Should We Make Profiles For The Divine Comedy?

[Antvasima]

Wouldn't it be easier to just have the God profile just have one key since the Divine Comedy uses the Trinity doctrine, where the three are the same-substance of a God-Head entity? Splitting them into three, while correct doctrine wise, seems weird profile wise since like, they'd all have the same abilities.

@Ultima_Reality

 

[MonkeyOfLife]

Ant, the issue I take with this stance it that disregards how we already risk such controversy with the fact we index many profiles of God specifically on this wiki as he appears across a pleothra of fictional works.

Dante's Divine Comedy is not exceptional in this at all. Dante just took a lot of inspiration from the god of the bible when creating this story, and that's okay. It isn't a problem at all.

How does this even justify it? We already have risky profiles so it's ok to make risker profiles... Like what?

The specific sandbox being a near replica of that from the Bible doesn't matter what fictional work it is from, as the "fictional work" has taken from the Religious texts

I just see it as trying to make a loophole to get the God from the Bible into the wiki which is very disrespectful in my view

 

[Gasper]

It's not the "inspired work of fiction" that they'll get offended about is what I'm talking about

Yes, you're talking about theology, I get it.
Divine Comedy is heavily inspired by platonic forms which don't apply to the Bible at all.

 

[Gasper]

How does this even justify it? We already have risky profiles so it's ok to make risker profiles... Like what?

The specific sandbox being a near replica of that from the Bible doesn't matter what fictional work it is from, as the "fictional work" has taken from the Religious texts

I just see it as trying to make a loophole to get the God from the Bible into the wiki which is very disrespectful in my view

It looks like you're keep ignoring what I'm saying for some reason.

Nowhere in the Bible is there 10 heavens, nine circles of hell, platonic forms, vergin Mary isn't divine in the bible either while she is in the poem.
I can go on and on.

Another question, are you personally offended by including the poem?

 

[Planck69]

I don't mind us making the profiles. It's ultimately a very faithful fantasy adaptation, not that categorically different from most other God expies we have on the site. I'll leave the details (assuming this is agreed with) to Ultima and the others.