- 15,474
- 22,562
I don’t think Saitama’s a maniac but his spirit doesn’t seem to be indomitable as your average Shonen protag it seems. Dude saw red and lost himself for a moment
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
STRONGEST One-Punch Man Discussion Thread!
- Thread starter Phoenks
- Start date
- 1,716
- 855
To be fair, it destroying the solar system and so on was the combined power of Garou and Saitama colliding with each other. It could be that it was exponentially increased in power (which explains the Punch^2 as the chapter title).
Later we see Saitama doing Serious Punch against Garou again and again with it all not being close to being as destructive.
- 3,690
- 646
Next chapter gonna reveal that this is all part of Saitama master plan.
- 1,641
- 1,136
Link?
- 1,716
- 855
In defense to Saitama, many Shonen protags have a Berserk button that have them let loose a destructive power with no conscious thought of their surroundings.
- 3,690
- 646
Oh boy
- 11,606
- 10,785
- Thread starter
- #51,087
Does this seem fair for Garou?
Attack Potency: Large Planet level (Created a black hole), possibly Large Star level (His attack was compared to a real Gamma Ray Burst which produces at least 1 foe or 10^44 joules of energy). Up to Multi-Solar System level with Power Mimicry (Copied and matched Saitama's Serious Punch, producing an explosion that annihilated millions of stars)
Attack Potency: Large Planet level (Created a black hole), possibly Large Star level (His attack was compared to a real Gamma Ray Burst which produces at least 1 foe or 10^44 joules of energy). Up to Multi-Solar System level with Power Mimicry (Copied and matched Saitama's Serious Punch, producing an explosion that annihilated millions of stars)
- 3,690
- 646
- 2,509
- 2,112
Yes but I think "likely" is more fair.
- 3,690
- 646
- 3,084
- 1,145
I quoted the guy who showed the pic.
- 15,474
- 22,562
- 4,004
- 2,798
I'm sorry to say that I don't have one, I'm in the translation discord and that's where I saw the fan translation team discuss the "well you can take the plunge" translation. When Onenation brought the subject up, Graywords replied with a screenshot of his reddit post. If you really want it from me I can ask him tomorrow because i'm going to bed right now
- 11,606
- 10,785
- Thread starter
- #51,095
What I've got for Awakened Garou's Intelligence.
Intelligence: Extraordinary Genius. Gained knowledge on the behavior of all forces and flow of all energy in the universe, and applied this knowledge through replicating complex natural phenomena such as nuclear fission and gamma ray bursts. His aptitude for martial arts and fighting has increased to the point that he can perfectly mimic both the power and technique of skills, including those that can manipulate the reality of the cosmos, in a single glance, and further improve them to perfection past the original states. Garou has stated that his fist is beyond timing, and that all of his strikes are completely unavoidable.
Intelligence: Extraordinary Genius. Gained knowledge on the behavior of all forces and flow of all energy in the universe, and applied this knowledge through replicating complex natural phenomena such as nuclear fission and gamma ray bursts. His aptitude for martial arts and fighting has increased to the point that he can perfectly mimic both the power and technique of skills, including those that can manipulate the reality of the cosmos, in a single glance, and further improve them to perfection past the original states. Garou has stated that his fist is beyond timing, and that all of his strikes are completely unavoidable.
Last edited:
- 206
- 71
- 89
- 17
do
you think if it's a black hole murata will draw it like that
- 190
- 108
How about this?
Here I want to calc Speed Garou and Saitama.
Garou and Saitama distance : 14+16+19+21+24+47+11+12+35+23+16+13+8+9+11+44+23+64+21+40+13+16+10 +18+27+15+15+56+98+18+29+24+20+35+12+34+35+17+10+28+22+9+60+31+28+20+32+27 +10+9+8+17+21+54+20+26+20+27+10+13+16+7+25+29+14+18+53+13+39+20+16+36+18 +18+16+27+18+36+16+14+14+19+92+33+50+17+22+31+23+11+24+50+106+22+22+31+31+32 +20+16+20+14+15+15+20+17+15+17+4+17+51+26+16+36+25+17+22+20+14+15+15+20+32 +18+48+22+22+35+11+19+12+13+13+23+46+13+18+30+25+43+29+21+21+25+45+52*+31+ 22+15+22+33+16+50+41+14+16+19+20+28+14+17+24+19+30+12+36+25+16+50+16+14+24+ 14+16+26+10+137+30+41+12+13+13+13+33+19+24+32+21+37+25+18+14+21+28+28+28+49+ 22+17+53+16+42+16+48+38+50+34+17+16+25+14+25+42
Total 5448px
Io Satellite Diameter 3642000m (388px)
Distance 5448px=51.138.185.6 m
Later, we'll just make the total distance × 2, because what we calculate is half the area of the front ball layer, but not yet.
Time frame assumption is 0.0013 because Garou himself can't react for a while.
Speed=d/t
D=102.276371
T=0.0013
Divide by SOL for result in c
MFTL 262.42c
Here I want to calc Speed Garou and Saitama.
Garou and Saitama distance : 14+16+19+21+24+47+11+12+35+23+16+13+8+9+11+44+23+64+21+40+13+16+10 +18+27+15+15+56+98+18+29+24+20+35+12+34+35+17+10+28+22+9+60+31+28+20+32+27 +10+9+8+17+21+54+20+26+20+27+10+13+16+7+25+29+14+18+53+13+39+20+16+36+18 +18+16+27+18+36+16+14+14+19+92+33+50+17+22+31+23+11+24+50+106+22+22+31+31+32 +20+16+20+14+15+15+20+17+15+17+4+17+51+26+16+36+25+17+22+20+14+15+15+20+32 +18+48+22+22+35+11+19+12+13+13+23+46+13+18+30+25+43+29+21+21+25+45+52*+31+ 22+15+22+33+16+50+41+14+16+19+20+28+14+17+24+19+30+12+36+25+16+50+16+14+24+ 14+16+26+10+137+30+41+12+13+13+13+33+19+24+32+21+37+25+18+14+21+28+28+28+49+ 22+17+53+16+42+16+48+38+50+34+17+16+25+14+25+42
Total 5448px
Io Satellite Diameter 3642000m (388px)
Distance 5448px=51.138.185.6 m
Later, we'll just make the total distance × 2, because what we calculate is half the area of the front ball layer, but not yet.
Time frame assumption is 0.0013 because Garou himself can't react for a while.
Speed=d/t
D=102.276371
T=0.0013
Divide by SOL for result in c
MFTL 262.42c
- 1,641
- 1,136
Translation
Raws
I haven't checked the first panel's (where garou is in) raws via dictionary yet, but im currently on the second panel (the one where it supposedly says limitlessly again, with garou not being present in that panel) and.. I find no kanji for Limitless, Infinite, Infinity, forever, etc via japanese dictionary. Idk about the first panel yet even tho i ran machine translation with it but with no dictionary quite exactly. Can you or anybody who knows these dudes, to ask them to provide the specific kanji where they got to the conclusion that the raws meant to say "limitless"?. Cant find any.
- 206
- 71
Saitama and garou's punch destroy a bunch of stars
vsbattles.fandom.com
- 2,509
- 2,112
- 1,716
- 855
You need a calc member to look at it and have them approve it.Saitama and garou's punch destroy a bunch of stars
- 1,641
- 1,136
... Official translations ≠ 100% right in accuracy of translation. Its a case by case anyways.
speaking of official, we have one named "Viz" which had once before completely butchered the JoJo translation. It was complete garbage.
Also nobody said Machine translation > Official translation. but there are cases where machine translations can actually pick up the specific meaning more than official. (One that comes to my mind is JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Part 4, light speed statement) not saying that official is wrong, infact, both can be. But its a case by case kinda.
- 1,641
- 1,136
どこまでもコイツをコピーして打ち克ってやる (Second scan in the imgur raws link)
forever - Jisho.org
jisho.org
limitless - Jisho.org
jisho.org
infinite - Jisho.org
jisho.org
infinity - Jisho.org
jisho.org
infinitely - Jisho.org
jisho.org
The context is in regards to strength, but... I cant find any kanji that supports it being "limitless", at all.
- 25,023
- 27,034
I agree to this
- 25,023
- 27,034
Everyone in this series has questionable morality, except Mumen Rider
Alternatively, maybe this wasn’t an exaggeration and Saitama genuinely has a strained moral compass
- 2,258
- 391
I mean the characters don’t actually create light streams so it’s safe to assume they are afterimages; in which case I think 0.0013 is absolutely fine. Though tbh I don’t see why we can’t scale using the serious punch^2.
- 190
- 108
this can be used for travel speed for saitama
- 11,606
- 10,785
- Thread starter
- #51,113
Calc Stacking. Also a bit half-assed with the pixel scaling.
- 290
- 863
that was highly a mistranslation actually , he was talking about garou going all out not himself
- 4,807
- 1,119
my dreamCan’t wait for Sonic to scale to FF, that’ll be a dream come true, and then Tatsumaki will scale above him.(speed) And the S class will scale to Sonic later on
- 11,606
- 10,785
- Thread starter
- #51,117
Actually, nvm, it isn't calc stacking. I was referring to the 0.0013 seconds, but that was what Garou actually reacted to before. Not something that was calculated..
Uh... I donno if that timeframe can be accepted though, guess I'll wait for someone else to say so.
- 1,716
- 855
Cool, nice to know.
- 190
- 108
Shouldn't use that timeframe isn't a problem, because here Saitama has clearly exceeded Garou's speed
instead I think this is the best result
we made this for saitama's travel speed , this should be good, because we got MFTL+ for saitama and garou's attack + combat speed
- 15,474
- 22,562
Here's what Graywords (the guy who translated chapter 167) had to say. He just reposted this reddit comment of his when it came up in the translation server.
