- 8,438
- 3,294
The way we currently do Versus Match additions forces a grace period of 24 hours after 7 votes for either character A, character B, or inconclusive has been reached. After the grace period has past the thread can be posted in the Versus Match Additions Thread (for locked profiles) or it can be added by a user that knows the format. However, a rule exists that if the vote is unanimous, the match does not need to be given a grace period but instead can be added immediately. This rule should go.
This rule does nothing to encourage good discussion. Within 24 hours another user can easily arrive and present new and insightful arguments as to why a character should or shouldn't win, which will shift votes. Even if a definitive conclusion has been reached and no vote will be changed, nothing is lost. The thread will be remembered by someone involved the next day and the match will be added.
The only thing the rule rewards is blind "FRA"ing by removing the time needed for a valid counterargument to be presented. For popular characters, such as Altair or Rimuru Tempest, 7 unanimous votes can be reached very quickly and a potentially bad/invalid matchup can be added to the profiles without contest. While removing this rule will not prevent bad matches from being added, it will limit such occurrences while not punishing well-argued threads.
This rule does nothing to encourage good discussion. Within 24 hours another user can easily arrive and present new and insightful arguments as to why a character should or shouldn't win, which will shift votes. Even if a definitive conclusion has been reached and no vote will be changed, nothing is lost. The thread will be remembered by someone involved the next day and the match will be added.
The only thing the rule rewards is blind "FRA"ing by removing the time needed for a valid counterargument to be presented. For popular characters, such as Altair or Rimuru Tempest, 7 unanimous votes can be reached very quickly and a potentially bad/invalid matchup can be added to the profiles without contest. While removing this rule will not prevent bad matches from being added, it will limit such occurrences while not punishing well-argued threads.