- 6,879
- 1,320
I'll wait on Ant's assessment too
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
He pretty much has numerous equivalents to Einstein’s theory of relativity in different fields of magic/science except if humanity had been working under the understanding that the theory of relativity could in no way be accurate for centuriesNot enough for Extraordinary Genius IMO. As the profile says, Genius seems fine.
That is correct, yes.Not enough for Extraordinary Genius IMO. As the profile says, Genius seems fine.
Agreed.This is not Gifted at all. Above Average seems more appropriate here.Gifted (Is far above regular undead in intelligence, Has lived countless lifetimes, even if most of that was spent asleep beneath the Desert Temple. Has knowledge about the prophecy that crowned Archie as the Arch-Illager.)
"Unknown. Gifted in combat." perhaps?Gifted.High (Akali is a highly proficient assassin, having been trained to kill since the moment she was able to walk. Having been personally trained to use shurikens by [[Kennen]], personally trained in the ninja arts, stealth, and subterfuge by Shen, as well as developing her own fighting style of emphasizing speed and agility over strength and becoming a master of the kama and kunai. Her skill is so great that she succeeded her mother as the Fist of Shadow when she was only a teenager, and despite not possessing any innate supernatural abilities like Shen and Kennen she was considered just as deadly as them.)
"At least Average." is probably fine.Average or Above Average at best.Gifted (Experienced police officer and martial artist)
Yes, I was thinking about it since there was no clear intelligence feat, but more of a combat feat. Well, I will apply the changes according to what was previously said."Unknown. Gifted in combat." perhaps?
Apart from that the profile rating is accurate and does not need to be changed.Like Bart, Homer is a polyglot, someone with the ability to pick up languages fairly quickly, perhaps even a hyper polyglot (a polyglot fluent in more than six languages). He has been shown to speak Spanish, Chinese, Penguin and Drunk and when he and Bart were imprisoned in Japan for a seemingly short amount of time due to unknowingly assaulting Emperor Akihito, he was able to speak the language fluently by the time he left. He was also able to pick up a few Indian words by watching Apu and Manjula argue. He was also shown to mimic people's voices especially well. This was evidenced in a flashback in Grampa vs. Sexual Inadequacy, where Homer, after watching a televised speech made by then-President John F. Kennedy, proceeded to flawlessly mimic Kennedy's speech pattern and mannerisms.
So, everything would just give him a stronger Gifted rating?Let's see, first of all, solving a rubix's cube is not a feat of intelligence as such, since it is not necessary to be so smart, it is more the practice behind it (How long has he been practicing, things like that), I can't give a clear feat to that without knowing a context, but I could assume that he is gifted (Because he had not even looked at the cube and it practically took him 2 moves to solve it) and it would practically not change his current rating.
There is no such thing as a stronger "Gifted" rating, his rating itself will not change, the only thing is that now there are 2 more feats that could be said to equate him "sometimes" to a "Gifted", but his rating remains the same. but I would reword it to something like:So, everything would just give him a stronger Gifted rating?
"At least Above Average, likely Gifted." seems more warranted based on the above description.Self-Explanatory, not genius at all. At least Average seems more appropiate.Genius, he is an extremely cunning leader and manipulator
It seems more like "Extraordinary Genius" or "At least Genius, likely Extraordinary Genius" level, but it depends on how advanced the technology he developed over 800 years ago was.Genius should work or if you think a flat Genius is not enough, then At least Gifted, likely Genius may work too. He has many more intelligence feats in the manhwa but they don't seem to be integrated into the profile yet.Immense, he is one of the most intelligent people, if not the most intelligent, of the Noblesse verse. Over 820 years prior to the start of the story (Story begins in the year 2011) he had already developed extremely advanced modification technology, and his research is the source of all the inventions by the Union, an organization that specializes in modification and technology and advanced weaponry. In addition to his incredible academic prowess, Frankenstein is also a brilliant tactician and a highly skilled combatant who has had centuries of combat experience against a variety of foes; he has defeated many enemies that outclassed him in terms of raw power for this reason.
Right, I don't know why I suggested Average since Above average is more accurate. I don't agree with likely Gifted but it doesn't matter."At least Above Average, likely Gifted." seems more warranted based on the above description.
I only watched the anime when it was released a few years ago, the technological advancement was certainly noticeable, but nothing so extremely extraodinary, but yes, I'll be fine with "At least Genius, likely Extraordinary Genius". That said. I'll apply the changesIt seems more like "Extraordinary Genius" or "At least Genius, likely Extraordinary Genius" level, but it depends on how advanced the technology he developed over 800 years ago was.
"Usually Below Average. Sometimes Above Average to Gifted in specific areas.", with the most important examples listed in conjunction, seems fine to me.There is no such thing as a stronger "Gifted" rating, his rating itself will not change, the only thing is that now there are 2 more feats that could be said to equate him "sometimes" to a "Gifted", but his rating remains the same. but I would reword it to something like:
Usually "Below Average", rarely "Above Average, likely Gifted".
Well, we can use "At least Above Average, possibly Gifted" if you consider it uncertain.Right, I don't know why I suggested Average since Above average is more accurate. I don't agree with likely Gifted but it doesn't matter.
Okay. Thank you for helping out.I only watched the anime when it was released a few years ago, the technological advancement was certainly noticeable, but nothing so extremely extraodinary, but yes, I'll be fine with "At least Genius, likely Extraordinary Genius". That said. I'll apply the changes
Average in general. Gifted in combat.While academically average, Shirou is skilled in combat, and is trained in combat by Saber in all three routes, mostly defensively, as attempting to teach him to fight on even grounds with a Servant is a lost cause. He has an undeveloped Eye of the Mind. He can calmly analyze any situation, no matter how dire, considering multiple options and making intelligent decisions. He is incredibly stubborn, putting his all into everything he faces. In Unlimited Blade Works, his exposure to Archer causes his combat skills to develop much faster, and in Heaven's Feel, he can call on Archer's knowledge directly. However, Shirou's self-destructive thought processes tend to hold him back and put him in dangerous situations.
This version is practically the same as the previous one but more knowledgeable about magic in general, I would certainly give it the same rating as the one above, but I don't know if an "Average in general. Possibly Genius in combat". would be fine? Tho i'm not sureThis version of Shirou is much more knowledgeable in the use of magecraft than what his mainstream counterpart was able to learn due to his father putting in more effort to teach him all that he knows, showing his effectiveness in it as he can instantly reinforce mundane objects like a ruler or umbrella for offensive and defensive uses at a much faster rate. However, this efficiency increases even more after Installing Archer's Class Card, essentially inheriting his future self's knowledge and allowing him to project numerous Noble Phantasms and other weapons in his hand instantly along with gaining the latter's dual-wielding style that enables him to fight and keep up with more stronger and faster foes.
"Unknown in general. Genius in combat" seems fine.Archer can develop complicated plans and switch between them on the fly. Able to quickly determine the opponent’s strengths and weaknesses to shift his tactics accordingly. Technically, suppose there’s even a 1% chance of victory. In that case, he can still win due to his Eye of the Mind (True) skill, allowing him to defend himself in his second encounter with Lancer despite the latter's blatantly superior stats due to having fought him before and by deliberately leaving gaps in his attacks. Hence, he knew where Lancer would attack and react accordingly during the Unlimited Blade Works route. He is even skilled enough to take six of Berserker's lives off before dying despite having a broken arm and without ever using Unlimited Blade Works due to being deprived of sufficient mana to use it in the Fate route. Archer is proficient in both melee and ranged combat due to his unique fighting style, being praised by Berserker for his swordsmanship and sniping other Servants from several kilometers away without issue. Also, he orchestrated the events of the Unlimited Blade Works route, successfully breaking his contract with Rin, eliminating Caster, and nearly killing Shirou, only failing due to Saber's intervention after the latter made a contract with Rin.
It is practically unchanged from the one above. Practically the same rating.While a different entity compared to EMIYA, No Name is nonetheless extremely capable in combat. He is capable of battling the likes of Gawain, one of the greatest Knights of the Round Table who was the equal of Lancelot, Cú Chulainn, a great hero of Ireland who slew five thousand soldiers every day, and Li Shuwen, a legendary martial artist who could outmaneuver and outskill Beowulf. Additionally, through the use of his Eye of the Mind (False) skill, he is capable of effectively analyzing any battle and act accordingly to survive and win the fight and can track his targets from four kilometers away with the use of his Clairvoyance.
"Unknown in general. Likely Gifted in combat" Clearly inferior in combat skills to the 2 above.EMIYA Alter is a cold-hearted machine who thinks only of preserving the Human Order. Because of this, he pragmatically kills his foes through any means necessary, most frequently by putting a bullet between their eyes rather than facing his foes in honorable combat. His methods allowed him to outmatch the likes of Jeanne Alter. He frequently taunts his opponents in battle to agitate them and create openings and has no qualms with retreating from a poor situation. He'll also work with his enemies if it will help him achieve his ends, but will betray them just as quickly.
What do you mean?Well, for Earth Emiya, he does make for a good house servant
That seems fine to me. Feel free to add yourself to the listed members there.Btw Ant. Do you think it would be okay to list me as a knowledgeable member in intelligence? I have another strong point as well which is Nonexistent Physiology. I can easily help in these terminologies if called upon.
That seems fine to me.Average in general. Gifted in combat.
Maybe "At least Above Average in general. At least Gifted, possibly Genius in combat."?This version is practically the same as the previous one but more knowledgeable about magic in general, I would certainly give it the same rating as the one above, but I don't know if an "Average in general. Possibly Genius in combat". would be fine? Tho i'm not sure
Maybe "Gifted in general. Genius in combat."?"Unknown in general. Genius in combat" seems fine.
"Unknown in general. Genius in combat." seems fine here, yes.It is practically unchanged from the one above. Practically the same rating.
That seems like an appropriate rating to me as well, yes."Unknown in general. Likely Gifted in combat" Clearly inferior in combat skills to the 2 above.
If you update his intelligence justifications to turn much more accurate, and give him an "At least Genius" rating in conjunction, that is probably fine.I found a good one
Practically the explanation of the feat is not according to what the scan says. It is never said in the scan that he "Near-effortlessly mastered countless fields of scientific study" only that "His preferred fields of research were diverse" and there are at most 10 scientific fields and not countless as the wording of the scan says. Besides, what the scan itself states does not even meet the minimum requirements of Supergenius. I would clearly give him a feat of Genius. IMO the only thing that could qualify him as Extraordinary Genius would be that he is knowledgeable in many fields of science apart from that, he does not meet the requirements for Extraordinary Genius. And I believe that a Genius could achieve that.
I've already added myself, i'll do the rest later, i'm in the college rn.That seems fine to me. Feel free to add yourself to the listed members there.