- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #601
The calculation must not only be approved by mathematics, but justified and accepted by users. I personally do not see any problems with my interpretation, but let's wait for the opinion of others
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
Mob Psycho 100 upgrade
- Thread starter NikHelton
- Start date
- Status
- 17,231
- 26,961
Just wanted to comment on this bit, I find it very weird as an argument.
Where in Mob Psycho have we literally ever seen this be a concern or brought up like ever that any of the stronger characters fear moving people at high speeds would pose immediate danger to their lives or even then they'd have trouble flying like 10-20 people at most away from somewhere safely at high speeds.
Frankly this, in my honest opinion seems like a stretch and in some way your own headcanon for whatever reason as its not really based concretely in anything in the series, again in a series where average humans have been shown to be able to survive cratering walls or being forcefully thrown dozens of feet unscathed or with like a few scrapes. Like being real could you send any scan of someone of adequate skill and power in mob psycho being afraid of moving someone at high speeds not as an attack or anything but literally just moving them so your argument can have at least a scan or some precedent to stand on within this series specifically
Flying people away from blast zones are such a common thing in fiction so I'd like to where Mob Psycho makes the distinction that doing so would like result in people like being killed or falling out hitting obstacles or whatever
- 1,271
- 445
I agree
- 17,231
- 26,961
Both are fine with being used and we're discussing Serizawa's 6-A feat and eventually need to tackle mogami's world
- 1,271
- 445
It's understandable.
It was decided that feats from the anime are allowed, partly because of ONE's artistic limitations and that he was involved in the development of the anime.
Currently, I think, the new Keys and changes are being decided, together with a previous calculation.
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #607
In the anime, the car went into the horizon in a couple of seconds, turning into a shining star.
Using math we got hypersonic speed
But we have also given a number of examples and translations that specifically refer to escaping from an explosion, and not literally running.
By the way, even if ordinary people moved a distance, starting from normal speed, the base 6-C Mob barrier would save them from the explosion. This is not a complete argument, but an interesting idea.
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #608
Mogami's exploits were accepted but used as "possibly".
However, if we use Toichiro's High 6-A burst, then I think the feat in the Mogami World will be accepted directly. In any case, the fact that we have two feats of this category in the verse says something.
- 17,231
- 26,961
Yeah agreed that opens up much more precedent for that ouright removing the possibly
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #610
Serizawa's strength would be 7-C. Strength 6-A. Will this be the strongest 7-C character?
- 11,510
- 10,767
If both are fine with being used, then when do we determine which feats are being used?
Now, me personally I would just stick to one medium for feats, just because of consistency issues (IE the manga likely having far smaller scale feats due to art limitations, or the anime exaggerating and overblowing feats).
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #612
High 6-A's calculation for Toichiro's explosion was accepted by the calculation team.
He believes that Mob would not be able to leave the affected area with his speed.
Previously, Plank69, CloverDragon03 and other users were hesitant to use melt, so it should be fine now.
A number of people have suggested using linear speed scaling.
What do you think?
- 17,231
- 26,961
Well we already covered this stuff earlier soo
opinion is definitely noted and respected but we're pretty solidly accepted to be able to use bothI'm not sure I understand what you're asking
- 11,510
- 10,767
No, I'm asking when do we know when to use which medium? If Mob for example destroyed a town in both the anime and manga, then which one would we use and why?Well we already covered this stuff earlier soo
I already know about what's been accepted, I'm not contending against said decision.
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #615
If the anime feat is more detailed and large-scale, then we use it
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #616
If his AP scales to 7-C+ and his durability scales to 6-A, then characters of his level won't be able to penetrate him. Imba.
- 11,510
- 10,767
And why is that? This response doesn't get to the root of the question.
If the manga's feat isn't clear, then I understand. But if it's calcable, but it's just not as pretty as the anime, then why would we use the anime?
- 17,231
- 26,961
Anime primarily as these comments
Post in thread 'Mob Psycho 100 upgrade' https://vsbattles.com/threads/mob-psycho-100-upgrade.146840/post-5338856
"One is an excellent author, but subpar artist, getting anything from the original work is unreasonable imo. Anime is fine to use.
The Mogami feat though feels kinda iffy to me, been a while but pretty sure it was like in a dream, which wasn't even made out of real stuff"
Post in thread 'Mob Psycho 100 upgrade' https://vsbattles.com/threads/mob-psycho-100-upgrade.146840/post-5338924
"Like I've said, I'm of the mind that using the anime feats is fine. Unlike other mangas, not only does ONE'S art style make sizes and perspectives very inconsistent and hard to use, but we actually have the anime as an alternative for it, and a 1:1 adaptation of the feats with the only difference being the calculated values.
So if we are going to use anime feats primarily, count me in."
And regarding Mogami's world, personally I'm neutral towards its use. It can wait until after we settle the anime-manga feat issues.
Staff and user seem to have the same sorta thoughts
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #619
The use of anime and manga has already been decided.
All that's left is to figure out the scaling chain. However, with the new end of the feat, we need to reconsider the use of the Mogami feat
- 1,271
- 445
In the REIGEN manga, there is a spirit (I don't remember its name) that manages to knock out Serizawa. Would that position it as 6-A?
And then Reigen takes the spirit away for a long time. Wouldn't that increase its durability?
- 11,510
- 10,767
I still feel like the whole anime vs manga and when which should be used needs more direction and explanation. From what I saw, Staff literally just said they're fine with the anime because manga art is garbage, but someone also sent a feat from the anime that's completely different from the manga yet it's still being used.
Like if we're just gonna make an anime profile, then that's cool, but I think saying that we're using both is just a guise to cover the fact that not a single manga feat is being used (tmk), and nobody wants to find manga feats due to the feats being drastically lower than the anime.
Like if we're just gonna make an anime profile, then that's cool, but I think saying that we're using both is just a guise to cover the fact that not a single manga feat is being used (tmk), and nobody wants to find manga feats due to the feats being drastically lower than the anime.
- 1,271
- 445
In fact, if some feats from the manga are used.
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #623
We use a number of the manga's exploits for the 47th Division's pre-arc. Also the cloud feat is equivalent to the anime feat.
- 11,510
- 10,767
Yeah I just checked that most of his profile is manga. But my point is that composite profiles aren't allowed, unless in specific cases (like Boruto I think), where it was explicitly stated that both iterations are canon, and they both reference each other in some arcs.
But this isn't the case.
Could you explain what you mean here?
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #625
Clouds go the same way to the horizon in both manga and anime. The same kinetic energy
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #627
For this feat, we are using an anime timeframe. As in the case of the last calculation with the Suzuki explosion
- 11,510
- 10,767
So we're using the manga feat but using the anime timeframe? Or are we just using the anime?
Sorry if I'm aggressive I'm just confused
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #629
In this case, it doesn't matter at all.
But the same feat earthquake is based on the manga
- 6,020
- 3,043
This cover a good portion of what I wanted to say, like really the amount of assumptions needed to try to change the extremely simple line "you don't have time to run away from my big ass explosion" to "you can't escape my big ass explosion when running like a normal person with all your friends despite the fact that you can perfectly fly at hypersonic speed even while carrying others" is ridiculously.
About the anime feat talk, please stop with that, it was already accepted by more than 4-5 staffs (one more if counted the retired staff Dargoo who actively argued for that in the past and did calcs with the anime) after 2-3 pages of discussion, and this crt have already reached the 7 pages so please just apply the things and close this unnecessarily long thread.
- 11,510
- 10,767
It was a question because I needed clarification, thank you Dalsean and Nik.
As I already stated earlier, I wasn't going to read 7 whole pages, so I asked for a TL;DR.
- 3,688
- 2,322
I give up. Can't wait for the next revision thread which addresses all the points I made or revises the calcs that were done.
- 17,231
- 26,961
We addressed your points you haven't even provided scans that support your argument in anyway for what you were saying for the average human running argument or whatever...
- 4,716
- 4,209
Woah, can't believe we got High 6-A from something beside the Mogami world
Regardless it looks good, but I'd like to see a few more calc members opinions on it
Regardless it looks good, but I'd like to see a few more calc members opinions on it
- 18,580
- 18,640
We did and we found them to be mostly resolved or coming from a place of needless pedantry.
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #638
Should we still label a feat in the Mogami World as possible? I mean we have an accepted High 6-A feat and it's not even a baseline.
Having two High 6-A keys is a little weird
- 18,580
- 18,640
Mogami's is still in high contention for it's nature but now we have an actual High 6-A feat for support so.....huh.
I'm leaning on allowing it to scale to ???% and no one else maybe but we might honestly even discard it at this point.
- 3,068
- 1,658
- Thread starter
- #640
Let me remind you that many agreed with the direct scaling of the feat.
However, due to the lack of real-world counterparts to this feat, some had doubts.
Now that we have a supporting feat, we can scale this directly.
- Status
