- 4,381
- 1,314
Agree with Boros getting his own CRT. That can also deal with webcomic profiles too since it's related.
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Some updates on One Punch-Man
- Thread starter USklaverei
- Start date
-
- Tags
- one-punch man
- Status
- 2,926
- 1,399
- Thread starter
- #482
The Geryunganshoop thing too
- 4,381
- 1,314
Do-S needs to cause pain to her victims for her mind control to work. She could hurt the mercenaries through their suits and destroyed the outer parts of them.
Also her attack would've harmed Bushidrill if Amai didn't step in.
- 25,023
- 27,035
I'm pretty sure it was referring to boros in general, if they wanted to be specific, they would have specified which form
- 15,450
- 15,866
That would just leave Fubuki/Do-S and the A-Class heroes for this CRT, right? Unless removing AG and GS’ keys are agreed upon enough to do now.
- 4,004
- 2,798
@Matthew_Schroeder Would this logic + DO-S's interactions with Amai Mask (restraining him, damaging his face) affect your stance on Monster Raid Fubuki and DO-S being upgraded to the same level as the Disciples and the power suits?
- 25,023
- 27,035
Also it was earlier stated that the near light speed boros thing was coming from and officiall guidebook one and murata made, why is it getting rejected now?
And boros should scale to Garou in the manga when Garou appears, because murata stated that one told him that boros and Garou should be comparable
And boros should scale to Garou in the manga when Garou appears, because murata stated that one told him that boros and Garou should be comparable
- 4,004
- 2,798
If we're moving the Boros and Geryuganshoop to another CRT we just have:
1.) Upgrading Fubuki and DO-S to 8-A,
* We are waiting to hear all Matthew has to say.
2.) Downgrading A-class heroes (and most people who scale to Kombu Infinity) to "at least 9-A, likely 8-C". Certain characters like Zombieman/Death Gatling/Stinger who should be capable of dispatching a tiger level threat as powerful as Kombu should stay where they are.* If we all agree the above description is good, this change can easily be applied.
3.) Upgrading Boros's ship Ap to Low 6-B.
*This is a simple change. All we have to do is decide if Usklaverei's calc is valid.
- 20,549
- 17,464
If your question is asking if the Murata statement is valid, then by his own admission it would be no. Murata clarified that what he said about Gery was his thoughts on the matter and does not reflect ONE's world view, so it's not valid. He also outright stated what he says on stream isn't canon unless confirmed by ONE, then directly mentioned that the viewers should go to a completely canonical source in the Hero's Guidebook or ONE for questions.
Normally I wouldn't really care about using his quotes, since we use stuff like writer or director WoG for the MCU despite them not having total oversight over the project. But when Murata himself says he isn't a valid source we're running into a wall here.
The Boros thing is different from the Gery things in that one is an officially published behind the scenes thing while the other is a solo stream statement
- 4,004
- 2,798
Did you see my earlier mention where I wrote down all the agreed-upon changes? We can start implementing them, pending Antvasima's approval.
- 20,549
- 17,464
Besides the Gery speed and Do-S stuff everything can likely be applied.
- 25,023
- 27,035
Also scaling boros to orochi is also a no?
- 4,004
- 2,798
Firstly, all Boros changes are going to be postponed to the next CRT. This thread is becoming massive and difficult to navigate. We will conclude discussion on the points I've mentioned above and deal with the rest later.
Secondly, via Saitama's punches, no. Via the "dragon or above' statement, yes, but we need to determine which form is dragon or above. Meteoric Burst assuredly, Released is a debate that needs to happen elsewhere.
- 4,004
- 2,798
These changes can be implemented. I myself will start with Genos's profile.
- 25,023
- 27,035
- 25,023
- 27,035
At this point, we might as well wait for AG to come out, then we figure out boros
- 2,926
- 1,399
- Thread starter
- #497
I've already done everything about weight lifting, as the WC thing was not done, Orochi didn't climb to the G-Class, but I feel that he should since he physically must be stronger than Metal and Bang
- 25,023
- 27,035
Also I'll just put this here again. Would it be possible to get a calc out of geryuganshoop's attacks without the sub-light statement?
- 2,926
- 1,399
- Thread starter
- #499
nope
- 25,023
- 27,035
So when we making the boros and geryu CRT? Since everything else here is supposedly done
- 32,359
- 20,298
Yeah I think Geryu and Boros are controversial enough to have their own threads.
- 25,023
- 27,035
Should we combine those into one thread? As geryu's speed will affect boros and orochi and likely those who scale above the latter
- 4,004
- 2,798
Yes, they would be one thread. Said thread should also look over various Boros-relevant calcs, like the High 6-B meteor calc, the low 6-B ship bombardment, the adjusted CSRC and Moon Jump results.
- 25,023
- 27,035
How's the CSRC thing going?
- 4,004
- 2,798
Therefir would like me to recalc it as fragmentation of the earth's crust, which gives a result of 17 petatons. I don't think fragmentation makes sense though, since Boros doesn't destroy things that way. Or if he does, it would be unique to CSRC and different from any destruction we've seen from Boros so far.
Plus, it begs the question... if Boros is going to fragment the oceanic crust, what is going to happen to the ocean? It's obviously not going to disappear, and you need about 700 petatons of energy to vaporize the ocean, so how can the 17 petaton figure hold up? That kind of energy is not going to boil away the oceans. Neither will the generic explosion calc... the energy just isn't enough to shave the earth if you need to vaporize the oceans. Until he can provide some alternate answer to the ocean problem, 1.5 exatons of melting seems to be a good lowball.
- 226
- 64
It should definitely be melting since Meteoric Burst melts with every attack. It would be weird if CSRC was the only exception.
- 25,023
- 27,035
Wait, why fragmentation? When has Boros' attacks ever done that
- 12,304
- 11,259
Yeah, it should still be melting.
- 4,004
- 2,798
@USklaverei
Could you change the suggested A-class heroes downgrade from "8-C" to "at least 9-A, 8-C"? If we do so, that can be approved, as our staff members here have approved this rating. If you are okay with that, here is how I would change every High 8-C hero's tiering:
As stated, A-class level individuals who could reasonably defeat Kombu infinity may remain at "high 8-C". Stinger (one-shot numerous tiger level, wolf level sea folk), Great Philosopher (stronger than Stinger), Death Gatling (devastated tree line against Garou, did superficial damage to HEO), Heavy Tank Fundoshi (near S-class level according to Sitch) and Magic Trick Man (near S-class level) have all demonstrated that they are what is unofficially referred to as "high-tiger, above tiger". These should remain at High 8-C. They also happen to be some of the mostly highly ranked A-class heroes, which may be an indication of their superior strength.
Spring Mustachio should be "8-C, High 8-C with Tomboy", as he was able to defend against Kombu Infinity for an extended period of time and actually pierced Kombu Infinity's hair with Tomboy. Snakebite Snek should be 8-C, as he scales above Dave through his performance in the tournament. Lightning Max should also be 8-C, because he "hit with more oomph" than Snek according to Suiryu.
Every other A-class hero should be "At least 9-A (able to defeat Tiger level threats consistently), likely 8-C (should be as strong as Snek, who is superior to Dave)".
The following heroes should be downgraded to that "at least 9-A, likely 8-C" tier as they do not scale to the aforementioned heroes. If there are an alterations or objections, please let me know: Lightning Genji (can't be much stronger than Electric Catfish Man + Maiko Plasma), Golden Ball (Had nothing to offer against Kombu Infinity), Narcisstoic, Shadow Ring, Feather, One-Shotter and Chain N' Toad.
These B-class heroes should also downscale "at least 9-A, likely 8-C": Captain Mizuki and Needlestar.
Child Emperor's Physicals should downscale to this tier I think. He's likely low A-class level when we consider his brain development with the Okame mask. I would like to hear thoughts on this.
Zombieman's physicals should also downscale to this. I haven't seen him do any high-tiger, above tiger feats without his weapons and tiger level monsters seem to be able to significantly harm him.
How does that sound?
Could you change the suggested A-class heroes downgrade from "8-C" to "at least 9-A, 8-C"? If we do so, that can be approved, as our staff members here have approved this rating. If you are okay with that, here is how I would change every High 8-C hero's tiering:
As stated, A-class level individuals who could reasonably defeat Kombu infinity may remain at "high 8-C". Stinger (one-shot numerous tiger level, wolf level sea folk), Great Philosopher (stronger than Stinger), Death Gatling (devastated tree line against Garou, did superficial damage to HEO), Heavy Tank Fundoshi (near S-class level according to Sitch) and Magic Trick Man (near S-class level) have all demonstrated that they are what is unofficially referred to as "high-tiger, above tiger". These should remain at High 8-C. They also happen to be some of the mostly highly ranked A-class heroes, which may be an indication of their superior strength.
Spring Mustachio should be "8-C, High 8-C with Tomboy", as he was able to defend against Kombu Infinity for an extended period of time and actually pierced Kombu Infinity's hair with Tomboy. Snakebite Snek should be 8-C, as he scales above Dave through his performance in the tournament. Lightning Max should also be 8-C, because he "hit with more oomph" than Snek according to Suiryu.
Every other A-class hero should be "At least 9-A (able to defeat Tiger level threats consistently), likely 8-C (should be as strong as Snek, who is superior to Dave)".
The following heroes should be downgraded to that "at least 9-A, likely 8-C" tier as they do not scale to the aforementioned heroes. If there are an alterations or objections, please let me know: Lightning Genji (can't be much stronger than Electric Catfish Man + Maiko Plasma), Golden Ball (Had nothing to offer against Kombu Infinity), Narcisstoic, Shadow Ring, Feather, One-Shotter and Chain N' Toad.
These B-class heroes should also downscale "at least 9-A, likely 8-C": Captain Mizuki and Needlestar.
Child Emperor's Physicals should downscale to this tier I think. He's likely low A-class level when we consider his brain development with the Okame mask. I would like to hear thoughts on this.
Zombieman's physicals should also downscale to this. I haven't seen him do any high-tiger, above tiger feats without his weapons and tiger level monsters seem to be able to significantly harm him.
How does that sound?
Last edited:
- 12,304
- 11,259
I think it makes sense, personally.
- 25,023
- 27,035
Everything seems fine
- 2,926
- 1,399
- Thread starter
- #512
Call members, if accepted only apply
- 4,004
- 2,798
Are you saying we should call everyone else back in here? I do not know if I can do that, but I will ask everyone on the OPM main thread to give their opinions on my suggested downgrades.
Anyone else who is watching this, please let me know what you think of the suggested downgrades. If you have any alterations, I would also like to hear them.
Anyone else who is watching this, please let me know what you think of the suggested downgrades. If you have any alterations, I would also like to hear them.
- 25,023
- 27,035
This, fubuki and Do-S AP revision. In another thread, we'll discuss boros' ap, geryu's speed and Boros' ship's AP and dura. As well some stuff about orochi
- 4,381
- 1,314
Get Matt back on to see if he agrees with my reasonings for the Do-S/Fubuki things.
- 4,004
- 2,798
Okay.
Matthew, Tetsucabrah and I would like to know if our added reasoning for the DO-S Fubuki scaling changes your position on their suggested upgrade.
Further reasoning here:
Plus, DO-S restrained an Amai Mask who was about to butcher the mercenaries and damaged him. Also, she was going to attack Bushidrill and her whip drew his attention and a concerned look. If he were that much stronger than her, I don't think he would have reacted in the same way and I don't think DO-S would have been able to crack the mercenary armor. We never saw the impact of the attack because it was interrupted but Amai Mask and Bushidrill treated it like a potential threat.
- 15,450
- 15,866
While I agree with the Do-S/Fubuki upgrade, using Amai Mask as part of the justification doesn’t make much sense to me. He’s a 7-B, restraining and damaging him would be way more than an 8-A feat.
- 25,023
- 27,035
Almost sounds like a bit of an outlier tbh
Ped2018
He/Him- 5,058
- 6,127
Well, i kinda don't agree with Kombus' """feat""" anyway, but it looks good
- Status
