Zencha9
They/Them- 4,234
- 1,731
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Pokemon God Revision- Yes its Arceus (And minor stuff for Unown)
- Status
Zencha9
They/Them- 4,234
- 1,731
i handled it
- 167,684
- 76,264
You can't just leave a prominent page like that of Arceus in a messy state if that is the case.
Is somebody else here willing to properly clean it up, and apply Executor's conclusions, please?
Is somebody else here willing to properly clean it up, and apply Executor's conclusions, please?
- 167,684
- 76,264
Zencha9
They/Them- 4,234
- 1,731
done removed the <div> since there's no walls of hax to keep it consistent with the rest of the tabs
- 8,904
- 3,457
Yeah, no. I have no tolerance for people retrying threads until they get the result they want.
I would like one good reason to not close this thread, given you literally just admitted that it is an exact repeat of the previous one.
I would like one good reason to not close this thread, given you literally just admitted that it is an exact repeat of the previous one.
Sniper670
He/Him- 6,409
- 1,365
- Thread starter
- #302
I visited several Japanese websites to get the actual context/semantics/nuances behind a statement that was left vague in the English version. This one: “The power of plates is shared amongst Pokemon”. Here is the actual context from Native Japanese Speakers using the Japanese version of that statement. I'm using Deepl, since it’s the accepted translator app on the wiki:
a. みどりのプレート
「うまれてくる ポケモン プレートの ちから わけあたえられる」
⇒アルセウスが他のポケモン達にタイプを与えている描写だと思われます。
Green Plate
"Pokémon that are born can be assigned to any type of Pokémon plate."
⇒This is supposed to be a depiction of Arceus giving types to other Pokémon. (https://3secondsgameover.com/e/pokekousatsu05)
b. その次の生まれてくるポケモンのくだりで分け与えられた力は、ポケモンのタイプであると考えられる
The power shared by the Pokémon born after that is considered to be the Pokémon's type. (https://deoxi.at.webry.info/200705/article_11.html)
c. プレートの力(=タイプ)はすべてアルセウスからの授け物と記した神話の内容。真実は定かではない。
The myth states that all the power (=type) of the plate is a gift from Arceus. The truth is not certain. https://monsterya.com/archives/2022_02_07_28611264/.html8)
d. 昔の人々は、ポケモンが持つタイプの起源がプレートにあると考えたのだろう。
People in the past would have thought that the types that Pokémon have originated in the plate. (https://shirotama.xyz/rfm/pokemon12.html)
e. アルセウスは宇宙そのものを作り出した神（ポケモンや人間よりも高次の存在）であり、ミュウがポケモン世界の舞台となる惑星に最初に産まれた始祖のポケモンという解釈が可能となっている。
ポケモンの力=タイプは、アルセウスが宇宙を生み出した際に結晶化したプレートから分け与えられたものとされている点も、この解釈を肯定している。
It is possible to interpret Arceus as the god who created the universe itself (a higher being than Pokémon and humans) and Mew as the first Pokémon born on the planet where the Pokémon world is set. This interpretation is also supported by the fact that Pokémon's power = type is said to be shared from the plate that crystallized when Arceus created the universe. (https://dic.pixiv.net/a/アルセウス)
f. 続く文章はアルセウスの特性「マルチタイプ」と、ポケモンのタイプについての言及になる。全てのポケモンは、必ずタイプを持っている。ポケモン達の火や水を使う力はプレートが与えたもの……アルセウスの特性を通じて、人はポケモンのタイプの起源がプレートにあると考えるようになったのだろう。
The following sentence will be a reference to Arceus' characteristic "multi-type" and the Pokémon's type. All Pokémon always have a type. The Pokémon's power to use fire and water was given to them by the plate. ...... Through Arceus' characteristic, people may have come to believe that the origin of Pokémon types is in the plate.
And so with that we can understand what the English version is trying to say, which is more explicit;
"The powers of Plates are shared among Pokémon."
NB: Under the power bestowal page, bestowing powers to other doesn't mean you can grant it to yourself, but here, the plates already possess all said powers, it is rather simply sharing it's own powers.
- 8,904
- 3,457
And how is this different from what you have already proposed? Translated text walls aren’t new, and it being 2 AM for me doesn’t make it easy for me to tell one translation wall from another (that I read and disagreed with months ago, and would rather not revisit if I didn’t have to).
- 8,675
- 5,560
Are any of these even primary sources? It looks like a bunch of quotes from just, fansites, and we can't base something off of secondhand information or the interpretations of fans, otherwise this would've already gone through.
- 8,675
- 5,560
It doesn't matter who translated them if they're just quotes from fansites
- 8,675
- 5,560
Sure, but any interpretations a Japanese fan makes is still an interpretation and not to be accepted or used as evidence in itself. They are not automatically more correct, and their words should not be a primary source of information.
- 8,904
- 3,457
So you are saying that these are new (fansite-translated) quotes that back up your claim as to how Plates grant power to Pokemon? And again, please, watch your attitude.
- 8,675
- 5,560
If the native Japanese says that, just share the native Japanese, not people talking about it and drawing whatever conclusions.
She's telling you to watch your attitude for a reason.
She's telling you to watch your attitude for a reason.
- Status
Similar threads
