Genshin 4A downgrade...

[Breakdown]

Yeah, a rotted and corrupted Khemia creation of a Khaenriah-era Rhinedottir overpowers the Barbatos who was active during the Cataclysm - do with that info what you will /shrug

Your argument has several flaws.
1: Not every Hexenzirkel is of equal strength, Mona is even a member. Are we going to start scaling Mona above the Archons?
2: Alchemy is basically the science of mixing stuff together. Khemia is just very advanced alchemy. There is no reason that should in any way be a UES.
3: Being very good at Khemia doesn’t mean that all of Rhinedottir’s stats suddenly scale. This would be like saying that a really good nuclear physicist is City Level.
4: Every Extant Archon save Makoto was stronger than Barbatos. Durin being stronger than Barbatos at best means it’s as strong as one of them.

So, even if all of what you are saying is true, the Hexenzirkel scale above two of the archons. The scaling chain isn’t broken by this.

 

[GarrixianXD]

Do you not see the irony of saying this while also agreeing with the 4-A rating?

There's a difference between giving birth to a child and creating an entire Universe, so...

 

[Breakdown]

The world was previously nothing more than a history book.

Even after its "creation", its existence is "equivalent to the fiction of the real world", and is still compared to a dream.

And as if that weren't enough, the world still exists ONLY in the book, and not outside of it.

Alice's magic has been shown to be basically: She speaks a few words, and the thing is created.
With no mention of any kind of UES, as far as can be proven, it is just a "pocket dimension" hax.

Being that both the Simulanka and the theater space exist only within books;
there is no mention of UES or any type of energy for/in its creation;
Simulanka existence is compared to fiction and a dream (they don't exist, and this also counts for Theater, since as far as we know, they both probably use creation magic);
They do not meet any vbw criteria for scaling a "pocket dimension" to something other than just creation hax.

Clearly, the part where the "fantasy becomes more real", is just what I said, the world/reality "exists" as a "normal reality", but, ONLY inside the book, while from the outside, it would just be like a dream, something equivalent to fiction (it doesn't really exist).

Alice’s magic works on consciousness (I speak and I create), and elemental energy users were also shown to be able to change a Realm of Consciousness by letting out enough raw energy. They are equivalent, especially since the elements are abstract things in true nature. Maybe some magics are not, but these ones are.

 

[Furina003]

Okay, even discounting whether they're all relative or not (especially disagree on Barbatos being above Boreas 'undoubtedly', since Boreas gave up on the Gnosis by his own decision), the Archons being above Alice 'ideally' may be the case, but certainly not 'logically' in any way. If you recall, Rhinedottir, a member of the Hexenzirkel, literally created Durin and Barbatos HAD to get Dvalin's help to defeat it, couldn't even solo it to save his entire country. So here we have the Witches' creations outcompeting Archons already.

Now, I AM assuming here that the Witches we know about are all relative between eachother (exception of Mona), but it's a more reasonable assumption to make than others, I personally believe.

you are wrong if you equate this with the durin case, durin is a creature native to the abyss, gold only provides a body, you can read here, you forgot that mavuika even needs the xbalanque power that she got from ronova to destroy gosoythoth?

 

[Furina003]

Alice is just a witch from the Old Monstadt era, and she is the defender of Old Monstadt, while Decarabian is the god who leads Old Monstadt, which means Alice has a level below Decarabian,
Decarabian was defeated by Barbatos in a fight.

In my opinion, this is very good as a basis for scaling, at least Alice has a level below/equivalent to Archon

From here it also makes sense why Hexenzirkle challenged Barbatos to a fight, because Alice is the elder and founder of Hexenzirkle.