You are missing the point since meaning is bound to conscious judgment or perception. If the beings doing the perceiving are bound to reality, then in a roundabout way, the concept would be as well since they would be bound to that which is bound to reality. For instance, if I erased the timeline, the perception never happened and the concept never existed. This goes in direct opposition to what a type one concept is.
So isn't what is referred to here as the "universe" basically all of reality? Or is it just one of an infinite number universes?
Because in order for something to be a type 2 or type 1 concept, it must first affect the "reality" (it means all of existence) in the verse.
Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmm...
When we talk about Type 2 concepts they can be destroyed if their reality they depend on is destroyed, remember we talk about the REALITY. THE SPACE. Not the beings in it.
But the beings in reality are bound to space, time, et cetera. If I erased history, all of the people doing the perceiving would have never done the perceiving to create the concept; therefore, the concept is bound to time and type 1 concepts are not.
I think he's talking in general rather than just existing in a specific universe.
Actually not, the scale which a concept is used isn't really relevant for its type.
You wouldnt be just erasing time, you would be erasing time and the human minds. This is an unfair analogy to make
Once again, the human mind is bound to time and functions over time, and the perceptions that created the meanings happened at certain points in time. If I erased those points in time, the meanings would disappear. By your logic, the type 2 concept of a rock would actually be type 1, because I am not just destroying reality; I am destroying reality and rocks.
A concept of a rock that is not dependant on reality would be Type 1. But destroying the reality would also destroy the rocks, destroying the GF reality wont destroy the counciouss metafictional minds. Mindscape is not apart of reality technically
This is just saying "Life has no intrinsic meaning beyond what you consciously impose on it." It's neither a reference to Jung (And even if it was, it wouldn't amount to anything whatsoever) nor indicative of Conceptual Manipulation. Literally just basic existentialist shit.
The basic property of "ideas" is abstract and conceptual.
So...
Are you fine with Infinite Attack Speed at least?
CM 1 has been accepted by maverick and DDM
Sorry if this is necro, but Resistance is defined as "the power to withstand the effects of certain abilities through varying means", being unaffected by the ability itself (transmutation/petrification) would be Immunity.
After seeing the counterarguments I disagree with CM.
Are you fine with keeping it as NPI on Concept Type 2 for Mindscape then?
Bill's comment doesn't provide anything that would point towards "meaning" being a type 1 concept. Saying that meaning is determined by conscious judgment doesn't make it a concept. A concept is an abstraction that all particular instances of something are derived from. The concept of red is the global unifying concept that all red things borrow from, or represent, etc. It's almost hard to explain why this fails to qualify because it's not clear at all why you thought that.
Being outside the universe doesn't mean it's "outside time, laws, causality, and physics." Also being from a place that is atemporal doesn't mean you have resistance to time manip.
Bill creating the Rift doesn't mean he is as fast as it.
...do you even know why I made this claim? The Nightmare Realm is explicitly said to lack all of these.
How so?
Then you should write the OP to reflect that. If you represent your reasoning as "the NR is outside x,y,z, due to being outside the universe" then naturally I'm going to point out that being outside the universe doesn't mean you lack those things.
Once you go to a place that has time, you would be subject to time.
Tbh the reason for him having Type 4 Acausality is this:
Tbh is more off Bill working differently from the rest of the dimensions, given that unlike them he isn't under any law, much less under time itself, as also said here.
Isn’t that a possibly rating?
Destroying it is unquantifiable for speed, because we don't know the distances between them
Oh damn I didn't mean write "wipe", I don't know why I wrote that, I meant that eventually Weirdmageddon would "encompass" the entire universe.
Sounds like it’s just talking about the realm and not Bill himself.
I mean, Bill lived here a lot, to the point it was basically natural to him.
Bill basically became the one with the realm.
Should be left for another time it was rejected wholesale, also time manipulation is still being discussed so let’s not try to hastily past a CRT that isn’t fully accepted
I honestly think at least "tyranny of time" is about Bill himself, as he later mocks people for being victims of “natural selection”, so it’s more about individuals being oppressed by natural phenomenas rather than the places they live in.
Why not? Bill himself knows what it means to be tied to things like time and causality. When he arrived in NR, he began to assimilate the nature of the place and, seeing the benefits of not having laws, he was going to erase them from the entire multiverse.
