• This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.

    For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here.
  • We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.

    Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.

    Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page.
  • Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.

Tanjiro Kamado vs Toji Fushiguro

Tanjiro has all sorts of ways of getting stronger during the battle via Accelerated Development, Awakened Power, Rage Power and Stat Amps with forms of Total Concentration Breathing. He also has better skill feats than Toji.

The Inverted Spear of Heaven won't really do anything in this matchup and a regular katana isn't going to be much help so his best bet is to use the Split Soul Katana since that negs durability by bypassing the toughness of substances.

Tanjiro's Enhanced Senses of smell have let him pick up on his opponents intent and even pick up Muzan's scent in a crowded area since the start of the series, it became potent enough to allow him to predict his opponent's movements during the Swordsmith Village Arc and then Transparent World enhances his sight on top of making his perception of time slow down and allowing him to directly see the inner workings of his opponent's body to predict them with even more precision.

Toji's Enhanced Senses let him pick up on odors and footprints and see the atmosphere as scattered surfaces due to differences in temperature and density of the air around him which allows him to air jump and predict his opponents movements.

The difference between their Analytical Prediction is basically that Tanjiro can directly read his opponent and their intent while Toji sees everything around the opponent.

Overall I'd say Tanjiro should win due to having superior skill and comparable, if not better, prediction abilities as well as Toji not always opening his fights with the Split Soul Katana. (plus Red Crimson Nichirin Blade deals burn damage too)
 
Last edited:
Tanjiro has all sorts of ways of getting stronger during the battle via Accelerated Development, Awakened Power, Rage Power and Stat Amps with forms of Total Concentration Breathing. He also has better skill feats than Toji.

The Inverted Spear of Heaven won't really do anything in this matchup and a regular katana isn't going to be much help so his best bet is to use the Split Soul Katana since that negs durability by bypassing the toughness of substances.

Tanjiro's Enhanced Senses of smell have let him pick up on his opponents intent and even pick up Muzan's scent in a crowded area since the start of the series, it became potent enough to allow him to predict his opponent's movements during the Swordsmith Village Arc and then Transparent World enhances his sight on top of making his perception of time slow down and allowing him to directly see the inner workings of his opponent's body to predict them with even more precision.

Toji's Enhanced Senses let him pick up on odors and footprints and see the atmosphere as scattered surfaces due to differences in temperature and density of the air around him which allows him to air jump and predict his opponents movements.

The difference between their Analytical Prediction is basically that Tanjiro can directly read his opponent and their intent while Toji sees everything around the opponent.

Overall I'd say Tanjiro should win due to having superior skill and comparable, if not better, prediction abilities as well as Toji not always opening his fights with the Split Soul Katana. (plus Red Crimson Nichirin Blade deals burn damage too)
Putting this down as a vote for Tanjiro
Tanjiro fra
,Counted
 
Toji may be able yo try and sneak kill Tanjiro.
Toji can't sneak Tanjiro, his best stealth feat is catching a worn out Teen Gojo off guard and the fact that he was against people relying on sensing Cursed Energy was also a factor. Tanjiro would immediately pick up on Toji's scent and easily track him down.
 
wait wait

What is tanjiro's answer for the one shot, durability negating (both for people and objects like tanjiro's sword) cursed tool that is the soul libiration blade?
 
It’s going to be nearly impossible for Toji to land a hit due to STW. So he takes him down before he gets cursed.
 
wait wait

What is tanjiro's answer for the one shot, durability negating (both for people and objects like tanjiro's sword) cursed tool that is the soul libiration blade?
Outskiling apparently since it won’t hit him with his analytical prediction.
 
also there is a pretty big AP gap between the two, Tanjiro is somewhere in 8-A as we up scale him from 8-B (which is kinda against the rules for the most part but **** it) while toji is just flat out vastly above 260 tons meaning he is at least 2x stronger than tanjiro.
 
What is tanjiro's answer for the one shot, durability negating (both for people and objects like tanjiro's sword) cursed tool that is the soul libiration blade?
Tanjiro's Enhanced Senses of smell have let him pick up on his opponents intent and even pick up Muzan's scent in a crowded area since the start of the series, it became potent enough to allow him to predict his opponent's movements during the Swordsmith Village Arc and then Transparent World enhances his sight on top of making his perception of time slow down and allowing him to directly see the inner workings of his opponent's body to predict them with even more precision.
Overall I'd say Tanjiro should win due to having superior skill and comparable, if not better, prediction abilities as well as Toji not always opening his fights with the Split Soul Katana. (plus Red Crimson Nichirin Blade deals burn damage too)
also there is a pretty big AP gap between the two, Tanjiro is somewhere in 8-A as we up scale him from 8-B (which is kinda against the rules for the most part but **** it) while toji is just flat out vastly above 260 tons meaning he is at least 2x stronger than tanjiro.
Tanjiro has all sorts of ways of getting stronger during the battle via Accelerated Development, Awakened Power, Rage Power and Stat Amps with forms of Total Concentration Breathing.
 
that doesn't answer much other than he will dodge every strike which in this fight is unlikely to happen due to their anylitical prediction being comperable (with tanjiro having better overall but not by too much, mainly due to transparent world rather than the smell thing since honestly the actual ability to see the what's going to happen is better than being able to smell it) and with toji having outright better movement options with air walking and mid air acrobatics creating a situation where tanjiro has better anylitical prediction via transparent world but has lesser options when it comes to answering his opponents movements due to them basically being able to walk on air.

Yeah unless those Amps are actually quantifiable the more than 2 times AP and dura difference isn't becoming much smaller and don't bring up the whole the mark makes him 100 times stronger cuse at that point you will need to make a CRT for turning demon slayer 7-C for the top tiers while also trying to not adress the whole upscaling to a whole different tier without proper statements for a feat that is already questionable when it comes to scaling characters physicals to it (the whole sukunas fire arrow situation and the planetery devestation from naruto that is actually being adressed currently, honestly I got half a mind to actually make a CRT to dget that adressed) but I digress. Those stat amps without actual proper statements about how much they actually improve the characters stats don't provide a 2 times amp to cover half the AP difference between the two. The only thing really is the speed being increased to the point of blitzing with certain moves that are rarely used by tanjiro in character like waltz flash which will allow him to blitz toji while sacrafising some power output due to having to switch breathing forms to lighting brething to actually use this one. There is also the problem of the low-mid regen that tanjiro can't actually adress due to ya know, toji not being a demon meaning that tanjiro would have to dish out a whole heap of damage to actually put toji down.

Honestly this is an interesting fight and I don't know who wins it, but I don't find your arguments for tanjiro all that convincing @SunDaGamer
 
that doesn't answer much other than he will dodge every strike which in this fight is unlikely to happen due to their anylitical prediction being comperable (with tanjiro having better overall but not by too much, mainly due to transparent world rather than the smell thing since honestly the actual ability to see the what's going to happen is better than being able to smell it) and with toji having outright better movement options with air walking and mid air acrobatics creating a situation where tanjiro has better anylitical prediction via transparent world but has lesser options when it comes to answering his opponents movements due to them basically being able to walk on air.

Yeah unless those Amps are actually quantifiable the more than 2 times AP and dura difference isn't becoming much smaller and don't bring up the whole the mark makes him 100 times stronger cuse at that point you will need to make a CRT for turning demon slayer 7-C for the top tiers while also trying to not adress the whole upscaling to a whole different tier without proper statements for a feat that is already questionable when it comes to scaling characters physicals to it (the whole sukunas fire arrow situation and the planetery devestation from naruto that is actually being adressed currently, honestly I got half a mind to actually make a CRT to dget that adressed) but I digress. Those stat amps without actual proper statements about how much they actually improve the characters stats don't provide a 2 times amp to cover half the AP difference between the two. The only thing really is the speed being increased to the point of blitzing with certain moves that are rarely used by tanjiro in character like waltz flash which will allow him to blitz toji while sacrafising some power output due to having to switch breathing forms to lighting brething to actually use this one. There is also the problem of the low-mid regen that tanjiro can't actually adress due to ya know, toji not being a demon meaning that tanjiro would have to dish out a whole heap of damage to actually put toji down.

Honestly this is an interesting fight and I don't know who wins it, but I don't find your arguments for tanjiro all that convincing @SunDaGamer
I’m gonna make some points myself here.
Tanjiros analytical prediction greatly outscales Tojis own, with him being able to smell atleast 6 moves ahead- and he is capable of even seeing what move an opponent is going to use by small shifts in their body and muscles, and even their expressions(as we see when he does this against Tomioka) here

Also, Tanjiro isn’t silly, if he is finding trouble to hit an opponent..He will use the waltz flash. Tanjiro literally does this when he is in a pickle and can’t catch up to Hantegu, so he will use waltz flash against a running Toji.
Also, Toji had low mid regen over time.
 
that doesn't answer much other than he will dodge every strike which in this fight is unlikely to happen due to their anylitical prediction being comperable (with tanjiro having better overall but not by too much, mainly due to transparent world rather than the smell thing since honestly the actual ability to see the what's going to happen is better than being able to smell it)
His sense of smell lets him read his opponent's movements and track them down, then Transparent World stacks another level of Analytical Prediction on top of that by slowing down his perception of time and letting him see his opponent's muscles and blood vessels in fine detail. People like Gyomei and Muichiro after sustaining multiple injuries were able to counter Kokushibo's prediction and land multiple hits on him when they were able to use Transparent World too. Tanjiro was already capable of countering Akaza before learning Transparent World (only sustaining damage despite blocking Akaza's attacks due to Akaza's overwhelming strength) while Akaza was using Compass Needle (which allows Akaza to predict his opponent's movements by sensing their fighting spirit and enhances his Instinctive Action, awareness and accuracy to the point that his attacks are described to be like a magnet pulling towards his opponent's vitals) once Tanjiro did start tapping into Transparent World, he outright dodged one of Akaza's unerring blows. Tanjiro's instinctive action also allowed him to dodge Muzan's attacks which faster than his eyes could track while he was injured and fatigued from his fight with Akaza.
toji having outright better movement options with air walking and mid air acrobatics creating a situation where tanjiro has better anylitical prediction via transparent world but has lesser options when it comes to answering his opponents movements due to them basically being able to walk on air.
I don't see how Toji's movements are going to pose much of a problem for Tanjiro, an injured Beginning of Series Tanjiro could dodge Kyogai's Rapid Drumming spamming claw attacks while spinning around his environment, flinging him around the air, and he even had the prowess to avoid stepping on any sheets of paper flying around the room. Toji still has to travel toward Tanjiro like this to hit him which Tanjiro (and worn out Teen Gojo) can easily counter. Mid-air manoeuvres are something Tanjiro can do even after going 5 days without proper food or water although it's not as freely moving as Toji's air jumping.
Yeah unless those Amps are actually quantifiable the more than 2 times AP and dura difference isn't becoming much smaller
Those stat amps without actual proper statements about how much they actually improve the characters stats don't provide a 2 times amp to cover half the AP difference between the two.
The amps don't have to close the x2 gap entirely, they just make it smaller which is more than enough for this matchup because a gap like that is pretty much irrelevant when it comes to a sword fight where the weapons are supposed to slice apart the things comparable to them.
The only thing really is the speed being increased to the point of blitzing with certain moves that are rarely used by tanjiro in character like waltz flash which will allow him to blitz toji while sacrafising some power output due to having to switch breathing forms to lighting brething to actually use this one.
Tanjiro blitzed Gyutaro by combining Water Breathing with Hinokami Kagura despite Gyutaro being able to blitz him before not to mention that Breathing Styles can extend his range to Several Meters. Tanjiro can also use Fake Rainbow to create an afterimage that gets more effective the better his opponent's sense of sight is and Solar Heat Blaze which masks the actual reach of Tanjiro's sword with a heat haze and allowed him to get a cut into Akaza's neck despite him seeming to dodge it. The idea that Tanjiro wouldn't use a technique that increases his speed if he can't hit his opponent is pretty silly.
There is also the problem of the low-mid regen that tanjiro can't actually adress due to ya know, toji not being a demon meaning that tanjiro would have to dish out a whole heap of damage to actually put toji down
Toji's regen isn't going to be a factor here. A cut in the gut at the end of her first fight with Ogi was still affecting Maki in her fight against Naoya and it would take her 5 minutes to recover from internal damage. I'm not sure Toji should even have Low-Mid regen considering the injury that killed him is within the ballpark of his regen tier and Maki and Toji don't have RCT levels of regen to be regenerating lost limbs or disembowelment.
 
Toji isn't even likely to start with Split Soul Katana, he used a regular katana aginst Gojo first and then pulled up on Geto with a glock, he only opened with Split Soul Katana on curses
cept for two little things you forgot.

He specifically used a regular katana on gojo so that gojo couldn't track the cursed energy in the soul split or the spear of heaven and he used regular weapons on Geto because he didn't know if killing him would release all of his curses (and he also used a glock on the star plasma vessel so that geto couldn't sense him, which in turn ment he couldn't protect her in time)

And every time he had an opponent he could kill without having to sneak up on them, bypass infinity or having to worry about the release of cursed spirits he always pulled out the soul split and ended the fight in a single strike.

So yeah don't ignore context.
 
he used regular weapons on Geto because he didn't know if killing him would release all of his curses
He literally used the Split Soul Katana on Geto after breaking out of Kuchisake-Onna's simple domain to exorcise it and stagger Geto at the same time
 
Last edited:
His sense of smell lets him read his opponent's movements and track them down, then Transparent World stacks another level of Analytical Prediction on top of that by slowing down his perception of time and letting him see his opponent's muscles and blood vessels in fine detail.
again this is base analytical predication at best for the smell as it requires a specific sense that can be thrown of pretty badly, the transparent world is where its at as it actually allows for fine detail on the opponents movements and is actually better than being able to see atmospheric shifts.
People like Gyomei and Muichiro after sustaining multiple injuries were able to counter Kokushibo's prediction and land multiple hits on him when they were able to use Transparent World too. Tanjiro was already capable of countering Akaza before learning Transparent World (only sustaining damage despite blocking Akaza's attacks due to Akaza's overwhelming strength)
Yeah, right after Akaza stopped decided to talk to tanjiro for a bit and then after tanjiro barely block this attack at the last moment he decided to praise tanjiro and gloat
kimetsu_no_yaiba_148_13.jpg
kimetsu_no_yaiba_148_14.jpg
kimetsu_no_yaiba_148_15.jpg

Don't know about you but to me this doesn't seem like the behavior of a guy trying his hardest to kill, Akaza was for all intents and purposes playing with his food and it can be seen in the next chapter 149 that he indeed was because the moment akaza started to get even remotely serious, he started rag dolling tanjiro
kimetsu_no_yaiba_149_6.jpg
kimetsu_no_yaiba_149_7.jpg
kimetsu_no_yaiba_149_9.jpg

Hell tanjiro himself even says that he is unable to predict Akazas moves.
He manages to land a single blow on akaza through a specific technique that make his blade waver like its in a haze
kimetsu_no_yaiba_149_12.jpg

and this intrigues akaza to the point where he starts playing around again
kimetsu_no_yaiba_149_16.jpg
kimetsu_no_yaiba_149_17.jpg
kimetsu_no_yaiba_149_18.jpg

and even with akaza not going in for the kill with say a kick (which would kill tanjiro at this point) he just stands there and lets tanjiro try escaping to the point where tanjiro has to get saved.

And this is even more clear a chapter later where tanjiro can't even get off a surprise attack on akaza while he is fighting Giyuu
kimetsu_no_yaiba_150_16.jpg

while Akaza was using Compass Needle (which allows Akaza to predict his opponent's movements by sensing their fighting spirit and enhances his Instinctive Action, awareness and accuracy to the point that his attacks are described to be like a magnet pulling towards his opponent's vitals) once Tanjiro did start tapping into Transparent World, he outright dodged one of Akaza's unerring blows. Tanjiro's instinctive action also allowed him to dodge Muzan's attacks which faster than his eyes could track while he was injured and fatigued from his fight with Akaza.
In every one of those scans tanjiro has transparent world and it is the ability that makes this fight actually interesting
I don't see how Toji's movements are going to pose much of a problem for Tanjiro, an injured Beginning of Series Tanjiro could dodge Kyogai's Rapid Drumming spamming claw attacks while spinning around his environment, flinging him around the air, and he even had the prowess to avoid stepping on any sheets of paper flying around the room.
Cool? I mean he didn't step on a piece of paper while he was falling and that whole fight boiled down to a very basic pattern, room spins, there is a smell of mold which means the claws are coming repeat. This is not at all impressive against an opponent that has literally endless options to approach you with and one tap you with a single strike of his weapon.
Toji still has to travel toward Tanjiro like this to hit him which Tanjiro
yeah and unlike Kyogai he can come from literally any direction he could be going right at you instantly jump into the air, hop right off the air to be above or behind you and unlike Kyogai this doesn't have a pattern of just "room spins, claws shoot out" This isn't even comparable.
(and worn out Teen Gojo) can easily counter.
my man gojo had blue which can literally say no to any physical movement due to its attracting force tanjiro ain't got that (and even then toji's movements where so fast and unorthodox that gojo even with his six eyes which themselves provide a great deal of analytical prediction couldn't actually keep up to the point where gojo went for his nuclear option of lapse blue)
Mid-air manoeuvres are something Tanjiro can do even after going 5 days without proper food or water although it's not as freely moving as Toji's air jumping.
they are not where near as impressive, he has the most basic air maneuvering one can has while toji can basically fly through air hops.
The amps don't have to close the x2 gap entirely, they just make it smaller which is more than enough for this matchup because a gap like that is pretty much irrelevant when it comes to a sword fight where the weapons are supposed to slice apart the things comparable to them.
the gap is at least 2.6 times and while yes sword can do more damage to comparable opponents with ever increasing gaps it becomes less and less effective tanjiro upscales from doma (which is already a bit of a take if you ask me) to slightly above baseline 8-A or 100 tons of TNT while toji massively upscale to a pre realization Maki who was able to tank an attack worth 261 tons of TNT while still recovering from a sever injury she took prior to her heavenly restriction being fully realized and then she proceeded to actually rip out the attackers throat with her hands without even trying. The actual gap in power here is massive something that unspecified stat amps can't close at all.
Tanjiro blitzed Gyutaro by combining Water Breathing with Hinokami Kagura despite Gyutaro being able to blitz him before not to mention that Breathing Styles can extend his range to Several Meters.
yeah small problem, Gyutaro wasn't focusing on tanjiro and was outright underestimating him when this happened.
kimetsu_no_yaiba_90_13.jpg
kimetsu_no_yaiba_90_14.jpg
kimetsu_no_yaiba_90_15.jpg
kimetsu_no_yaiba_90_16.jpg

and tanjiro couldn't keep up with gyutaro throughout the rest of the fight prior to the mark

Also this stat amp isn't used by this key as it required tanjiro to use water breathing in combination with sun breathing because his body couldn't handle sun breathing at that point and this key is constantly using sun breathing to actually be on the 8-A level, unless you want to claim that he is 8-A without any breathing styles which would be a hell of a take I'll tell you what.
again more his base speed now.
which masks the actual reach of Tanjiro's sword with a heat haze and allowed him to get a cut into Akaza's neck despite him seeming to dodge it. The idea that Tanjiro wouldn't use a technique that increases his speed if he can't hit his opponent is pretty silly.
this is a specific technique that allows tanjiro to confusing his opponent, I mean Akaza was outright speed blitzing the poor shmuck prior to this moment and after it.and while this specific move will let tanjiro hit toji it isn't related to speed.
Toji's regen isn't going to be a factor here. A cut in the gut at the end of her first fight with Ogi was still affecting Maki in her fight against Naoya and it would take her 5 minutes to recover from internal damage.
One the cut was literally done a couple of minutes ago to a maki that didn't have regen at all as she didn't fully unleash her heavenly restriction yet. I mean it literally went maki V Ogi, she gets her intestines cut up with a few of her organs to boot and she got up when she her heavenly restriction was fully in effect, killed a whole room full of cursed spirits and then proceeded to blitz and one tap Ogi with the soul split, she then fought the whole Zen-in clan and when she fought Naoya it was stated that due to all of that, she would be at a disadvantage against a speedster in a prolonged fight hardly an anti feat. The internal damage didn't even take her 5 mins to recover as was stated by kamo a bit later;
https://cdn.****************.com/file/CDN-M-A-N/jjk_195_009.png

even though she hasn't fully recovered she was already in a good enough shape to actually fight again in less than 3 mins after having her insides ruptured by vengeful sprit naoya to the point where she couldn't even stand even though she was able to fully fight unhindered after having a flaming sword cut through her intestines, liver and kidneys looking at the placement of the slash.
I'm not sure Toji should even have Low-Mid regen considering the injury that killed him is within the ballpark of his regen tier and Maki and Toji don't have RCT levels of regen to be regenerating lost limbs or disembowelment.
My man, that is the extreme of Low-Mid, Low-mid is regen that at its base allows you to recover from heavy internal damage like ruptured organs, split intestines and shattered bone all of the things that maki has demonstrated, you are talking about the absolute peak of low-Mid that basically allows you to regenerate a fully destroyed body its big jump.
Maki has low-mid just on a lower scale of it and toji scales (also both of them can survive disembowelment cuse maki already did, hell high-low can let you survive disembowelments) So the regen is still a big issue for tanjiro in this fight.
 
He literally used the Split Soul Katana on Geto after breaking out of Kuchisake-Onna's simple domain to exorcise it and stagger Geto at the same time
no he didn't or geto would be dead he used a basic ass katan on him look at this
https://cdn.****************.com/file/CDN-M-A-N/kaisentcb_73_14.jpg
look at the pommel of the katan, it has a chain
now here is the soul split:
https://cdn.****************.com/file/CDN-M-A-N/kaisentcb_73_07.jpg
as you can see it has a solid pommel that splits two ways, no chain.

I mean we can use the anime to make it pretty clear.


2:25: toji pulls out the katana and it has a guard something that the soul split does not.

Also if he did use the soul split it would contradict its actual powers as that blade would split geto into 4 pieces when used like that
 
here is a better look of the soul split if ya need it
https://cdn.****************.com/file/CDN-M-A-N/jjk_150_002.png

as you can see the handle doesn't match at all with the katana toji actually pulled out.

Likely some basic cursed weapon that just had CE in it.
 
I’m gonna make some points myself here.
Tanjiros analytical prediction greatly outscales Tojis own,
with see through world? agreed. with the smelling thing? no.
with him being able to smell at least 6 moves ahead- and he is capable of even seeing what move an opponent is going to use by small shifts in their body and muscles, and even their expressions(as we see when he does this against Tomioka)
yeah see through world, the actual part of tanjiro's analytical prediction that is better than toji's
Did you get the right scan? because this is talking about Giyuu and that tanjiro can't read his expression not that he can see what the opponent is going to do based on expressions (although that would not be useful in this fight)
Also, Tanjiro isn’t silly, if he is finding trouble to hit an opponent..He will use the waltz flash. Tanjiro literally does this when he is in a pickle and can’t catch up to Hantegu, so he will use waltz flash against a running Toji.
he never used flash waltz again in the series even against opponents that vastly out scale his speed and that has a reason to it, breathing styles and their effects this key of tanjiro primarily uses sun breathing as it is the best all rounder of all breathing styles and if he where to use waltz flash he would be drastically cutting down his power to actually blitz toji and due to the already present power gap that would result in nothing, as tanjiro would not do any significant damage by actually limiting his power output by using thunder breathing.
Also, Toji had low mid regen over time.
not really, he much like maki is able to regenerate severe internal damage in a matter of minutes, overtime would imply this level of damage being regenerated over hours which is not the case by demonstrated feats.
 
Honestly this is a really finicky fight, both have their own big advantages over the other, with tanjiro's better speed with sun waltz and demon slayer mark as well as better prediction through the see through world and toji having superior AP, regen and stamina advantage as well as the soul split which will end the fight if he lands any type of hit as even if it is blocked tanjiro's sword would be done for as soul split cleaves through both living and unliving things ignoring the durability of both flesh and steel, meaning that if tanjiro goes for a block or a deflect he is losing his sword and at that point it's a wrap as ya know that AP difference and regen makes it an impossibility for tanjiro to win if he does lose his sword.


Honestly I still need to think about this.
 
again this is base analytical predication at best for the smell as it requires a specific sense that can be thrown of pretty badly
How is Toji going to throw off Tanjiro's sense of smell, he can't blitz Tanjiro and he doesn't have Fragrance Manipulation, That's like saying Toji's analytical prediction is base at best because someone with Air Manipulation can throw off that specific sense completely.. Meanwhile, Tanjiro picked up on Muzan's scent (despite never directly meeting Muzan beforehand) in the middle of a crowd that was a distance away from him. He can pick up on the scent of traps while the air around him is even thinner than on the mountain he grew up on. He can straight up smell an opening thread where he can strike his opponent, smell emotions, smell a demon hiding in a pocket dimension and the sense he developed while training against the Yoriichi doll are even faster than the opening thread and allowed him to compete against the Yoriichi doll which was wielding 5 swords with 5 hands working in unison.
Yeah, right after Akaza stopped decided to talk to tanjiro for a bit and then after tanjiro barely block this attack at the last moment he decided to praise tanjiro and gloat
Akaza doesn't acknowledge people who can't at least stand up to him, the fact that Tanjiro could even remotely stand against Akaza while he was using the Compass Needle and it's multitude of buffs to Instinctive Action, Awareness, Senses, Analytical Prediction and Accelerated Development is a better feat against another person using Analytical Prediction than Toji's non-existent ones.
Don't know about you but to me this doesn't seem like the behavior of a guy trying his hardest to kill, Akaza was for all intents and purposes playing with his food and it can be seen in the next chapter 149 that he indeed was because the moment akaza started to get even remotely serious, he started rag dolling tanjiro
kimetsu_no_yaiba_149_6.jpg
kimetsu_no_yaiba_149_7.jpg
kimetsu_no_yaiba_149_9.jpg
Your scans literally show Tanjiro reacting to and blocking Akaza's attacks but getting overwhelmed due to the strength of Akaza blows, Akaza's Blood Demon Art: Destructive Death is all about explosive power and shockwaves so simply blocking them with a sword isn't going to nullify the power behind his attacks. Akaza not going in for an immediate kill against Tanjiro means he isn't going to spam his strongest Destructive Death attacks like the Chaotic Afterglow which completely surrounds the area in a Danmaku attack, not that he's going to start ignoring all of Compass Needle's buffs, Tanjiro even affirms that Akaza is still fighting with precision when he states it's as if Akaza's attacks are magnetically attracted to his vitals.
Hell tanjiro himself even says that he is unable to predict Akazas moves.
No, he says even if he can somehow predict Akaza's moves (which he has demonstrated he can albeit with difficulty) he still gets damaged. That's a different statement to what you're claiming.
In every one of those scans tanjiro has transparent world
And I never said he didn't?
Cool? I mean he didn't step on a piece of paper while he was falling and that whole fight boiled down to a very basic pattern, room spins, there is a smell of mold which means the claws are coming repeat. This is not at all impressive against an opponent that has literally endless options to approach you with and one tap you with a single strike of his weapon.
Having your footing and entire environment constantly spun around would disorientate you yet Tanjiro can still fight in those conditions while suffering from multiple injuries in his previous fight, and you've listed another feat for Tanjiro's senses. Toji approaching Tanjiro from any angle in the air is pretty much a non-issue considering fending off attacks coming from multiple angles is something he can do easily and it's not as if Toji has a speed advantage here to throw Tanjiro off.
yeah and unlike Kyogai he can come from literally any direction he could be going right at you instantly jump into the air, hop right off the air to be above or behind you and unlike Kyogai this doesn't have a pattern of just "room spins, claws shoot out" This isn't even comparable.
I'd say having your environment constantly spun around and disorientating you while attacks coming in 5s are trying to hit you is worse than some dude going at your own pace air jumping, something that even Teen Gojo while exhausted could counter in time.
my man gojo had blue which can literally say no to any physical movement
Gojo didn't activate Blue until Toji came in for a swing and it's not as if Gojo had mastered minimizing the hand signs of his technique at this point.
pre realization Maki who was able to tank an attack worth 261 tons of TNT
That calc isn't valid because it makes a Semi-Grade 1 Zenin fodder comparable to Naobito and Naoya's top speeds.
the gap is at least 2.6 times and while yes sword can do more damage to comparable opponents with ever increasing gaps it becomes less and less effective
Tanjiro's whole shtick is decapitating Demons which requires completely slicing through the toughest part of their body, things like this are why AP gaps like x2.6 are pretty insignificant in sword fights.
yeah small problem, Gyutaro wasn't focusing on tanjiro and was outright underestimating him when this happened.
Gyutaro almost blitzed Tanjiro, who was moving at a snail pace compared to Gyutaro, previously and would've hit him if Uzui didn't push him out of the way. Then Tanjiro proceeds to cover several meters while Gyutaro barely reacts and even comments on Tanjiro moving fast. That's a pretty considerable difference.
Also this stat amp isn't used by this key as it required tanjiro to use water breathing in combination with sun breathing
All Breathing Techniques stat amp according to his profile and it's pretty nonsensical to argue that Tanjiro combining Water Breathing with Hinokami Kagura after taking several severe injuries is more of an amp than when Tanjiro masters Hinokami Kagura.
  • Statistics Amplification (Total Concentration Breathing makes the user become much stronger and faster, Constant Flux gradually increases the strength of his strike with each rotation due to momentum, increases his power and speed with Hinokami Kagura/Breath of the Sun)
this is a specific technique that allows tanjiro to confusing his opponent, I mean Akaza was outright speed blitzing the poor shmuck prior to this moment and after it.and while this specific move will let tanjiro hit toji it isn't related to speed.
Hence Tanjiro has ways of hitting Toji even with equal speed by extending his range
killed a whole room full of cursed spirits and then proceeded to blitz and one tap Ogi with the soul split, she then fought the whole Zen-in clan and when she fought Naoya it was stated that due to all of that, she would be at a disadvantage against a speedster in a prolonged fight hardly an anti feat.
There was more than enough time from killing the cursed spirits to being confronted by the Kukuru Unit to defeating the Hei and fighting Naoya for her injuries against Ogi to no longer be a factor due to her regen.
My man, that is the extreme of Low-Mid, Low-mid is regen that at its base allows you to recover from heavy internal damage like ruptured organs, split intestines and shattered bone all of the things that maki has demonstrated, you are talking about the absolute peak of low-Mid that basically allows you to regenerate a fully destroyed body its big jump.
Maki has low-mid just on a lower scale of it and toji scales (also both of them can survive disembowelment cuse maki already did, hell high-low can let you survive disembowelments) So the regen is still a big issue for tanjiro in this fight.
The ability to regenerate lost limbs, limited brain damage, and even severe organ damage or destruction, including traditionally fatal wounds and disembowelment or horizontal bisection.
Neither Toji nor Maki have feats of regening lost limbs and brain damage. Disembowlment means "to remove the bowels or entrails from; eviscerate" and horizontal bisection is offing them (kinda like it did Gojo). Kamo says he suspects Maki suffered internal damage with no specification that it's severe organ damage or destruction and coughing up blood happens due to bleeding from damaged blood vessels filling the lungs, healing those is Low Regen. At best they've got low end Low-Mid regen that takes several minutes to make a full recovery from internal damage whilst Tanjiro is used to fighting Upper Moons that can regen to a far greater degree than Toji and Maki in an instant. You said disembowlment can be survived with High-Low regen, I'd say Toji and Maki should be there instead then.
if he where to use waltz flash he would be drastically cutting down his power to actually blitz toji and due to the already present power gap that would result in nothing
Tanjiro uses Hinokami Kagura to slash Hantengu as soon as he caught up to him with Waltz Flash, you can even see the fire trail in his swing.
 
Neither Toji nor Maki have feats of regening lost limbs and brain damage. Disembowlment means "to remove the bowels or entrails from; eviscerate" and horizontal bisection is offing them (kinda like it did Gojo). Kamo says he suspects Maki suffered internal damage with no specification that it's severe organ damage or destruction and coughing up blood happens due to bleeding from damaged blood vessels filling the lungs, healing those is Low Regen. At best they've got low end Low-Mid regen that takes several minutes to make a full recovery from internal damage whilst Tanjiro is used to fighting Upper Moons that can regen to a far greater degree than Toji and Maki in an instant. You said disembowlment can be survived with High-Low regen, I'd say Toji and Maki should be there instead then.
don't have time to make a full response to it today but this is.

Low-Mid: The ability to regenerate lost limbs, limited brain damage, and even severe organ damage or destruction, including traditionally fatal wounds and disembowelment or horizontal bisection. For machines and vehicles, this would be regenerating minor parts and more extensive internal damage.

Maki has outright shown that she can recover from a slash across her mid section that went through a solid chunk of her torso (damn near full on cut in half) and we even see her guts being cut in a panel prior to it happening and again the location of the slash, it likely went through her liver and kidneys which is what give maki the low level Low-mid regen meaning she ain't growing back limbs but she can quickly recover her organs being destroyed, which is also what makes the damage recived from naoya that sever, being disembowled and having multiple organs damaged massively didn't slow down the full heavenly restriction maki for a second and after naoya she flat out couldn't stand for two minutes straight, meaning her organs where more than likely damn near mush after that strike.

and while yeah high-low allows you to survive disembowlment it sure as hell will not allow you to just push through it and keep fighting unless you want to give maki and toji immortality type 2 which hey that can work but the effect would be damn near the same as low-mid regen anyway.
 
don't have time to make a full response to it today but this is.

Low-Mid: The ability to regenerate lost limbs, limited brain damage, and even severe organ damage or destruction, including traditionally fatal wounds and disembowelment or horizontal bisection. For machines and vehicles, this would be regenerating minor parts and more extensive internal damage.

Maki has outright shown that she can recover from a slash across her mid section that went through a solid chunk of her torso (damn near full on cut in half) and we even see her guts being cut in a panel prior to it happening and again the location of the slash, it likely went through her liver and kidneys which is what give maki the low level Low-mid regen meaning she ain't growing back limbs but she can quickly recover her organs being destroyed, which is also what makes the damage recived from naoya that sever, being disembowled and having multiple organs damaged massively didn't slow down the full heavenly restriction maki for a second and after naoya she flat out couldn't stand for two minutes straight, meaning her organs where more than likely damn near mush after that strike.

and while yeah high-low allows you to survive disembowlment it sure as hell will not allow you to just push through it and keep fighting unless you want to give maki and toji immortality type 2 which hey that can work but the effect would be damn near the same as low-mid regen anyway.
I zoomed in on this and it looks like Maki's intestine is hanging out so I'll concede on that, Maki's profile shouldn't use the damage Curse Naoya as evidence for Low-Mid tho
 
I zoomed in on this and it looks like Maki's intestine is hanging out so I'll concede on that, Maki's profile shouldn't use the damage Curse Naoya as evidence for Low-Mid tho
I mean this is the panel right before she gets her guts spilled
https://cdn.****************.com/file/CDN-M-A-N/jjk_148_v2_17.png
We can see the sword going into her intestines.

also the naoya thing should be more supporting evidence than anything
 
Back
Top