- 21,390
- 2,978
Previous threads: The beginning. Hopefully the middle.
So, these revisions have been going on for like 4-5 months but hopefully we can conclude it in this thread. For those that don't want to look through the previous threads and would like to get a summary, the calc that all 7-B/7-A Servants used to scale to is outdated and other attempts at finding calcs to support that rating have either resulted in tiers way below 7-A or are unusuable for scaling. The main conclusion seems to be to have Hercules be at baseline 7-A and then figure out which Servants scale to him or scale to those that scale to him. We also need to find a tier for the Servants that are stronger than 9-B but get oneshot by Herc and those comparable to him. However, if someone finds new evidence for a possible tier, please free to post scans/links to a calc that can be verified. If you can think of a feat but aren't sure exactly how it played it out, try to find that feat before mentioning it in the thread.
So, these revisions have been going on for like 4-5 months but hopefully we can conclude it in this thread. For those that don't want to look through the previous threads and would like to get a summary, the calc that all 7-B/7-A Servants used to scale to is outdated and other attempts at finding calcs to support that rating have either resulted in tiers way below 7-A or are unusuable for scaling. The main conclusion seems to be to have Hercules be at baseline 7-A and then figure out which Servants scale to him or scale to those that scale to him. We also need to find a tier for the Servants that are stronger than 9-B but get oneshot by Herc and those comparable to him. However, if someone finds new evidence for a possible tier, please free to post scans/links to a calc that can be verified. If you can think of a feat but aren't sure exactly how it played it out, try to find that feat before mentioning it in the thread.