- 15,411
- 15,766
You’re correct, we don’t. We especially shouldn’t do it for Tatsumaki since she gets her scaling from a character that doesn’t exist in the webcomic.We don’t do webcomic vs manga scaling anymore, correct?
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
You’re correct, we don’t. We especially shouldn’t do it for Tatsumaki since she gets her scaling from a character that doesn’t exist in the webcomic.We don’t do webcomic vs manga scaling anymore, correct?
No pretty sure that the quotes from the webcomic are almost identical to the quotes from the mangaWell, if you compare webcomic vs webcomic, Saitama was just as bored in his fight against Boros and never says anything of note about him either.
Uhhhhh?https://vsbattles.fandom.com/wiki/GarouYou’re correct, we don’t. We especially shouldn’t do it for Tatsumaki since she gets her scaling from a character that doesn’t exist in the webcomic.
In all cases you can see that the city is large and in the sweep I used, you can measure the area affected by the calculation, so there is nothing defective in that.On the size of the city...
this page is unquantifiable and shows the edge of the city. this page is a lot better but it also shows the edge of the city with the cloud of smoke stopping after a while. this page is completely unquantifiable other than the city being larger than the ship. this shows the city is huge but there's no real parameter to get a size from it. Finally this is unquantifiable because it's not clear how far the destruction stretched, and if the roads were built around the rubble of the city or on top.
Even assuming that all of the roads in the last scan = the original city it's going to end up tiny because you can easily measure the size of a road going by how many cars can fit in it.
the scan you used the one with saitama on the building does show the edge.In all cases you can see that the city is large and in the sweep I used, you can measure the area affected by the calculation, so there is nothing defective in that.
At this point this is closer to spatial hax than it is to TK like Trafalagar Law's roomregardiing Tatsumaki, “her telekensis doesn’t bat an eye at the weight and speed of the objects she lifts, making her practically invincible“— so, Tatsumaki scales above everyone besides Saitama in speed and strength. Sarcasm, of course.
We discussed this pretty extensively last CRT and decided that Tatsumaki should be High 6-A overall, since she's not changing forms or anything, she's just flexing all her might. Making this change would require creating numerous keys for characters like Saitama and Goku all across the wiki, because they often hold themselves back. You'd get like 10 keys for Saitama, one for Snek, one for Rover, one for the ninja brothers, everytime he held back his power to a certain degree.Someone should pull up the webcomic boros fight. Also I think tornado should br at least high 6-C normally and High 6-A at full power
What does Garou have to do with anything I said? Tatsumaki gets her High 6-A scaling from Psykorochi. Orochi does not exist in the webcomic.
You are avoiding the point. You quoted this postWhat does Garou have to do with anything I said? Tatsumaki gets her High 6-A scaling from Psykorochi. Orochi does not exist in the webcomic
With thisWe don’t do webcomic vs manga scaling anymore, correct?
Webcomic Garou is High 6-A because of scaling him to manga boros. So you are clearing wrong.You’re correct, we don’t.
You do realize that Webcomic Boros is also High 6-A, right...? And we have discussed removing the Awakened Garou key in this thread.Webcomic Garou is High 6-A because of scaling him to manga boros. So you are clearing wrong.
A. AgreeYou're right Epiccheev. We're 450 comments in and discussion is diverging into topics that were never mentioned in the original CRT post. We still have plenty to discuss that is on-topic so we should make a list elsewhere and note any other potential changes. Please try to limit discussion to these topics and suggest other changes in the OPM general discussion thread here: https://vsbattles.com/threads/strongest-one-punch-man-discussion-thread.107591/page-18#post-3494506.
We will include it in the next CRT.
REMAINING CRT ITEMS IN ORDER:
A.) Fubuki vs DO-S scaling,
B.) A-class hero downgrades,
C.) Geryuganshoop speed upgrade,
D.) Boros AP ship upgrade,
E.) Boros key changes.
Got feats?One second- I want to ask Matthew why he opposes 8-A Monster Raid Fubuki and DO-S. The logic is that they should be comparable to the Disciples and Power Suits.
One second- I want to ask Matthew why he opposes 8-A Monster Raid Fubuki and DO-S. The logic is that they should be comparable to the Disciples and Power Suits.
DO-S restrained Royal Ripper's blade (Royal Ripper respected her and G-5 enough to stop) and DO-S also pierced Amai Mask's 'face' while temporarily restraining him. These aren't concrete, but they demonstrate DO-S is above baseline Demon, no low demon could do what she did to Amai Mask and Royal Ripper wouldn't respected her as much if she were such a weak demon (weaker than the disciples and the squad, basically). It also makes sense to me that Monster Raid Fubuki should scale higher because she's low 7-B by the time the MA arc rolls around and its only been a few days.Got feats?
I don't think piercing Amai Mask via his eye is grounds to scale.DO-S restrained Royal Ripper's blade (Royal Ripper respected her and G-5 enough to stop) and DO-S also pierced Amai Mask's 'face
Garou’s profile is still cross referencing and you still keep evading.You do realize that Webcomic Boros is also High 6-A, right...? And we have discussed removing the Awakened Garou key in this thread.
It’s literally scaling him to Webcomic Boros, and we have literally discussed removing that Garou key and making webcomic profiles, but sure, keep thinking that we can cross-scale the manga and the webcomic.Garou’s profile is still cross referencing and you still keep evading.
This has been discussed as well. Webcomic keys will be made for the next CRT. If we scrap scaling to webcomic Garou (which we should if we are updating things), we must turn to manga-exclusive feats.Honestly just make a webcomic key for those characters