EldemadeDityjon
He/Him- 16,835
- 12,522
Let's start with the fact that @Dereck03 already suggested NEP was wrong for Velda because whatever they are using in the profile scans and explanation doesn't grant him NEP.
There was a second time the NEP upgrade thread was made, but it was rejected by @Everything12, and the OP asked the mods to close it.
By the looks of the 3rd and 4th threads, it seems like the OP misled Elizha and DDM by wording the NEP justification however they liked. When you look at the scan and its context, nothing really indicates anything literally related to non-existence.
Tackling NEP Type 2:
@Dereck03 response to this.
There is another scan used in OP but not in the profile explanation. I'm going to address this as well, just in case someone brings it up again.
This scan is only talking about a place. It has nothing to do with NEP, unless there is solid proof that Velda predated even this void and that his existence was itself non-existent. This scan also holds no value because it is not discussing a state of being; it's just talking about a void space.
Duality arguments
The cosmology blog seems to discuss a Hell/Underworld where the Great Spirit of Darkness summons the Void. However, it never explicitly states that the Great Spirit of Darkness itself is non-existent, nor Velda, nor God. Therefore, arguments suggesting that the Great Spirit of Darkness has sub-abilities of Void Manipulation based on this do not grant NEP.
Additionally, the idea that God encompasses both existence and non-existence is a big assumption, as these concepts are not treated as dualities. Rather, they stem from the attributes of light and darkness. In the series, only light and darkness are treated as dualities according to the scans on the cosmology blog.
There is also Subspace, which is described as its own kind of Void. If supporters of Tensura can prove that God encompasses Subspace with supporting scans, then I could see a case for limited NEP type 1. However, God-Key Velda does not only encompass Subspace. He still exists and has not demonstrated any feats that indicate pure non-existence. Furthermore, this Subspace does not qualify for NEP type 2, as it is not the conventional form of "nothingness" required to prove NEP type 2 for God.
So obviously NEP type 2 justification scan is misleading. Hence it should be downgraded to limited NEP type 1 if they can prove Velda God key encompasses Subspace.
Tackling NEP Type 1 & 3:
I'm not going to bother with statements like "him being one and everything, or encompassing all, or being the world, or a fictional entity" with his vague statements, because I don’t really see how any of that supports the NEP. The NEP page even clarifies that one needs to be non-existent to gain the physiology. Which any of the scans here failed to provide or prove.
So, I suggest this also needs to be downgraded unless someone posts full scans instead of few lines with zero context. Not to mention, it has nothing to do with NEP.
If they failed to explain why NEP type 1 and 3 are valid. This also should be removed alongwith NEP type 2.
TD;LR
The scans and explanation have different contexts, and previously, OP used misleading arguments to upgrade Velda's NEP 1, 2, and 3 with little to no context. So, all NEP related content should be removed from Velda profile. Additionally, any characters who received NPI of NEP (if they have it) should also have it removed.
This guy also needs his NEP type 1 and 3 gets removed for same reasons as above.
Agree: @Dereck03 (Admin) (Agree with everything), @Planck69 (Admin) (Agree with everything), @DarkDragonMedeus (Admin) (Agree with everything),
Neutral:
Disagree:
There was a second time the NEP upgrade thread was made, but it was rejected by @Everything12, and the OP asked the mods to close it.
By the looks of the 3rd and 4th threads, it seems like the OP misled Elizha and DDM by wording the NEP justification however they liked. When you look at the scan and its context, nothing really indicates anything literally related to non-existence.
Tackling NEP Type 2:
No scans here, except this one talking about nothingness. In fact, this is not even discussing 'nothingness' in terms of non-existent physiology.
- Omnipresence, Large Size (Type 10), Nonduality (Type 1), Abstract Existence (Type 1), Nonexistent Physiology (Type 2) & Beyond-Dimensional Existence (Type 1; He is a singular existence, the primordial will that exist as and separate from everything else, his consciousness holds all things[24], the one that is all and the all that is one yet alone in the world, he is devoid of everything and nothing, for those are just pure parts of himself[24])
@Dereck03 response to this.
This is literally taking a specific context and changing it to a completely different one, Veldanava said that only his consciousness existed and that his consciousness lacked nothing as it was complete. You are taking the “lacking nothing” as if his consciousness is missing an aspect such as non-existence, nothing here is not even related to a non-existent model, only that his own being is complete and that nothing is missing.
So yeah, this is a misleading context.
So yeah, this is a misleading context.
There is another scan used in OP but not in the profile explanation. I'm going to address this as well, just in case someone brings it up again.
This scan is only talking about a place. It has nothing to do with NEP, unless there is solid proof that Velda predated even this void and that his existence was itself non-existent. This scan also holds no value because it is not discussing a state of being; it's just talking about a void space.
Duality arguments
The cosmology blog seems to discuss a Hell/Underworld where the Great Spirit of Darkness summons the Void. However, it never explicitly states that the Great Spirit of Darkness itself is non-existent, nor Velda, nor God. Therefore, arguments suggesting that the Great Spirit of Darkness has sub-abilities of Void Manipulation based on this do not grant NEP.
Additionally, the idea that God encompasses both existence and non-existence is a big assumption, as these concepts are not treated as dualities. Rather, they stem from the attributes of light and darkness. In the series, only light and darkness are treated as dualities according to the scans on the cosmology blog.
There is also Subspace, which is described as its own kind of Void. If supporters of Tensura can prove that God encompasses Subspace with supporting scans, then I could see a case for limited NEP type 1. However, God-Key Velda does not only encompass Subspace. He still exists and has not demonstrated any feats that indicate pure non-existence. Furthermore, this Subspace does not qualify for NEP type 2, as it is not the conventional form of "nothingness" required to prove NEP type 2 for God.
So obviously NEP type 2 justification scan is misleading. Hence it should be downgraded to limited NEP type 1 if they can prove Velda God key encompasses Subspace.
Tackling NEP Type 1 & 3:
Same as NEP type 2 above. NEP types 1 and 3 also have misleading explanations. There are no scans stating anything related to non-existence or nothingness. OP previously wrote this off with vague statements from scans with just few lines, which no one actually knows the full context of. One thing is certain: none of the scans here relate to non-existent physiology. They are all vague statements. Don’t look at the explanation; just look at the scans, and you’ll see what I mean.Nonexistent Physiology (Nature Types 1 & 3 ; All Aspects [Other: Fate & Story, Life and Death]; Those who ascended, have abandoned their soul, which is a source of collective consciousness, The conceptual formn which True Dragons exist as and the information that shapes reality. disappearing completely from the world, released from fate and from the story, becoming the world itself, they are fictional entities with physical bodies, thus existing and not existing simultaneously)
I'm not going to bother with statements like "him being one and everything, or encompassing all, or being the world, or a fictional entity" with his vague statements, because I don’t really see how any of that supports the NEP. The NEP page even clarifies that one needs to be non-existent to gain the physiology. Which any of the scans here failed to provide or prove.
So, I suggest this also needs to be downgraded unless someone posts full scans instead of few lines with zero context. Not to mention, it has nothing to do with NEP.
If they failed to explain why NEP type 1 and 3 are valid. This also should be removed alongwith NEP type 2.
TD;LR
The scans and explanation have different contexts, and previously, OP used misleading arguments to upgrade Velda's NEP 1, 2, and 3 with little to no context. So, all NEP related content should be removed from Velda profile. Additionally, any characters who received NPI of NEP (if they have it) should also have it removed.
This guy also needs his NEP type 1 and 3 gets removed for same reasons as above.
Granbell Rosso (Light Novel)
Tier: 6-A, Low 1-C with Disintegration | Low 1-C Key: Base | With Ultimate Skill Name: Granbell Rosso, Hero Gran, Sage of Sun Gran Origin: Tensei Shitara Slime Datta Ken Gender: Male Age: Thousands of years old Classification: Former Chosen Hero, Human Saint, Luminary Cleric, Head of the Rosso...
vsbattles.fandom.com
Agree: @Dereck03 (Admin) (Agree with everything), @Planck69 (Admin) (Agree with everything), @DarkDragonMedeus (Admin) (Agree with everything),
Neutral:
Disagree:
Last edited: