Let me point this out. Jesus' ap is >>>>>>>>>>> 126MJ. That attack was an insanely casual attack that wasn't even an attack at all. He just kinda got angry and destroyed the roof for fancies before attacking. So the AP gap is much less than you think.
Second, Henry is not very intelligent and is unlikely to lead with the best thing in the best situation.
Third, Henry's poor Lifting Strength means Jesus ragdolls him extremely easily, and rips every weapon out of his hand. So not only are all Henry's weapons literally useless, but Jesus can actually use them against him if he so chooses to (He would refrain from using non-gun weapons, so it's unlikely Jesus accidentally kills himself)
Not to mention Henry's stupidity and luck has gotten himself killed on multiple occasions, so it's completely possible that Henry gets himself killed before the much more highly skilled Jesus has to do anything.
As well, Jesus' guns could certainly obliterate Henry. Jesus' and Hank's (Hank is Jesus' rival and equal) AP and Dura are much higher than 126 MJ, but their guns can nearly one-shot each other. If Jesus grabs Henry with telekinesis (Which he would, especially against a fodder-looking enemy such as Henry), Jesus can simply unload a few rounds in his head and win on the spot.
So:
AP and Dura: Close due to Jesus massively upscaling, but guns likely give Jesus the advantage.
Abilities: Jesus. Jesus can hardcounter all of Henry's weapons and kill him quickly. Since Jesus has higher lifting strength, Henry's telekinesis is useless, while Jesus' telekinesis ***** him.
Range: Irrelevant due to starting range.
Experience: Massively in favor of Jesus. Henry kills himself absurdly often.
Henry only wins if he leads with specific, non-weapon abilities. Considering Henry doesn't have a personality to lead with any specific thing, and is kinda an idiot, he's just as likely to start with anything. Meanwhile, Jesus wins if Henry does.. basically anything else. Jesus will telekinesis, fire a bunch of rounds into Henry, and win. Even PSI attacks may have trouble putting Jesus down instantly, due to him being undead and being able to resist a powerful disease that made him puke blood for a significantly long time, all while fighting many opponents.
Vote Jesus, low-diff. Considering AP was a prime reason for Henry votes, all of Henry votes are nulled.
Tl:dr Jesus has AP much, much above what was calced, his guns are enough to one-shot foes comparable or even stronger than him, and Telekinesis renders most of Henry's arsenal useless.