EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 17,006
- 12,689
- Thread starter
- #81
Concepts which forms the reality should be independent from the reality they governs is there any proof destroying the concept of name won't affect the concept of name itself?
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Touhou Project Conceptual Manipulation Downgrade
- Thread starter EldemadeDityjon
- Start date
-
- Tags
- touhou project
- Status
- 15,472
- 7,188
It's not necessary a proof. Again, Madoka Magica.
- 9,984
- 10,829
Names exists for all things in reality and those things aren't distinguishable from each other, if names are governing smth individual object then that would fall under type 3 not type 2, for that they need to govern fundamental aspects of reality as whole, not all singular objects individually.
- 15,472
- 7,188
They're the reason why reality is not a mass of chaos, that's enough to prove superiority over it lol.
PrinceofPein
Username Only- 9,100
- 6,037
I agree with your thread at least till I see Fuji's counter points.
but it is really a Touhou and MGK thing, which i made as a harmless joke.
That said @StrymULTRA you are not refuting or addressing his points, so let @Mad_Dog_of_Fujiwara do it, instead of the thread getting dragged on needless
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 17,006
- 12,689
- Thread starter
- #86
I don't care about that make a Downgrade CRT if you want. Current standard says what i claimed even above a staff literally clarified.
This is current standard. Really if you want to nuke Madoka Conceptual Manipulation then that's upto you but My thread is based on how wiki treats conceptual manipulation so feel free to create a seperate thread for that one.
- 9,984
- 10,829
Then I remove your name or destroy your name, will reality crumble afterwards?
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 17,006
- 12,689
- Thread starter
- #88
Well you know when a CRT gets dragged on staffs won't try to evaluate it so I want to avoid unnecessary comments that's all. Especially many staffs don't even want involve in Touhou CRTs because of supporters. No hate buddy I know you were joking.
- 18,393
- 14,323
Princess of Pain is doing harmless jokes
And ya I agree that the supporter of verse need to address the counter-arguments tho!
- 16,000
- 6,005
I’m fairly certain Strym is strawmanning off the basis of “predating” reality, when if you look at the original OP, he never says predate explicitly—he just says independent of.
- 15,472
- 7,188
I thought the thing was about predating lmfao.
- 18,393
- 14,323
There is nothing predating in every scan, so drop the argument.
- 16,000
- 6,005
I’ve been reading this entire thread and nothing about OP nor the definition of conceptual manipulation says predating.
Not sure if this guts Touhou further, though, but it’s one recursive argument done.
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 17,006
- 12,689
- Thread starter
- #94
Name didn't Existed until gods gave names to things which already debunks CM type 1 argument. Names are not independent from the reality they govern. If names were independent then they should have existed even before the world was born. World already existed where name didn't. Names came after when gods gave them. They named things individually which literally indicates personal concepts type 3 not type 2 or 1.
Reality/World already Existed names didn't. Names are not independent if they can't exists without the reality they govern.
I guess we have to wait for Fuji arguments then.
Kirbonic_Pikmin
He/Him- 3,480
- 6,940
Incredible that y’all have managed to send nearly an entire page of text before the opposition can make their argument against OP. Absolutely nothing suspicious or spiteful here in the least.
Mad_Dog_of_Fujiwara
She/Her- 9,828
- 12,455
Okay, as promised, here's my response.
Boundaries
Since the OP chose to use Yukari's CM justification, I'll also be covering why boundaries are type 1 concepts. To begin with, we already know boundaries affect universal concepts; There are boundaries of life and death, space and time, existence and nonexistence, and so on. Boundaries separate everything in reality, and without boundaries, all of reality would collapse into a state of formless chaos. This is, obviously, type 2. However, boundaries are also shown to not be affected by the alteration of what they govern; For example, Fujiwara no Mokou is a character who has consumed the Hourai elixir and is therefore completely absent of the concepts of life and death. Despite this, boundary users like Yukari can still force her to cross the boundary of life and death, showing that while it is possible to be absent of life and death, the boundary between them is independent of those concepts and will not be affected by their removal. Another example is the boundary of red and white, which is literally existence and nonexistence (or black and white, which is void [imaginary number] and nonexistence [zero]. Since boundaries created these two concepts, they must thus predate reality and therefore be unbound from it (since, if they were bound to existence, then they would never be able to exist in order to create existence to begin with). In a typical causal relationship, the creator [boundaries] must always come before the creation [existence], it's quite simple.
TL;DR: Boundaries govern all of reality and aren't bound to alterations in what they govern, making them type 1.
Names
Now onto the main point. To start, names created boundaries ("when naming something, a new border is created" [note that borders and boundaries are used interchangeably in Touhou, they mean the same thing]). This is directly stated, and is important because type 2 or lower concepts cannot create type 1 concepts. Two quotes from the CM page prove this, the first from the notes section:
"All Conceptual Manipulators are bound by the type of concept they have been shown to manipulate. A character able to manipulate a concept on a Type 3 level cannot manipulate any higher concept type."
And the second from the type 1 description:
"Such concepts are completely independent from the part of reality they govern, except maybe of other concepts of this nature."
So if boundaries are type 1, names have to be type 1 as well. Names themselves though have their own evidence of type 1, starting with how they govern all of reality. When a god is given a name, their nature changes accordingly (such as a god of pottery becoming a god of sorcery by changing their name). However, this nature of the gods actually takes the form of an idea spread across all of reality; So when you give a name to a god, you're not just changing that god alone, but also the entire idea they represent (using the former example, it'd be affecting all instances of pottery and sorcery in existence). Hell, this would even extend to boundaries since gods of boundaries exist, showing yet again that names govern boundaries and would have to be superior to them. Keep in mind this is just an individual name doing this, not a broader concept of names. Also as explained previously, names created reality and thus predate it; Again, as names created everything from nothingness, that means names had to have come first, and thus be unbound from what they created. Otherwise, names wouldn't be able to exist to begin with, for the same reason as boundaries.
TL;DR: Names created type 1 concepts and govern them, govern ideas spread across all of reality, and predate reality.
Boundaries
Since the OP chose to use Yukari's CM justification, I'll also be covering why boundaries are type 1 concepts. To begin with, we already know boundaries affect universal concepts; There are boundaries of life and death, space and time, existence and nonexistence, and so on. Boundaries separate everything in reality, and without boundaries, all of reality would collapse into a state of formless chaos. This is, obviously, type 2. However, boundaries are also shown to not be affected by the alteration of what they govern; For example, Fujiwara no Mokou is a character who has consumed the Hourai elixir and is therefore completely absent of the concepts of life and death. Despite this, boundary users like Yukari can still force her to cross the boundary of life and death, showing that while it is possible to be absent of life and death, the boundary between them is independent of those concepts and will not be affected by their removal. Another example is the boundary of red and white, which is literally existence and nonexistence (or black and white, which is void [imaginary number] and nonexistence [zero]. Since boundaries created these two concepts, they must thus predate reality and therefore be unbound from it (since, if they were bound to existence, then they would never be able to exist in order to create existence to begin with). In a typical causal relationship, the creator [boundaries] must always come before the creation [existence], it's quite simple.
TL;DR: Boundaries govern all of reality and aren't bound to alterations in what they govern, making them type 1.
Names
Now onto the main point. To start, names created boundaries ("when naming something, a new border is created" [note that borders and boundaries are used interchangeably in Touhou, they mean the same thing]). This is directly stated, and is important because type 2 or lower concepts cannot create type 1 concepts. Two quotes from the CM page prove this, the first from the notes section:
"All Conceptual Manipulators are bound by the type of concept they have been shown to manipulate. A character able to manipulate a concept on a Type 3 level cannot manipulate any higher concept type."
And the second from the type 1 description:
"Such concepts are completely independent from the part of reality they govern, except maybe of other concepts of this nature."
So if boundaries are type 1, names have to be type 1 as well. Names themselves though have their own evidence of type 1, starting with how they govern all of reality. When a god is given a name, their nature changes accordingly (such as a god of pottery becoming a god of sorcery by changing their name). However, this nature of the gods actually takes the form of an idea spread across all of reality; So when you give a name to a god, you're not just changing that god alone, but also the entire idea they represent (using the former example, it'd be affecting all instances of pottery and sorcery in existence). Hell, this would even extend to boundaries since gods of boundaries exist, showing yet again that names govern boundaries and would have to be superior to them. Keep in mind this is just an individual name doing this, not a broader concept of names. Also as explained previously, names created reality and thus predate it; Again, as names created everything from nothingness, that means names had to have come first, and thus be unbound from what they created. Otherwise, names wouldn't be able to exist to begin with, for the same reason as boundaries.
TL;DR: Names created type 1 concepts and govern them, govern ideas spread across all of reality, and predate reality.
Since you were waiting for a rebuttal, here it is. TL;DR boundaries are type 1, names created boundaries, names govern all of reality.
Everyone in this thread is destined for hell.
Predating reality means you exist independently of it. If you depended on any part of reality, then you would be unable to predate it without just dying or disappearing (since the things you depend on wouldn't exist yet).
- 18,393
- 14,323
There are multiple of oppositions, and they have right to discuss and share. There is no “suspicious” on this. Why no one actually stop with this bs right now?
- 16,000
- 6,005
Not inherently, no. Most things just happen to get Type 1 via predating reality, there are verses that have Type 1 despite not having concepts that predate reality, yet remain independent from it. Madoka Magicka for one, as Styrm put.
Mad_Dog_of_Fujiwara
She/Her- 9,828
- 12,455
Hmmmm yes i cant possibly think of a reason why Elde would single out my verse after I downgraded MG, no reasons at all, definitely not sussy
I didn't say that not predating reality didn't count for type 1, I'm just saying that predating reality can often be proof of type 1 by itself (which you seem to agree with?). There are multiple ways of getting type 1, this is just one of them.
- 18,393
- 14,323
Fuji, did Elde break any rules with the thread? If yes, report him in RvR, if not, drop with this absurd derailment.
- 16,000
- 6,005
Yeah, I would agree.
Kirbonic_Pikmin
He/Him- 3,480
- 6,940
I disagree with the downgrade FRA. Fuji tackled everything perfectly here.
- 18,393
- 14,323
I need a moment to see all the scans.
EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 17,006
- 12,689
- Thread starter
- #104
She didn't I will responding to that later. I will be offline for a Bit. I don't even know where to start she literally spammed Random things which are not necessary for CM arguments.
- 43,118
- 37,263
I disagree FRA.
I won't way any more because I would get toxic
I won't way any more because I would get toxic
- 9,984
- 10,829
I mean, are we certain that these boundaries are the boundaries that has something to do with the names distinguishing named things? Names creates boundaries between all named things but that doesn't mean each time the word "boundaries" has been used it'll refer to only name and named thing, that boundary of life and death seems kinda vague and more like a name of some skill that has the ability to manipulate ppls life and death barrier and causing them to suffer and all. Barrier of Time and space is entirely without context for me to say anything.
- 18,393
- 14,323
Ok but I don't see how it is being independent of concepts at all. All this just implies laws of the universe. Nothing refers to CM type 1.
This is all immortality type 5, NEP 2 and TD type 2 or (type 1), nothing refers to CM type 1 at all.
May I know the evidence of this bolded part? Because it does not sound like that. Reiner already pointed out this.
They don't. No standards can vouch this.
The scan seems implying that Gods were before being nameless. Nothing implies name being actually a concept to start with.
This scan does not imply anything with CM type 1, let alone the non-proved interpretation you made.
Nothing refers to predating the reality. Name manipulation is CM type 3.
I still agree with the thread.
- 15,472
- 7,188
In Touhou the name of a power is literally what the power does, so name fallacy doesn't exist in the verse.
- 18,393
- 14,323
This does not even sound like concepts to me at all, rather laws of universe or duality.
- 9,984
- 10,829
That kinda entirely name fallacy, seems like if the verse uses names as concept then all kind of names will refer to concepts if that's the case then there is no point in making arguements as time and space itself are names, life and death itself are names, in ben 10 everything has names and names can be used to have a absolute control over smth then that doesn't mean time and space will fall under it. It needs to be specified that the lvl of reality names governs are extends far to fundamental aspects of reality as whole which will cause a change across, such as time and space, life and death, not some vague statements about it with no context whatsoever.
- 15,472
- 7,188
I mean about this
Conceptual Manipulation (Type 1; The process of creating a spell card requires giving it a 'name' to define its form and power, not unlike how the gods gave 'names' to everything at the beginning of reality to give them form from nothingness, albeit on a much smaller scale[1][2][3]),
Also kindly do not mention Ben 10 here please as it blatantly doesn't work that way thank you
- 18,393
- 14,323
You said it twice, we understood. The derailment of this thread is really crazy.
Mad_Dog_of_Fujiwara
She/Her- 9,828
- 12,455
If the concepts of life and death are destroyed, the boundary separating them will remain. That is independence from what the concept govern.
If this were referring to actual characters, yes, but it's for concepts, which shows that the predation and destruction of what they govern doesn't harm the boundary itself.
Yes, they do. Type 2 concepts can't create or govern type 1 concepts. As stated here:
"All Conceptual Manipulators are bound by the type of concept they have been shown to manipulate. A character able to manipulate a concept on a Type 3 level cannot manipulate any higher concept type."
"Such concepts are completely independent from the part of reality they govern, except maybe of other concepts of this nature."
So names would scale to whatever level of CM boundaries have, since they created and govern boundaries.
Ah yes, because altering the nature of something and creating all of existence from nothing is definitely not concept hax. Get real.
It's to help prove that names affect all of reality.
Mad_Dog_of_Fujiwara
She/Her- 9,828
- 12,455
What derailment? People agreeing with my points is derailing? They're free to give their opinions (doubly so since they know a fair bit about Touhou themselves), so stop trying to silence them.
- 18,393
- 14,323
The justification itself is not even Type 1 to begin with. I am starting to understand why DT don't want involvement.
Elaborate rather requesting from someone to drop it. This is not a counter-argument.
Mad_Dog_of_Fujiwara
She/Her- 9,828
- 12,455
I mean, I never said the justifications were good. But names are type 1 concepts in and of themselves, that's the point here.
- 18,393
- 14,323
They have repeated themselves, as I mentioned earlier. Unless there are connectivity issues, I have no issue with it. However, as they have repeated themselves without any explanation, it seems unnecessary.
I did not intend to limit "freedom" in any way, but if you revisit my previous comment, you will notice that it is a duplicate.
Given this precedent, I could hypothetically spam "Agree FRA" every two minutes, without it being considered as derailing.
- 4,477
- 4,551
Looking at the OP, it looks like Touhou actually is almost the exact definition of Type 1 CM. I struggle to see what exactly would cause for it to qualify for Type 3 instead
- 18,393
- 14,323
I will respond to your comment above, and we will “talk” if names is actually type 1 or not. Jeez, give me a break, I am loving the debate right now
- Status
Similar threads
