- 1,744
- 1,165
Tempest makes the most sense to me.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
East Blue to Skypiea revisions.
- Thread starter Ryuga21
- Start date
- Status
- 1,744
- 1,165
- 2,692
- 952
Doubt anyone can blame tempest when debating against someone who's arguments are just straight up opinionated at this point, which is what they have been damage, you haven't convinced me either.
I agree with tempest.
I agree with tempest.
- 31,206
- 27,403
It's no excuse. Even if KingTempest believes he is right, he needs to control himself on the forum.
Who would want to argue with someone who is being so aggressive in their posts?
I'm expressing my doubt and bringing up things that I think are contradictions, and I feel like have KingTempest trying to bite my head off and calling me a liar. What kind of incentive is that to keep the discussing going?
- 2,692
- 952
Eminiteable
He/Him- 7,401
- 6,631
What Tempest said makes sense to me, I see what he's saying that the 10 times impact dial and calc for Enel are both very consistent with eachother.
Also Damage keep in mind Luffy and Sanji previously got many times stronger from just sitting around on the train ride from Water 7 to Enies Lobby, so these characters can grow stronger from seemingly doing nothing.
Also Damage keep in mind Luffy and Sanji previously got many times stronger from just sitting around on the train ride from Water 7 to Enies Lobby, so these characters can grow stronger from seemingly doing nothing.
- 2,692
- 952
Not to mention this is backed up by the statement of luffy's fruit evolving further and further, and zoro saying they've gotten stronger after every island.
- 31,206
- 27,403
The issue is that we're only applying this when it is convenient for us.
Several days pass between Alabasta and Skypiea, but Luffy and Sanji only recieve their 10 x power-ups in the hour or two after they were hit by the Impact Dial?
If these characters can change their ratings so quickly in such a short span of time, then who's to say they scale to 23.5 Kilotons when they were hit by the Impact Dial at all?
- 167,675
- 76,251
Everybody please calm down here. There is no need to get so heated up over this.
However, I suspect that it is the current ad-apocalypse that our system manager has still not shut down, that creates a lot of extra tension.
However, I suspect that it is the current ad-apocalypse that our system manager has still not shut down, that creates a lot of extra tension.
Eminiteable
He/Him- 7,401
- 6,631
You bring up a great point Damage, for accuracy sake they can be treated "at least 23.5 Kilotons" when taking the impact dial, that should account for the battle with Bellamy and the time passed.
- 31,206
- 27,403
I'll step back a bit and go through the full document being proposed later to address all of the issues that I find with it.
I think we're being far too relaxed in our scaling of characters, and this issue with the Dials is just a symptom of it. For some reason we're not even considering that we could be wrong we're just saying "These characters got several times more powerful" just to support our scaling chains.
I think we're being far too relaxed in our scaling of characters, and this issue with the Dials is just a symptom of it. For some reason we're not even considering that we could be wrong we're just saying "These characters got several times more powerful" just to support our scaling chains.
- 31,206
- 27,403
Please don't try this nonsense. We're all arguing over our opinions & interpretations here. VSBW is a site that is built on a foundation of head-canon and interpretation.
- 2,692
- 952
Their opinion is being backed up by facts, while your opinion is backed up by.... your opinion.
- 31,206
- 27,403
Both sides are back up by facts Arslan. We're both interpreting the same manga. No matter how look at it, issues are going to arise. Maybe you can overlook those issues a lot easier than I can, but that doesn't make you more right just because you can ignore things easier.
- 31,206
- 27,403
How about another point then. Why can't Enel get more powerful off-screen as well? His attack on the Moon was a lot more powerful than his calced attacks during the Skypeia arc itself.
If Sanji and Luffy can get 10 x stronger by doing nothing in the span of an hour, why can't Enel get a few times stronger with his attacks? Why not make his attack on the Moon part of a new key?
- 2,692
- 952
Ignore things? Dawg your entire premise has been "I don't think" "I think" You're interpreting the manga with nothing but those. They are giving actual facts and reasons as to why, but you're just bringing up an opinion as a counter to a fact. If anyone is ignoring things, you are, and this isn't the first time, you're the sole reason why people get sick and tired of HST scaling, because you scrutinize the living shit out of everything.
(done talking now.)
- 1,744
- 1,165
Normally, that would be the case. However, Damage, you aren't guiltless yourself. The amounts of contradictory arguments whenever it's convenient to you and strawmans makes even rationale people on this wiki lose their control over themselves, don't act like Tempest is always like that towards other people, he even goes as far to warn people before it gets too heated, he sometimes like that towards you.
For clarification, i'm not attacking you personally (you may consider it as constructive criticism), i'm explaining to you one of the reasons why people lose their control whenever they are debating with you on something, specifically explaining why some things makes sense.
(i won't talk about that any further)
Eminiteable
He/Him- 7,401
- 6,631
You bring up a good point Damage, but I
think we would need evidence of Enel's accelerated development that Luffy and Sanji have shown to conclude that.
With Luffy and Sanji we've seen before time and time again they can get stronger from seemingly doing nothing, but to my knowledge not with Enel.
Last edited:
- 31,206
- 27,403
The unsubtle insinuation of "Facts > Opinions" meaning you're dismissing everything the opposition is saying and acting like other side is the only rational option.
You and StrawHatArslan are contributing nothing to the thread but pointless insults.
I never said Tempest is always acting like that, stop putting words in my mouth.
I constantly face Strawman Arguments from several people in this thread in fact, and as much as I'd like to let loose on them, I try to keep myself restrained.
- 1,690
- 1,191
Is that correct damage? Or are opinions more reliable/correct than facts? I don’t even see where you would have an issue with this point.
Quote where I insulted you or anybody else I’d advise you not lie on my name and say I’m doing stuff that I am in no way doing. Just a shitty move.
If your resorting to making false claims maybe take a chill pill cus it’s a damn lie that I insulted anybody.
- 31,206
- 27,403
Your earlier post on this thread is an insult to me.
At this point you're derailing the thread. If you want to continue this, take it off of the CRT because I'll be deleting posts from this point forwards that it are off-topic.
- 1,744
- 1,165
Like i said earlier, i'm not attacking him personally, it's constructive criticism, because this is happening very frequently regarding someone accidentally attacking damage (Myself included). But, I'll drop it. Since it's derailment at this point. Anyways, do we agree with the Skypia calc or not?
- 18,727
- 13,753
Enel doesn't have Accelerated Development... Sanji and luffy do...
- 31,206
- 27,403
You've got it backwards. We give Sanji and Luffy because we're seen them improve in a short timeframe.
If Enel has shown that his destructive power is much more significant than it was before... then that is also an improvement in a short timeframe.
- 18,727
- 13,753
That's not enough for Accelerated Development tho... Right? No statement, no nothing... The only thing is devil fruit gets stronger the more you use and train them... Which we have no proof he did after getting defeated
Multiple statements as well
- 31,206
- 27,403
I'm not saying he needs the ability added to his profile. I'm saying if One Piece characters can grow significantly stronger in a short time by doing nothing, then it doesn't make a lot of sense to backscale Enel's feat on the Moon to every single one of his lightning attacks in the Skypeia arc.
- 18,727
- 13,753
But... Isn't there literally nothing telling us he got stronger tho?
luffy's elephant gun is the biggest here
Here it's smaller
This doesn't mean Fishman Island arc luffy has stronger elephant gun than wano luffy
- 8,155
- 2,589
Enel is a haki user even if he doesn't know how to armor himself with it (i.e Busoshoku), and i think all haki users have Accel develop, it (the moon feat) was also after recovering from a fight which seems to trigger AP amps many times in haki users.
- 31,206
- 27,403
There's nothing telling us his other attacks are as powerful as his attack on the Moon either.
Also truth be told, but those Elephant Guns look about the same to me. (Top left panel on the Fishman Island spread especially), but that's not really relevant.
Eminiteable
He/Him- 7,401
- 6,631
Acclerated development applies for them improving their haki proficiency specifically; as shown in the Katakuri fight, and when against stronger haki users.
So it wouldn't apply to Enel increasing his devil fruit power.
- 18,727
- 13,753
Fishman island luffy was literally a pixel to the elephant gun while on wano you can clearly see luffy...
Here's another example
I mean... Isn't that kinda common sense? The don't just get stronger because they want to...
Last edited:
- 8,155
- 2,589
But we do see then develop their potency, Luffy got strong enough to match Kata's awakening with G3 while Sanji got stronger from doing nothing, just like everyone did in Enies Lobby, not only that, but i am sure Teach saying Luffy's haki got stronger isn't a mistranslation, so even those with i still inactive haki can get stronger via fighting, so i see no reason to not give Accel Develop to their AP or to not apply it to Enel in this case.
- 18,727
- 13,753
Enel haven't unlocked armament...
When did sanji get stronger by doing nothing?
Need more context... Don't have to tho
That was probably conquerors haki... All haki gets stronger in battle not their actual stats...
- 31,206
- 27,403
Sorry, meant top-right panel.
No. Enel's attacks explicitly vary in power. He even names them according to this sometimes. What I've been seeing though in the proposals is that all of Enel's attacks are being considered to be as powerful as his most powerful feat.
- 1,744
- 1,165
Neither did Luffy during Impel down arc. Every lifeform has Haki within themselves. Blackbeard saying that to Luffy, heavily implies you don't necessarily need to unlock either Busoshoku Haki or Kenbunshoku Haki. Since you always had both inside you, thus gets stronger in battles or other methods.
Eminiteable
He/Him- 7,401
- 6,631
Why are you assuming those examples are due to Haki's acclerated development?
- 18,727
- 13,753
which attacks exactly? El thor is one of enels most powerful one which should be comparable with thunder dragon and shock release- Status
