Where do we draw the line between game mechanics and when an ability is really indexable

[FeebasExE]

Even with an entire page being dedicated to this topic, sometimes it's really hard to tell in some franchises.

 

[Maskofthedragon]

Does it make my preferred character stronger? Use it!
Does it make my preferred character weaker? Bullshit, non-canon, how could anyone take it seriously?!

 

[FeebasExE]

Okay that's actually hilarious.

And vice versa.

this spell gives you immunity to physical attacks? That's just game mechanics dude.

But it only lasts 10 seconds and it leaves you incapacitated for 5 seconds. That part is a weakness we should index!