long ago and IIRC it took literally months to conclude.
Wdym by that?I don't think this discussion will last long.
I actually think it will take a long time. I don't know why I wrote that.Wdym by that?
Where did Akuto destroy the original world? Curious since I have only read the last volume.Also, do you call the world Akuto destroyed as actually breaking a 4th wall?
No it doesn't. We are never told what the verse means by the "layers". It could also be that the original story was just a volume in a bigger story. These would be "layers" but still won't have a transcendent difference. Saying it can only refer to Reality>Fiction layers is just tunnel vision.it completely contradicts everything you said and creates an extremely illogical situation. I am in a box and when I destroyed it but realized there is another box.
You had a fetish for revealing that which was fictional, and kept doing it again and again.
If you compare the controversial nature of the arguments then discussing this topic first would definitely be less tedious.The thing is: I don't really agree with your estimate that these would be easy to dicuss. We had a thread on the subject of the amount of layers not long ago and IIRC it took literally months to conclude.
“I’m going to go a step beyond that. How about I crush this world in my grasp?”Where did Akuto destroy the original world? Curious since I have only read the last volume.
I don't quite understand what you mean here. So I will answer as I understand it. The concept of story within a story is the same as a dream within a dream. if i create a character who writes a story as a story writer. The story within the story exists, the same as a dream within a dream. the author gives us the same thing in 2 different ways, two different ways of expression, writing on a piece of paper or having a dream; What these two have in common is that they both represent fiction. It is fiction that a person sees in a dream. In the story he wrote, what is fiction for the person who sees the dream is real for the individuals in the dream. Likewise, the character in the story I wrote is real according to himself and fiction for me. The layers of fiction and the hierarchy of dreams mean the same or similar things precisely because of what I've described.It seems like a very simple conclusion that it is contextualised by the "story that is revealed to be a story" that was mentioned few paragraphs prior.
But that's literally afterlife? All Akuto did was destroy and rebuild it later. It was never said he transcended to some layer above the afterlife.Akuto destroys the reality that consists only of the world he is in.
Not by default. As I said, a case of tunnel vision. A story inside story can also mean the former is part of some bigger story. For example Umineko's story is part of the bigger when they cry franchise.The concept of story within a story is the same as a dream within a dream. if i create a character who writes a story as a story writer. The story within the story exists, the same as a dream within a dream.
It is said that after destroying it, another system came into play. so what you said is wrongBut that's literally afterlife? All Akuto did was destroy and rebuild it later. It was never said he transcended to some layer above the afterlife
It is the things that the series offers me that made me do this whole thing. If 2+2=4 is no different than saying 2+3=5 in my opinion. because, as I said, the author explains to us that stories are real for the person who wrote them, for the person in the fiction. that is, the author tells us "this is a fiction" in both of them and says that there is infinity in these two fictions. the person who dreams endlessly and the person who writes stories endlessly above each other. Even if you say these are different things, both are infinite reality fiction step, layer or step. Whatever you name it, the author explains to us what the stories are like, when they're fictional, and when they're real. This world was fiction. But it was also real. This wiki, which I tried to say, is an obvious reality for the outsider, for the inside fiction. relations work exactly as in the quote nu, naturally there is no problem with this dimensional layering.But that's literally afterlife? All Akuto did was destroy and rebuild it later. It was never said he transcended to some layer above the afterlife.
Not by default. As I said, a case of tunnel vision. A story inside story can also mean the former is part of some bigger story. For example Umineko's story is part of the bigger when they cry franchise.
You're right, but feats don't fly in DKDIf 20 people come out and say that this universe must be 10b, should it be like this? While low 2c feats are flying in that universe, you take what I want to tell elsewhere.
you tell me how it works in ümeniko, I tell you how it works in this series. Or rather, I'm trying to explain. the contexts given to us by the author, the narrations, the way the story works, we can understand some things ourselves, right? The author need not say anything to show that an apple is an apple. I think you or anyone else can figure out what is an apple and what is a plastic ball.Not by default. As I said, a case of tunnel vision. A story inside story can also mean the former is part of some bigger story. For example Umineko's story is part of the bigger when they cry franchise.
It doesn't matter if you don't see success, it is extremely surprising for me that you can say "there is no success in the series" without knowing about the series. If you're ignoring the two infinite fiction reality hierarchies and their operation fits perfectly into the stratification of the wiki and saying "no success", I can only say this: I'm not Jesus, I can't heal a blind person.You're right, but feats don't fly in DKD
And the downgrade is inevitable, as, apparently, the tier 4 universe wasn't refuted, and tier 1 stuff are still being discussed, but they're definitely not staying the way they're now
Talk like a human, please, who said DKD has no "success"?..... Makes no senseIt doesn't matter if you don't see success, it is extremely surprising for me that you can say "there is no success in the series" without knowing about the series. If you're ignoring the two infinite fiction reality hierarchies and their operation fits perfectly into the stratification of the wiki and saying "no success", I can only say this: I'm not Jesus, I can't heal a blind person.
He never does, only earth is destroyed, in fact he returns back to the original world at the very end when he meets up with korone the original universe (solar system ) it never gets destroyedWhere did Akuto destroy the original world? Curious since I have only read the last volume.
That wasn’t talking about the afterlife thought to be fairIt is said that after destroying it, another system came into play. so what you said is wrong
No one refuted it cus it literally had no relevancy to the current tier, this was stated multiple times in the original threadYou're right, but feats don't fly in DKD
And the downgrade is inevitable, as, apparently, the tier 4 universe wasn't refuted, and tier 1 stuff are still being discussed, but they're definitely not staying the way they're now
What I am trying to say is that you do not read this series and say that there is no success at this level without knowing it. According to whom, if you know, discuss with me the same as darksmash did, but all you do is there is no success from where you are, there is no success. You first communicate with me in a healthy way and I will talk to you like a human. nothing is clear yet, the discussion is not over, it's still going on and you are talking as if you came from the future. You may find other people's arguments logical, but your ignoring my arguments and speaking nonsense is as human as the example I gave. I think you know that I told you that you don't want to see when you say you are blind, anyway, I won't argue any more for today. because I have work, if you have arguments against me, bring them, or instead of talking, please wait for the people who are arguing to finish their discussion. Unless your side is clear and you don't offer arguments or anything, all your comments pile up unnecessarily. Anyway, that's all from me for today. Good day to everyoneTalk like a human, please, who said DKD has no "success"?..... Makes no sense
Meh I'll just wait for @DontTalkDT and @Shuradou
If you want, let's talk privately. I don't want to reply to this discussion any more today.That wasn’t talking about the afterlife thought to be fair
I know it's irrelevant, that is for the tier 1 keysNo one refuted it cus it literally had no relevancy to the current tier, this was stated multiple times in the original thread
Who ever said i have arguments against you? Guys, please, I'm clearly talking about the tier 2 keys.....What I am trying to say is that you do not read this series and say that there is no success at this level without knowing it. According to whom, if you know, discuss with me the same as darksmash did, but all you do is there is no success from where you are, there is no success. You first communicate with me in a healthy way and I will talk to you like a human. nothing is clear yet, the discussion is not over, it's still going on and you are talking as if you came from the future. You may find other people's arguments logical, but your ignoring my arguments and speaking nonsense is as human as the example I gave. I think you know that I told you that you don't want to see when you say you are blind, anyway, I won't argue any more for today. because I have work, if you have arguments against me, bring them, or instead of talking, please wait for the people who are arguing to finish their discussion. Unless your side is clear and you don't offer arguments or anything, all your comments pile up unnecessarily. Anyway, that's all from me for today. Good day to everyone
No my point still stands, the original universe is tier 4 it has nothing to do with tier 2 keys, tier 2 comes from virtual alternate dimension, no one scales to the baseline universeI know it's irrelevant, that is for the tier 1 keys
Seems that no one cares about the tier 2 keys, then?
Alrighty will do so,If you want, let's talk privately. I don't want to reply to this discussion any more today.
Who ever said i have arguments against you? Guys, please, I'm clearly talking about the tier 2 keys.....
Oh, seems i have to reread stuff, sorryNo my point still stands, the original universe is tier 4 it has nothing to do with tier 2 keys, tier 2 comes from virtual alternate dimension, no one scales to the baseline universe
It's fineoh ! my mistake i'm so sorry. i misunderstood
But nobody is ignoring you. They just happen to disagree with the current ratingsWhat I am trying to say is that you do not read this series and say that there is no success at this level without knowing it. According to whom, if you know, discuss with me the same as darksmash did, but all you do is there is no success from where you are, there is no success. You first communicate with me in a healthy way and I will talk to you like a human. nothing is clear yet, the discussion is not over, it's still going on and you are talking as if you came from the future. You may find other people's arguments logical, but your ignoring my arguments and speaking nonsense is as human as the example I gave. I think you know that I told you that you don't want to see when you say you are blind, anyway, I won't argue any more for today. because I have work, if you have arguments against me, bring them, or instead of talking, please wait for the people who are arguing to finish their discussion. Unless your side is clear and you don't offer arguments or anything, all your comments pile up unnecessarily. Anyway, that's all from me for today. Good day to everyone
I think it looks like L2c. My faultThough tbh the tier 2 is more than likely, high-3A.