• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Usopp vs Lady Nagant (9/11/2)

All of his attacks scale faster than him in general since he shoots them from a slingshot if they weren't that'd be like saying Lee in the 6th gate is >8th gate guy because his throwing speed is faster than guy was able to react
Of all the examples, you had to remind me of that one. That moment triggered me.

Anyway, I’m not talking about the speed he shoots them, I mean the speed of the plant itself. You said it can move, so how fast does it move when it’s active.
 
Of all the examples, you had to remind me of that one. That moment triggered me.

Anyway, I’m not talking about the speed he shoots them, I mean the speed of the plant itself. You said it can move, so how fast does it move when it’s active.
A lot faster than Usopp
 
Sorry, for implying he had prep time. However, the knowledge Usopp has on her is enough to know that his first priority is protecting himself from her bullets, as i've explained before the growth of the plants is instantaneous same applies to his sleep hax. So, it's not entirely impossible for Usopp to block the bullets via his plants despite bullets being faster than him, since the speed of the bullets is unquantifiable. Usopp theoretically can shoot the ground before bullets hit him.


I was not implying he is suddenly safe, but if the bullets hit the plants, it obviously give Usopp some time to react to the bullets or use impact wolf at the start. Technically he can conjure up enough plants needed to stop her rapid fire, also i asked why her rapid fire isn't listed as one of her notable abilities?
Now we’ve entered the realm of semantics and unknown variables. Too much of the fight is feeling dependent on factors we as debaters can’t control or fully know about.

Whether Usopp shoots the ground first or she hits him, do her shots curve and hit him anyway, what does he do next, does he blind her, does she hit him, who needs to reload first, when does flight become relevant, what speed are his plants.

I’m switching to inconclusive, too much of a hassle trying to argue she wins and I can’t see any definitive path for victory in Usopp’s favor either. I feel I can’t even comprehend a winner, it’s just arguing which possibility is more likely with both having equal merit.

And it’s not on her profile cause it isn’t an ability? She just can rapid fire her gun like an automatic instead of a sniper.
 
Pictures?
if you want to see why they scale above usopp in speed you should preferably watch post timeskip the show has many moments where his pop greens outperform him and even just using common sense if Usopp had speed relative or surpassing his pop greens why doesn't he just attack the villains by himself a good example of his pop greens being superior to him would be the fishman island arc
 
Last edited:
Bruh I'm too lazy to find some, but if you want to see why they scale above usopp in speed you should preferably watch post timeskip the show has many moments where his pop greens outperform him and even just using common sense if Usopp had speed relative or surpassing his pop greens why doesn't he just attack the villains by himself a good example of his pop greens being superior to him would be the fishman island arc
That’s not really an argument for his plants being higher in speed to a point it matters here. Also that would probably require a crt to note in his speed section if they were faster to the same degree Nagant’s bullets are faster.

That video just shows him beating up someone easily. Was that person faster than him normally or something? And it seemed more so that they were stupid and fell into his traps rather than his plants outsped them.
 
That’s not really an argument for his plants being higher in speed to a point it matters here. Also that would probably require a crt to note in his speed section if they were faster to the same degree Nagant’s bullets are faster.

That video just shows him beating up someone easily. Was that person faster than him normally or something? And it seemed more so that they were stupid and fell into his traps rather than his plants outsped them.
Usopp doesn't scale to his pop greens so we don't know how he scales to that fishman but his pop green is clearly faster than him
 
Whether Usopp shoots the ground first or she hits him, do her shots curve and hit him anyway, what does he do next, does he blind her, does she hit him, who needs to reload first, when does flight become relevant, what speed are his plants.
Why are we assuming that she exactly knows what Usopp is going to do, he holds the advantage in versatility he could start with literally anything, on top of that he knows her bullets are fast, can curve, and she can rapid fire. Judging by what you are trying to imply she will immediately start off with rapid fire, so which raises the question if the plants blocks her rapid fire, doesn't she need to shoot again because the said bullets are stopped, there is no "curve" or anything when her first fire is stopped, of course, she will immediately proceed to shoot again. However, Usopp will blind her via flash dial or shoot his sleep gas. (His Range abilities are also faster than himself)

Everyone with common sense knows that it's not a good idea to stay within poisonous or sleep gas, she will naturally get away from the gas, thus will focus on flying and analyzing Usopp's next move that's the moment he uses his plant to put to sleep. Another scenario, she is temporarily blinded by the flash dial (since she doesn't resist it) thus allows Usopp a lot of options as well.

And it’s not on her profile cause it isn’t an ability? She just can rapid fire her gun like an automatic instead of a sniper.
Thanks for clearing this up, so in other words, it's not just a rifle she can transform it into a snipe same way Baby 5 does?
 
That’s not really an argument for his plants being higher in speed to a point it matters here. Also that would probably require a crt to note in his speed section if they were faster to the same degree Nagant’s bullets are faster.
King... we are currently awaiting a big revision. This will also be included, i'll have you know most One piece pages are outdated, also most CTRs in One piece are currently "invalid" since it'll be a big revision.
 
That’s not really an argument for his plants being higher in speed to a point it matters here. Also that would probably require a crt to note in his speed section if they were faster to the same degree Nagant’s bullets are faster.

That video just shows him beating up someone easily. Was that person faster than him normally or something? And it seemed more so that they were stupid and fell into his traps rather than his plants outsped them.
Usopp has faster attacks than Nagant though blatantly since a flash dial is a SOL attack
 
That video just shows him beating up someone easily. Was that person faster than him normally or something? And it seemed more so that they were stupid and fell into his traps rather than his plants outsped them.
Yes. The fishman is naturally faster than Usopp. Usopp baiting him into his trap doesn't disprove it, most of Usopp's enemies are faster and stronger than him normally, he beats them with either "Hax" or intelligence.

We naturally assume his attacks to be faster than himself just like how we assume that Nami's climatact is faster than herself normally (combat speed). Usopp created the climatact and his own slingshots, both weapons have one thing in common they are not ordinary weapons, Nami creates natural lightning via her climatact, fire and other things. Usopp's Kabutos are significantly better than rifles and pistoles in One piece, on top of that Usopp's excellent marksman skills allows him to shoot with precision and predictions which is further enhances with his newest kabuto.
 
Why are we assuming that she exactly knows what Usopp is going to do, he holds the advantage in versatility he could start with literally anything, on top of that he knows her bullets are fast, can curve, and she can rapid fire. Judging by what you are trying to imply she will immediately start off with rapid fire, so which raises the question if the plants blocks her rapid fire, doesn't she need to shoot again because the said bullets are stopped, there is no "curve" or anything when her first fire is stopped, of course, she will immediately proceed to shoot again. However, Usopp will blind her via flash dial or shoot his sleep gas. (His Range abilities are also faster than himself)

Everyone with common sense knows that it's not a good idea to stay within poisonous or sleep gas, she will naturally get away from the gas, thus will focus on flying and analyzing Usopp's next move that's the moment he uses his plant to put to sleep. Another scenario, she is temporarily blinded by the flash dial (since she doesn't resist it) thus allows Usopp a lot of options as well.


Thanks for clearing this up, so in other words, it's not just a rifle she can transform it into a snipe same way Baby 5 does?
The issue however is that he can’t pull out enough objects to block her since she knows his abilities too. She starts with shooting him with her bullets and he either dies or gets a plant out to block. You realize she can preplan her bullets to curve and hit him right? She doesn’t need to shoot straight at him, she’s hitting him from multiple angles to either kill him first or tear apart any plants he puts up to protect himself.

If she hits shots before his plants come up, he is dead.

If she doesn’t hit shots because his plants block them, she either destroys the plant and keeps firing or takes off and starts sniping from angles that get past his plants anyway, assuming the several bullets she shoots at the beginning aren’t already curving around bullets to hit him. Usopp cannot predict where her bullets are going to curve to, all he knows is that they can and are faster than him.

Has he even displayed the ability to wrap himself in plants to fully protect himself from Low 7-B attacks? If the only ability is that flower, why can’t she shoot past it? I don’t see the flower actively moving at speeds above Usopp’s own outside of when it spawns. In fact, it doesn’t seem to move at all after it appears. And isn’t only the bubble in the middle the defensive part? Would it even hold up to a piercing attack? Would that tear right through the bubble? What about the leaves? Why wouldn’t her curved bullets tear right through them and hit him anyway?

Lets further assume, the very unlikely possibility, that he has somehow fully blocked himself from her shots on all angles. Now she’s in the sky, propelling herself out of his range of 1 kilometer to continuously snipe him where he can’t hit her, or even worse, continuing to fire at him while she ascends, making it hard for him to do anything if he’s focused solely on making plants to protect himself. At best at that point he can do his smokescreen or flash dial, but now he has to get to her without revealing himself. How does he do that? Any of his plants will be seen and avoided, she knows about the dials so she can avoid a flash one unless it detonates in her face, Impact Wolf only works within 3 meters of her, his big attacks need to actually make contact to matter and he can’t remotely detonate his projectiles.

Even if he does the sleep option, either one, she’s going to see them before they come even close to him because of the distance she is going to retreat to in the possibility he manages to defend against her initial bullets. But that’s even assuming that occurs in the first place.
 
King... we are currently awaiting a big revision. This will also be included, i'll have you know most One piece pages are outdated, also most CTRs in One piece are currently "invalid" since it'll be a big revision.
Current possible revisions have Lady Nagant becoming 7-A+. So ok.
 
The issue however is that he can’t pull out enough objects to block her since she knows his abilities too. She starts with shooting him with her bullets and he either dies or gets a plant out to block. You realize she can preplan her bullets to curve and hit him right? She doesn’t need to shoot straight at him, she’s hitting him from multiple angles to either kill him first or tear apart any plants he puts up to protect himself.
If she hits shots before his plants come up, he is dead.
Won't happen her AP isn't large enough to easily get pass through the plants, even then her first attack is technically stopped. You are implying that her bullets easily tear any plants apart, but the issue here is his plants will come up immediately the moment he shot them and protect him.

If she doesn’t hit shots because his plants block them, she either destroys the plant and keeps firing or takes off and starts sniping from angles that get past his plants anyway, assuming the several bullets she shoots at the beginning aren’t already curving around bullets to hit him. Usopp cannot predict where her bullets are going to curve to, all he knows is that they can and are faster than him.
Destroying the plants also requires time and focus. Also the plants are meant to distract her, so saying she will focus on getting rid of them first means she fell into Usopp's plan before you say otherwise she straight up admitted that she will trying to get rid of them. Furthermore, since he knows about her ability to manipulate the bullets he will definitely come up with a plan to restrain her via using smokescreen to hinder her sight or force her to retreat into a safe position by shooting his sleep gas, either that or he will use this to end put her to sleep.

Has he even displayed the ability to wrap himself in plants to fully protect himself from Low 7-B attacks? If the only ability is that flower, why can’t she shoot past it? I don’t see the flower actively moving at speeds above Usopp’s own outside of when it spawns. In fact, it doesn’t seem to move at all after it appears. And isn’t only the bubble in the middle the defensive part? Would it even hold up to a piercing attack? Would that tear right through the bubble? What about the leaves? Why wouldn’t her curved bullets tear right through them and hit him anyway?
Not necessarily. But it's irrelevant. His plants are stated to be working as offensive and defensive weapons, Usopp who utilizes his weapons at it's finest should be capable of pulling it off with ease. Regarding Low 7-B attacks argument, you should know better than anyone that we naturally assume that a said character who possess defensive abilities to protect himself from a tier equal or lesser than himself.
 
I can direct that question back at you. How are you certain everyone will agree about Usopp’s attack speed? You brought up revisions first.
So, lemme ask you this what's more likely a possibly downgrade for a said character or someone whose abilities resolved around scientifically weapons that far faster than himself
 
Won't happen her AP isn't large enough to easily get pass through the plants, even then her first attack is technically stopped. You are implying that her bullets easily tear any plants apart, but the issue here is his plants will come up immediately the moment he shot them and protect him.


Destroying the plants also requires time and focus. Also the plants are meant to distract her, so saying she will focus on getting rid of them first means she fell into Usopp's plan before you say otherwise she straight up admitted that she will trying to get rid of them. Furthermore, since he knows about her ability to manipulate the bullets he will definitely come up with a plan to restrain her via using smokescreen to hinder her sight or force her to retreat into a safe position by shooting his sleep gas, either that or he will use this to end put her to sleep.


Not necessarily. But it's irrelevant. His plants are stated to be working as offensive and defensive weapons, Usopp who utilizes his weapons at it's finest should be capable of pulling it off with ease. Regarding Low 7-B attacks argument, you should know better than anyone that we naturally assume that a said character who possess defensive abilities to protect himself from a tier equal or lesser than himself.
Except they’re plants vs piercing ammunition. Her shots tore through Deku’s Mid Gauntlet, which handles the recoil of his Low 7-B attacks with ease. She is not the one found wanting in the AP department, she should be fully capable of sniping through his plants and hitting him. Unless there’s a specific plant he has that can deflect her shots and won’t just get pierced through or curved around by her initial volley of shots, any further actions for Usopp don’t matter because he’s getting hit.

No, destroying the plants he initially creates don’t require focus. She shots through them and hits him unless they’re strong enough to block her. He’s not coming up with any plans unless he gets over the first problem. Knowing about an ability is far different from actually experiencing it, and Usopp, as I said, has no idea of how she will curve her bullets in this scenario. She could just from her initial volley alone set up 3 different ways to hit him, cutting off any route to move away. You can’t just gloss over that the plants block her attacks because he wants them to.

So he can’t even defend all around himself if he DOES get a plant out? Doesn’t that make it worthless? She rapid fires multiple shots and several of them are going to be curving around corners to get him, she’s not shooting a straight line here. If he’s not protected from all sides, why does he not get shot to hell? And no, that is a terrible assumption when dealing with a character whose attacks are designed to pierce through other Low 7-B’s with ease. Provide reasoning that his plants can block her shots or don’t even mention them as an option.
So, lemme ask you this what's more likely a possibly downgrade for a said character or someone whose abilities resolved around scientifically weapons that far faster than himself
Depends on the verse, who is debating it, what the feats are and what the verses accept. That’s a case by case thing.
 
Except they’re plants vs piercing ammunition. Her shots tore through Deku’s Mid Gauntlet, which handles the recoil of his Low 7-B attacks with ease. She is not the one found wanting in the AP department, she should be fully capable of sniping through his plants and hitting him. Unless there’s a specific plant he has that can deflect her shots and won’t just get pierced through or curved around by her initial volley of shots, any further actions for Usopp don’t matter because he’s getting hit.
Again, i disagree with you magical plants vs piercing ammunition, magical plants are infinitely superior to what you are suggesting, especially the impact wolf is capable of absorbing the bullet (the name is pretty self-explanatory, it's made of the same material as skypia impact dial which could absorb Luffy's attacks) so naturally it is capable of stopping the bullet, though the plants are Low 7-B, i don't think she will easily get pass through them.


No, destroying the plants he initially creates don’t require focus. She shots through them and hits him unless they’re strong enough to block her. He’s not coming up with any plans unless he gets over the first problem. Knowing about an ability is far different from actually experiencing it, and Usopp, as I said, has no idea of how she will curve her bullets in this scenario. She could just from her initial volley alone set up 3 different ways to hit him, cutting off any route to move away. You can’t just gloss over that the plants block her attacks because he wants them to.
His plants will block her initial attack. The issue here is, her lack of versatility and the knowledge he has on her (Having intel on the person literally means he knows how she can curve her bullets in that scenario, the only thing he doesn't know is her ability to fly. The OP specifically said that Usopp doesn't know her ability to fly, but knows the others prior to the battle), Usopp who never underestimates anyone and always prepares himself for any worst-case scenarios, will try to protect himself in order to survive. And what's the worst-case scenario in this scenario? her ability to curve her bullets and hit him directly, Usopp always assuming the worst enables him to come up with a strategy to counter this ability.

So he can’t even defend all around himself if he DOES get a plant out? Doesn’t that make it worthless? She rapid fires multiple shots and several of them are going to be curving around corners to get him, she’s not shooting a straight line here. If he’s not protected from all sides, why does he not get shot to hell? And no, that is a terrible assumption when dealing with a character whose attacks are designed to pierce through other Low 7-B’s with ease. Provide reasoning that his plants can block her shots or don’t even mention them as an option.
Regarding your rapid fires multiple shots argument, why are you not taking into consideration that Usopp will simply use his plants as sacrifices to dodge her bullets, Also, why would she assume he will survive her initial shoot? before you say she's a professional sniper or something like that even for her it's possible to make mistakes and underestimating her foes. Her attacks pierce, the Impact wolf is made of shockwave generation it's 3x stronger than a normal impact dial. Assuming it's just a plant that can be pierced with ease is ridiculous, as her bullet doesn't count literal shockwave disguised in a plant wolf.

Depends on the verse, who is debating it, what the feats are and what the verses accept. That’s a case by case thing.
Me: irrelevant, a sudden downplay can happen any time, especially MHA is not an exception. You have no idea how many times people tried to upgrade Goku to multiverse lvl and Naruto to Solar system lvl.
Anyways, i'm entirely disinterested in this debate anymore, i disagree with you and you disagree with me. This thread is already past 200+, we won't be able to change our opinions because even the first scenario is pure speculations and assumptions, you are claiming Usopp will die and i am claiming he won't die. In the end, we are unnecessarily dragging this out, that were my last words. Anyways, goodnight for real.
 
I could write another 5 paragraph rebuttal but I really am not about it anymore. I’m going to sleep and if anyone wants to continue, I’ll address all these points again and keep going, but I’m praying we just get inconclusive and go on about our lives. 267 posts isn’t healthy.
 
I could write another 5 paragraph rebuttal but I really am not about it anymore. I’m going to sleep and if anyone wants to continue, I’ll address all these points again and keep going, but I’m praying we just get inconclusive and go on about our lives. 267 posts isn’t healthy.
Don’t know if someone typed this but his plants move faster than his opponent who is faster than usopp link (link and link)
 
Last edited:
Well I was more convinced with Nagants arguments tbh, maybe there was something in that page long circular argument I missed lol.
I'm sure those who voted ussop with just an FRA probably feel the same

Initially I sided with Nagant 100% due to the probability of Ussop doing everything he needs to do to survive without any knowledge was lower than Nagant just lighting him up but now that he has prep time I'm considering incon but for now going for Nagant.
 
Back
Top