Versus Thread Removal Requests (New forum)

[SlendVeny]

So if I make Tanjiro vs SSJB Goku, and everyone decide to vote for Tanjiro somehow, it will be added and no one will be capable to remove?

That's an entirely different case. It can be removed for being a stomp, or for incorrect arguments, not on the basis of it being a unanimous decision.

 

[LIFE_OF_KING]

I'm not entirely certain of your point. Do you intend to say that in these matchups, one character stomps the other? That is the case in this hypothetical, is it not? It is invalid for a different reason.

I intent to say that the match doesn't make sense
Its a 10-A with a shotgun against a 9-A capable to dodge things that hit the target automatically
The point is that there was no argument for Itadori at all, with just a FRA train without basis
But if the fact that the result of the match just doesn't make sense isn't enough to remove it from the profile, I will accept it

 

[CloverDragon03]

So if I make Tanjiro vs SSJB Goku, and everyone decide to vote for Tanjiro somehow, it will be added and no one will be capable to remove?

False equivalence and a half holy-

Votes need to come from actual arguments, not just voting for the sake of it

 

[Mr. Bambu]

I intent to say that the match doesn't make sense
Its a 10-A with a shotgun against a 9-A capable to dodge things that hit the target automatically
The point is that there was no argument for Itadori at all, with just a FRA train without basis
But if the fact that the result of the match just doesn't make sense isn't enough to remove it from the profile, I will accept it

Well, no, if you intend to say the outcome is wrong and the outcome is impossible (that is, it is not reasonable), then I invite you to re-read what I said. If a match is legitimately wrong in its decision, and one character is decided to be unable to win, then it is invalid- even if that character was voted to win. So if you want to prove that, then you need to start discussing that point, rather than discussing how it was unanimous. The vote being unanimous doesn't matter.

 

[LIFE_OF_KING]

Well, my first argument was that the match doesn't make sense, but then it was said that it could be only be removed if it was stomp
But well, the moment that I said a decent argument for Itadori the OP started to change the rules of the fight, so it says a lot of how the original result just doesn't make sense

 

[SlendVeny]

Its a 10-A with a shotgun against a 9-A capable to dodge things that hit the target automatically

A 9-A with multiple guns, actually

 

[SlendVeny]

A 9-A with multiple guns, actually

Wait, you're arguing about a match that isn't on the profile. I haven't played the games, but I'm pretty sure the Hunter and Agent are two seperate entities.

 

[Fallen_Angelicx]

This match is very biased (?). Its using the first key of Itadori, which barely has any feats and only lasts for less than 10 chapters, while the guy has a bunch of skill feats and precog in a 2-A scale

Not really. Yuji's wincon is outlasting Ryuunosuke which is possible via Higher AP and Durability (4X actually) meaning there's a possibility in these matches that Ryuunosuke likely wouldn't be able to take him down before he out exerts himself due to his weakness.
Ryuunosuke doesn't have 2-A Precognition. He has Time Precognition. It doesn't help his stamina case either so it's not really a stomp

 

[Mr. Bambu]

Please don't post four times to a management thread like that. It's unnecessary and is technically against the rules.

 

[CryoTheMayo]

I believe these two should be removed:

​

Reinhard van Astrea vs Son Goku (DBS Manga)​

Son Goku (DBS Manga) vs Mega Man X​

​

Both matches are from 2022. Goku has had many revisions since then. I believe Reinhard has also received significant revisions.

I also think the Son Goku (GT) vs Son Goku (DBS Manga) match from February 2024 deserves some scrutiny. From what I can tell both Gokus have had significant revisions since then and the arguments used in the thread seem to be outdated or incorrect as the AP scaling chain used to justify Goku (GT) winning appears to give Goku (DBS Manga) a relatively very low value. For context that's Goku from the ToP with access to Ultra Instinct.

Finally Grand Priest vs Medea is from 2019 and from what I can tell Grand Priest doesn't have the loss on any of his profiles. Yet Medea's page still has the match. I believe this was an incomplete removal. And even if not the match should be completely removed due to being very outdated.

Bump.