- 32,359
- 20,298
Season 2 cuts like 30% of shit from the manga and crams stuff together.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Strongest One Punch General Discussion Thread v3
- Thread starter Qawsedf234
- Start date
-
- Tags
- garou genos one-punch man saitama
- Status
- 31,400
- 27,691
I agree. The anime is a terrible adaptation - and the manga is a higher form of canon anyway.
- 2,540
- 1,220
are you guys ******* with me right now? we waited literally like a month for the ******* anime timeframe, and now its finally out and it yielded good results, so now you guys are saying that the anime "rushed the scene" and are saying that the result isnt usable?
than why the **** did we wait this long for the timeframe if we're not allowed to use it?
i bet if the time frame wasnt as quick and yielded worse results, you guys would have been fine with it.
and people ask me why i think vs battles hates OPM. the downplay smfh. what a joke
i ******* knew that you guys wouldnt ever let gouketsu reach tier 6, even though he clearly is.
i dont even know why the **** im on this biased ass site that clearly hates OPM.
than why the **** did we wait this long for the timeframe if we're not allowed to use it?
i bet if the time frame wasnt as quick and yielded worse results, you guys would have been fine with it.
and people ask me why i think vs battles hates OPM. the downplay smfh. what a joke
i ******* knew that you guys wouldnt ever let gouketsu reach tier 6, even though he clearly is.
i dont even know why the **** im on this biased ass site that clearly hates OPM.
- 904
- 24
Why is Saitama only High 6-A, Is not Boros final attack capable of destroy Earth?
- 2,540
- 1,220
what in the ever loving **** does that have to do with how quickly a cloud disperses?Matthew Schroeder said:
and 30% my ass, stop exaggerating. its like 10% at best. probably 5% tbh
so just because season 2 cut some scenes, it means that the speed the cloud dispersed isnt valid? what the **** kinda logic is that lmao
- 31,400
- 27,691
In the manga Boros says he will blow away the Earth's surface, not the entire Earth itself.Final Godzilla E said:
- 904
- 24
So we only accept the Manga?
- 2,540
- 1,220
lmfao because the anime timeframe yielded really high results, all of you are suddenly saying "**** the anime its not a good adaptation" i admit that s2 is a dogshit adaptation, but the hell does that have to do with the validity of the speed of dispersion of a cloud?Damage3245 said:
- 904
- 24
- 904
- 24
To be more specific:
Q: Can Saitama blow up Earth?
A: I guess he can if he wanted to, but I don't think he will do it.
Q: Can Saitama blow up Earth?
A: I guess he can if he wanted to, but I don't think he will do it.
- 4,381
- 1,314
http://prntscr.com/o0n8d9 this quote in particular?Final Godzilla E said:
- 4,381
- 1,314
Tbf Murata should know the upper limits of Saitama's abilities since he knows stuff we don't.
- 904
- 24
Exactly.Tetsucabrah said:
- 4,381
- 1,314
It's true that the adaptation has rushed and cut things out but I don't think that applies here.
They didn't change this part at all.
They didn't change this part at all.
- 2,540
- 1,220
exactly. the shittyness of the adaptation has nothing to do with how fast the cloud disperses and whether or not it's valid lmfao. at this point this is just pure downplay and there's no denying it.Tetsucabrah said:
you guys just cant stand the fact that gouketsu has a 60 gigaton feat
- 11,316
- 13,342
Gouketsu's feat is different in the anime though. His attack didn't move any clouds, it's just a shockwave. Suiryu's feat is the same as the manga, so that timeframe is fine.
But Gouketsu's attack doesn't move the clouds, so I don't think it can be used.
But Gouketsu's attack doesn't move the clouds, so I don't think it can be used.
- 4,381
- 1,314
I guess that is a fair point. I even had to rewind the episode a bit because the shockwave went by so fast.TheRustyOne said:
- 20,541
- 17,454
- Thread starter
- #60
If someone makes a new CRT with the timeframe then and it gets accepted I'll make the CRT. But there should absolutely be no upgrades until that happens.
- 20,541
- 17,454
- Thread starter
- #61
Manga > Webcomic > Anime in terms of canon (on this site). If anime was prime canon then Boros, Garou, and Saitama would all be 5-B since the anime upgraded Boros' CSRC.Final Godzilla E said:
- 904
- 24
Why is Manga more "trustable" than webcomic?
- 4,381
- 1,314
Probably because it can be considered the finished product. ONE added a ton more story and characters into the Garou arc compared to the web comic.Final Godzilla E said:
- 32,359
- 20,298
1. Anime isn't Canon.
2. Gouketsu's feat isn't even properly shown in the anime. Much like Choze's feat prior.
2. Gouketsu's feat isn't even properly shown in the anime. Much like Choze's feat prior.
- 4,381
- 1,314
What was wrong with Choze's feat in the anime? I can actually see what's wrong here, but not there.Matthew Schroeder said:
- 1,673
- 289
The MHS calc is invalid since its attempting to measure movement from a single panel, you cannot tell if the drops where frozen through the duration of their movements.
- 32,359
- 20,298
There is nothing to compare the clouds being parted against to determine their size in Choze's anime feat. Whole in the manga we can see a wide shot of the stadium.
- 1,673
- 289
https://youtu.be/E_JHZXX4I0U?t=55
You can see a brief camera pan towards the sky here if you watch frame by frame, the PoV is from ground level, I don't know if that matters here but it means that the feat in the anime is very close to what's portrayed in the manga since the perspective would be on the same height.
I don't really have anything to say regarding the use of anime timeframes for manga feats, I think they're fine but we're sort of inconsistent on how we apply them, for instance, our Piccolo moonbust doesn't use the anime's timeframe.
You can see a brief camera pan towards the sky here if you watch frame by frame, the PoV is from ground level, I don't know if that matters here but it means that the feat in the anime is very close to what's portrayed in the manga since the perspective would be on the same height.
I don't really have anything to say regarding the use of anime timeframes for manga feats, I think they're fine but we're sort of inconsistent on how we apply them, for instance, our Piccolo moonbust doesn't use the anime's timeframe.
- 2,540
- 1,220
like i ******* said. if the anime is not canon and we can't use the timeframe, why the **** did we wait a month for this damn episode to air?Matthew Schroeder said:
"hey guys we have to wait for the anime episode to air so we know the timeframe"
"ok"
- a month later
wtf
- 10,758
- 6,491
Yeah. The clouds didn't move in the anime aka this wasn't the same feat.
Using the timeframe won't work
Using the timeframe won't work
- 7,936
- 8,868
Tbf the deal was if they adapt the feat well enough to be used as a parameter, the calc would use the timeframe as cano
they ruined the feat by removing the most important part: When Gouketsu actually splits the clouds.They just showed a quick shockwave and didn't actually animate the clouds moving.
I agree with using Choze's timeframe from the anime, mostly because we don't have anywhere else to look for a timeframe except supposition, which will always be too subjective to please everyone.
they ruined the feat by removing the most important part: When Gouketsu actually splits the clouds.They just showed a quick shockwave and didn't actually animate the clouds moving.
I agree with using Choze's timeframe from the anime, mostly because we don't have anywhere else to look for a timeframe except supposition, which will always be too subjective to please everyone.
- 4,381
- 1,314
So who's making the CRT?
- 20,541
- 17,454
- Thread starter
- #76
I will right now if
- Someone has made a new blog about the Goketsu feat
- We've just decided to ditch the anime in this case and stick with 7-A
- 10,758
- 6,491
Sticking with 7-A would be better imo.
- 4,381
- 1,314
What's wrong with using the low end on the old blog?
- 20,541
- 17,454
- Thread starter
- #80
If two mods are against using the anime timeframe I guess there's not much I can do besides tally a vote. Andy and Matt are against using the anime timeframe and I'm for it. So comment on if the calc should be usable or not. That or ask the calc members who commented on the original calc to comment here.
Against using the timeframe: Andytrenom, Matthew Schroeder
For it or for the 6-C end: Qawsedf234
Against using the timeframe: Andytrenom, Matthew Schroeder
For it or for the 6-C end: Qawsedf234
- Status
