- 671
- 739
Sandbox looks great to me, then. Full steam ahead
-
This forum is strictly intended to be used by members of the VS Battles wiki. Please only register if you have an autoconfirmed account there, as otherwise your registration will be rejected. If you have already registered once, do not do so again, and contact Antvasima if you encounter any problems.
For instructions regarding the exact procedure to sign up to this forum, please click here. -
We need Patreon donations for this forum to have all of its running costs financially secured.
Community members who help us out will receive badges that give them several different benefits, including the removal of all advertisements in this forum, but donations from non-members are also extremely appreciated.
Please click here for further information, or here to directly visit our Patreon donations page. -
Please click here for information about a large petition to help children in need.
MCU Love & Thunder Spoiler Thread
- Thread starter ArkhamDC06
- Start date
- 8,997
- 9,718
- 671
- 739
Are we ready to call in evaluation?
- 671
- 739
Bump
- 2,151
- 2,108
- 671
- 739
Bump
- 671
- 739
Wait is this no longer the active CRT? Maybe I missed something
- 8,997
- 9,718
- 671
- 739
Yeah for some reason my notifications shut down. I just got updated
- 50
- 21
Thor (Marvel Cinematic Universe)
Thor Odinson is the God of Thunder, prince of Asgard and a former member of the Avengers. When his irresponsible behavior threatened his homeland, he was stripped of his power and banished by his father Odin to Earth. While exiled on Earth, Thor learned humility, found love in Jane Foster, and...
vsbattles.fandom.com
Scaret Witch,Captain Marvel,Captain America,Thanos
- 8,997
- 9,718
NoSo Thor has been fixed,Other characters should be scaled up too?Thor (Marvel Cinematic Universe)
Thor Odinson is the God of Thunder, prince of Asgard and a former member of the Avengers. When his irresponsible behavior threatened his homeland, he was stripped of his power and banished by his father Odin to Earth. While exiled on Earth, Thor learned humility, found love in Jane Foster, and...
Scaret Witch,Captain Marvel,Captain America,Thanos
This has been discussed many times. The only characters who scale to Love and Thunder Thor are:
- Gorr
- Zeus
- Mighty Thor (Jane Foster)
- Valkyrie with Thunderbolt
- Hercules
- 10,787
- 16,051
Have to shove through their chest like how Thor shoved Stormbreaker through "The Anus's" chest.
- 25,017
- 27,011
- 10,787
- 16,051
- 189
- 76
I found proof for upgrading MCU Thor and Gorr to at least 4-C star level based solely on the star-moon relationship of the Shadow Realm in Love & Thunder.
The new wording for Gorr would be:
"At least Star Level (Empowered by the Necrosword, whose power moved both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe"
The wording for Thor's attack potency and durability would remain the same:
AP: "Fought evenly against Gorr the God Butcher on multiple occasions"
Durability: "Tanked a direct hit from Gorr's All-Black the Necrosword and endured a beating from him)
---
The Proof:
The Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:14:30 says "Light from a blazing sun revealed behind the celestial body washes over Jane's awed face just before the Goat Boat crashes into the surface of the moon."
Then the Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:28:40 says "In the Shadow Realm, the silhouette forms of the children can be seen against the bright glow of the sun as giant boulders float together to form pillars. With Stormbreaker slung across his back, Gorr stands at the front of the children and watches as chunks of the moon form the cracked stone floor of the structure around them."
This means Gorr generated the force necessary to move the mass of both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm from its previous position to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe.
We know this because the very previous scene is Thor and Valkyrie discussing directions to Eternity at the center of the universe, so Thor would not get lost. This discussion would be unnecessary if the previous position of the star and moon of the Shadow Realm had already been at the Gate of Eternity in the center of the universe, since Thor already knew how to reach the moon of the Shadow Realm and in fact had just been there a few minutes ago onscreen.
We also know that, at timestamp 1:28:40, the star and moon of the Shadow Realm are clearly in a different position than during Gorr's previous battle with Thor, Jane and Valkyrie at timestamp 1:21:10, because at timestamp 1:28:40 Gorr, the children, and outer space are in color instead of the black-white-gray of the previous battle.
Note that the Shadow Realm itself has areas of color, as proven at timestamp 43:31, when Thor first identifies that this is where the caged children are located. Thor, the children, and outer space are in color at timestamp 43:31, yet Thor says "I know where you are" and then a few seconds later "They're in the Shadow Realm." He does not say "I know where you're going" and he does not say "They're going to the Shadow Realm." They are already there, in color.
At timestamp 43:31, the children also are on a large floating rock in outer space, which is definitely under Gorr's control. This proves Gorr can move large amounts of matter through outer space.
---
IMPORTANT:
It does not matter whether Gorr directly moved the star and the moon to the Gate of Eternity, or whether Gorr only moved the moon while the star somehow orbits the moon on its own.
Why? At timestamp 33:57 Love & Thunder explicitly shows onscreen in the movie that the laws of centripetal force (F=mv^2/r) and Newton's law of universal gravitation (F=G*Mm/r^2) apply to actions in the MCU. Jane, an in-universe astrophysicist, teaches a lecture with both formulas on her whiteboard. She can only teach what she perceives, and she clearly perceives these laws of physics in that universe.
NASA says the laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation apply to objects such as our own Sun's pull on the Earth, and that both forces are equivalent to each other when also accounting for velocity.
https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/features/yba/CygX1_mass/gravity/sun_mass.html
Therefore, applying these laws and formulas to Gorr and/or the star-moon relationship of the Shadow Realm, this means that either the moon itself has much more mass than the star in order to keep the star orbiting the moon, or Gorr himself must generate enough centripetal force / gravitational attraction to simulate that greater mass ... as they all move from the place of battle at timestamp 1:21:10 to the center of the universe at timestamp 1:28:40.
The laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation also mean that even if we take a low mass for a real star, 3% of the sun's mass, either Gorr himself or the moon itself must generate at least 9.79x10^37 Newtons of force to keep it orbing the moon, if we assume 1 orbital rotation per minute velocity (onscreen approximation) at a distance of 1 astronomical unit (Earth to Sun). Increasing the velocity, and/or decreasing the distance, increases the force needed.
Mass of our sun = 1.989x10^30 kilograms
3% mass of our sun = 5.9x10^28 kilograms = M
r = 1 astronomical unit = 1.495x10^11 meters
v = 1 orbital rotation per minute at 1 astronomical unit = 1.56x10^10 meters per second
Centripetal force = F=Mv^2/r = (5.9x10^28 kilograms x (1.56x10^10 meters per second squared)) / 1.495x10^11 meters = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
Mass of the moon = m =v^2r/G = ((1.56x10^10 meters per second squared) x 1.495x10^11 meters) / Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 = 5.5x10^41 kilograms = m
Gravitational attraction = F=G(Mm/r^2) = Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 x ((5.9x10^28 kilograms x 5.5x10^41 kilograms) / 1.495x10^11 meters^2) = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
---
In a universe with Infinity Stones and weapons forged from neutron star material, a building-sized moon with large star-level mass would be very possible.
The new wording for Gorr would be:
"At least Star Level (Empowered by the Necrosword, whose power moved both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe"
The wording for Thor's attack potency and durability would remain the same:
AP: "Fought evenly against Gorr the God Butcher on multiple occasions"
Durability: "Tanked a direct hit from Gorr's All-Black the Necrosword and endured a beating from him)
---
The Proof:
The Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:14:30 says "Light from a blazing sun revealed behind the celestial body washes over Jane's awed face just before the Goat Boat crashes into the surface of the moon."
Then the Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:28:40 says "In the Shadow Realm, the silhouette forms of the children can be seen against the bright glow of the sun as giant boulders float together to form pillars. With Stormbreaker slung across his back, Gorr stands at the front of the children and watches as chunks of the moon form the cracked stone floor of the structure around them."
This means Gorr generated the force necessary to move the mass of both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm from its previous position to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe.
We know this because the very previous scene is Thor and Valkyrie discussing directions to Eternity at the center of the universe, so Thor would not get lost. This discussion would be unnecessary if the previous position of the star and moon of the Shadow Realm had already been at the Gate of Eternity in the center of the universe, since Thor already knew how to reach the moon of the Shadow Realm and in fact had just been there a few minutes ago onscreen.
We also know that, at timestamp 1:28:40, the star and moon of the Shadow Realm are clearly in a different position than during Gorr's previous battle with Thor, Jane and Valkyrie at timestamp 1:21:10, because at timestamp 1:28:40 Gorr, the children, and outer space are in color instead of the black-white-gray of the previous battle.
Note that the Shadow Realm itself has areas of color, as proven at timestamp 43:31, when Thor first identifies that this is where the caged children are located. Thor, the children, and outer space are in color at timestamp 43:31, yet Thor says "I know where you are" and then a few seconds later "They're in the Shadow Realm." He does not say "I know where you're going" and he does not say "They're going to the Shadow Realm." They are already there, in color.
At timestamp 43:31, the children also are on a large floating rock in outer space, which is definitely under Gorr's control. This proves Gorr can move large amounts of matter through outer space.
---
IMPORTANT:
It does not matter whether Gorr directly moved the star and the moon to the Gate of Eternity, or whether Gorr only moved the moon while the star somehow orbits the moon on its own.
Why? At timestamp 33:57 Love & Thunder explicitly shows onscreen in the movie that the laws of centripetal force (F=mv^2/r) and Newton's law of universal gravitation (F=G*Mm/r^2) apply to actions in the MCU. Jane, an in-universe astrophysicist, teaches a lecture with both formulas on her whiteboard. She can only teach what she perceives, and she clearly perceives these laws of physics in that universe.
NASA says the laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation apply to objects such as our own Sun's pull on the Earth, and that both forces are equivalent to each other when also accounting for velocity.
https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/features/yba/CygX1_mass/gravity/sun_mass.html
Therefore, applying these laws and formulas to Gorr and/or the star-moon relationship of the Shadow Realm, this means that either the moon itself has much more mass than the star in order to keep the star orbiting the moon, or Gorr himself must generate enough centripetal force / gravitational attraction to simulate that greater mass ... as they all move from the place of battle at timestamp 1:21:10 to the center of the universe at timestamp 1:28:40.
The laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation also mean that even if we take a low mass for a real star, 3% of the sun's mass, either Gorr himself or the moon itself must generate at least 9.79x10^37 Newtons of force to keep it orbing the moon, if we assume 1 orbital rotation per minute velocity (onscreen approximation) at a distance of 1 astronomical unit (Earth to Sun). Increasing the velocity, and/or decreasing the distance, increases the force needed.
Mass of our sun = 1.989x10^30 kilograms
3% mass of our sun = 5.9x10^28 kilograms = M
r = 1 astronomical unit = 1.495x10^11 meters
v = 1 orbital rotation per minute at 1 astronomical unit = 1.56x10^10 meters per second
Centripetal force = F=Mv^2/r = (5.9x10^28 kilograms x (1.56x10^10 meters per second squared)) / 1.495x10^11 meters = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
Mass of the moon = m =v^2r/G = ((1.56x10^10 meters per second squared) x 1.495x10^11 meters) / Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 = 5.5x10^41 kilograms = m
Gravitational attraction = F=G(Mm/r^2) = Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 x ((5.9x10^28 kilograms x 5.5x10^41 kilograms) / 1.495x10^11 meters^2) = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
---
In a universe with Infinity Stones and weapons forged from neutron star material, a building-sized moon with large star-level mass would be very possible.
Oliver_de_jesus
He/Him- 24,724
- 17,761
I found proof for upgrading MCU Thor and Gorr to at least 4-C star level based solely on the star-moon relationship of the Shadow Realm in Love & Thunder.
The new wording for Gorr would be:
"At least Star Level (Empowered by the Necrosword, whose power moved both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe"
The wording for Thor's attack potency and durability would remain the same:
AP: "Fought evenly against Gorr the God Butcher on multiple occasions"
Durability: "Tanked a direct hit from Gorr's All-Black the Necrosword and endured a beating from him)
---
The Proof:
The Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:14:30 says "Light from a blazing sun revealed behind the celestial body washes over Jane's awed face just before the Goat Boat crashes into the surface of the moon."
Then the Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:28:40 says "In the Shadow Realm, the silhouette forms of the children can be seen against the bright glow of the sun as giant boulders float together to form pillars. With Stormbreaker slung across his back, Gorr stands at the front of the children and watches as chunks of the moon form the cracked stone floor of the structure around them."
This means Gorr generated the force necessary to move the mass of both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm from its previous position to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe.
We know this because the very previous scene is Thor and Valkyrie discussing directions to Eternity at the center of the universe, so Thor would not get lost. This discussion would be unnecessary if the previous position of the star and moon of the Shadow Realm had already been at the Gate of Eternity in the center of the universe, since Thor already knew how to reach the moon of the Shadow Realm and in fact had just been there a few minutes ago onscreen.
We also know that, at timestamp 1:28:40, the star and moon of the Shadow Realm are clearly in a different position than during Gorr's previous battle with Thor, Jane and Valkyrie at timestamp 1:21:10, because at timestamp 1:28:40 Gorr, the children, and outer space are in color instead of the black-white-gray of the previous battle.
Note that the Shadow Realm itself has areas of color, as proven at timestamp 43:31, when Thor first identifies that this is where the caged children are located. Thor, the children, and outer space are in color at timestamp 43:31, yet Thor says "I know where you are" and then a few seconds later "They're in the Shadow Realm." He does not say "I know where you're going" and he does not say "They're going to the Shadow Realm." They are already there, in color.
At timestamp 43:31, the children also are on a large floating rock in outer space, which is definitely under Gorr's control. This proves Gorr can move large amounts of matter through outer space.
---
IMPORTANT:
It does not matter whether Gorr directly moved the star and the moon to the Gate of Eternity, or whether Gorr only moved the moon while the star somehow orbits the moon on its own.
Why? At timestamp 33:57 Love & Thunder explicitly shows onscreen in the movie that the laws of centripetal force (F=mv^2/r) and Newton's law of universal gravitation (F=G*Mm/r^2) apply to actions in the MCU. Jane, an in-universe astrophysicist, teaches a lecture with both formulas on her whiteboard. She can only teach what she perceives, and she clearly perceives these laws of physics in that universe.
NASA says the laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation apply to objects such as our own Sun's pull on the Earth, and that both forces are equivalent to each other when also accounting for velocity.
https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/features/yba/CygX1_mass/gravity/sun_mass.html
Therefore, applying these laws and formulas to Gorr and/or the star-moon relationship of the Shadow Realm, this means that either the moon itself has much more mass than the star in order to keep the star orbiting the moon, or Gorr himself must generate enough centripetal force / gravitational attraction to simulate that greater mass ... as they all move from the place of battle at timestamp 1:21:10 to the center of the universe at timestamp 1:28:40.
The laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation also mean that even if we take a low mass for a real star, 3% of the sun's mass, either Gorr himself or the moon itself must generate at least 9.79x10^37 Newtons of force to keep it orbing the moon, if we assume 1 orbital rotation per minute velocity (onscreen approximation) at a distance of 1 astronomical unit (Earth to Sun). Increasing the velocity, and/or decreasing the distance, increases the force needed.
Mass of our sun = 1.989x10^30 kilograms
3% mass of our sun = 5.9x10^28 kilograms = M
r = 1 astronomical unit = 1.495x10^11 meters
v = 1 orbital rotation per minute at 1 astronomical unit = 1.56x10^10 meters per second
Centripetal force = F=Mv^2/r = (5.9x10^28 kilograms x (1.56x10^10 meters per second squared)) / 1.495x10^11 meters = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
Mass of the moon = m =v^2r/G = ((1.56x10^10 meters per second squared) x 1.495x10^11 meters) / Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 = 5.5x10^41 kilograms = m
Gravitational attraction = F=G(Mm/r^2) = Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 x ((5.9x10^28 kilograms x 5.5x10^41 kilograms) / 1.495x10^11 meters^2) = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
---
In a universe with Infinity Stones and weapons forged from neutron star material, a building-sized moon with large star-level mass would be very possible.
holy Sparda
Liquid_Bigb0ss
He/Him- 110
- 83
So is Odin in-universe considered an average or even weak god if he isn’t in omnipotence city
- 671
- 739
I found proof for upgrading MCU Thor and Gorr to at least 4-C star level based solely on the star-moon relationship of the Shadow Realm in Love & Thunder.
The new wording for Gorr would be:
"At least Star Level (Empowered by the Necrosword, whose power moved both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe"
The wording for Thor's attack potency and durability would remain the same:
AP: "Fought evenly against Gorr the God Butcher on multiple occasions"
Durability: "Tanked a direct hit from Gorr's All-Black the Necrosword and endured a beating from him)
---
The Proof:
The Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:14:30 says "Light from a blazing sun revealed behind the celestial body washes over Jane's awed face just before the Goat Boat crashes into the surface of the moon."
Then the Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:28:40 says "In the Shadow Realm, the silhouette forms of the children can be seen against the bright glow of the sun as giant boulders float together to form pillars. With Stormbreaker slung across his back, Gorr stands at the front of the children and watches as chunks of the moon form the cracked stone floor of the structure around them."
This means Gorr generated the force necessary to move the mass of both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm from its previous position to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe.
We know this because the very previous scene is Thor and Valkyrie discussing directions to Eternity at the center of the universe, so Thor would not get lost. This discussion would be unnecessary if the previous position of the star and moon of the Shadow Realm had already been at the Gate of Eternity in the center of the universe, since Thor already knew how to reach the moon of the Shadow Realm and in fact had just been there a few minutes ago onscreen.
We also know that, at timestamp 1:28:40, the star and moon of the Shadow Realm are clearly in a different position than during Gorr's previous battle with Thor, Jane and Valkyrie at timestamp 1:21:10, because at timestamp 1:28:40 Gorr, the children, and outer space are in color instead of the black-white-gray of the previous battle.
Note that the Shadow Realm itself has areas of color, as proven at timestamp 43:31, when Thor first identifies that this is where the caged children are located. Thor, the children, and outer space are in color at timestamp 43:31, yet Thor says "I know where you are" and then a few seconds later "They're in the Shadow Realm." He does not say "I know where you're going" and he does not say "They're going to the Shadow Realm." They are already there, in color.
At timestamp 43:31, the children also are on a large floating rock in outer space, which is definitely under Gorr's control. This proves Gorr can move large amounts of matter through outer space.
---
IMPORTANT:
It does not matter whether Gorr directly moved the star and the moon to the Gate of Eternity, or whether Gorr only moved the moon while the star somehow orbits the moon on its own.
Why? At timestamp 33:57 Love & Thunder explicitly shows onscreen in the movie that the laws of centripetal force (F=mv^2/r) and Newton's law of universal gravitation (F=G*Mm/r^2) apply to actions in the MCU. Jane, an in-universe astrophysicist, teaches a lecture with both formulas on her whiteboard. She can only teach what she perceives, and she clearly perceives these laws of physics in that universe.
NASA says the laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation apply to objects such as our own Sun's pull on the Earth, and that both forces are equivalent to each other when also accounting for velocity.
https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/features/yba/CygX1_mass/gravity/sun_mass.html
Therefore, applying these laws and formulas to Gorr and/or the star-moon relationship of the Shadow Realm, this means that either the moon itself has much more mass than the star in order to keep the star orbiting the moon, or Gorr himself must generate enough centripetal force / gravitational attraction to simulate that greater mass ... as they all move from the place of battle at timestamp 1:21:10 to the center of the universe at timestamp 1:28:40.
The laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation also mean that even if we take a low mass for a real star, 3% of the sun's mass, either Gorr himself or the moon itself must generate at least 9.79x10^37 Newtons of force to keep it orbing the moon, if we assume 1 orbital rotation per minute velocity (onscreen approximation) at a distance of 1 astronomical unit (Earth to Sun). Increasing the velocity, and/or decreasing the distance, increases the force needed.
Mass of our sun = 1.989x10^30 kilograms
3% mass of our sun = 5.9x10^28 kilograms = M
r = 1 astronomical unit = 1.495x10^11 meters
v = 1 orbital rotation per minute at 1 astronomical unit = 1.56x10^10 meters per second
Centripetal force = F=Mv^2/r = (5.9x10^28 kilograms x (1.56x10^10 meters per second squared)) / 1.495x10^11 meters = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
Mass of the moon = m =v^2r/G = ((1.56x10^10 meters per second squared) x 1.495x10^11 meters) / Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 = 5.5x10^41 kilograms = m
Gravitational attraction = F=G(Mm/r^2) = Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 x ((5.9x10^28 kilograms x 5.5x10^41 kilograms) / 1.495x10^11 meters^2) = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
---
In a universe with Infinity Stones and weapons forged from neutron star material, a building-sized moon with large star-level mass would be very possible.
The subtitles are pretty solid supporting evidence
- 8,997
- 9,718
Considering his status prior to becoming a benevolent king, Odin is definitely not an average / weak god
Also, I'm pretty sure Odin was once a member of Omnipotence City and represented the Asgardians
Last edited:
Liquid_Bigb0ss
He/Him- 110
- 83
Oh ok, thanks for clarification. It’s been awhile since I watched ragnarok and I haven’t been keeping up much with the MCU anymore after the disappointment that was MoM and the embarrassment that was Love and Thunder. Though how would Odin scale to the other gods like konshu, Ammit, zeus, and current Thor?
- 8,997
- 9,718
Eh, I enjoyed these two movies. Like, I get the negativity around them, but I feel like they are overhated
Not sure about Zeus and current Thor. But if I'm not wrong about him being once part of Omnipotence City, there's a possibility of him scaling to Khonshu and Ammit
Liquid_Bigb0ss
He/Him- 110
- 83
To each their own. Though I don’t hate MoM per say, but I think i just think it didn’t live up to the hype built up for it. And it felt like a Scarlett witch movie to me more than anything.
I think this would be a nice upgrade for Odin if he does scale to khonshu and Ammit.
Coolboy6
He/Him- 7,436
- 6,003
I found proof for upgrading MCU Thor and Gorr to at least 4-C star level based solely on the star-moon relationship of the Shadow Realm in Love & Thunder.
The new wording for Gorr would be:
"At least Star Level (Empowered by the Necrosword, whose power moved both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe"
The wording for Thor's attack potency and durability would remain the same:
AP: "Fought evenly against Gorr the God Butcher on multiple occasions"
Durability: "Tanked a direct hit from Gorr's All-Black the Necrosword and endured a beating from him)
---
The Proof:
The Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:14:30 says "Light from a blazing sun revealed behind the celestial body washes over Jane's awed face just before the Goat Boat crashes into the surface of the moon."
Then the Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:28:40 says "In the Shadow Realm, the silhouette forms of the children can be seen against the bright glow of the sun as giant boulders float together to form pillars. With Stormbreaker slung across his back, Gorr stands at the front of the children and watches as chunks of the moon form the cracked stone floor of the structure around them."
This means Gorr generated the force necessary to move the mass of both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm from its previous position to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe.
We know this because the very previous scene is Thor and Valkyrie discussing directions to Eternity at the center of the universe, so Thor would not get lost. This discussion would be unnecessary if the previous position of the star and moon of the Shadow Realm had already been at the Gate of Eternity in the center of the universe, since Thor already knew how to reach the moon of the Shadow Realm and in fact had just been there a few minutes ago onscreen.
We also know that, at timestamp 1:28:40, the star and moon of the Shadow Realm are clearly in a different position than during Gorr's previous battle with Thor, Jane and Valkyrie at timestamp 1:21:10, because at timestamp 1:28:40 Gorr, the children, and outer space are in color instead of the black-white-gray of the previous battle.
Note that the Shadow Realm itself has areas of color, as proven at timestamp 43:31, when Thor first identifies that this is where the caged children are located. Thor, the children, and outer space are in color at timestamp 43:31, yet Thor says "I know where you are" and then a few seconds later "They're in the Shadow Realm." He does not say "I know where you're going" and he does not say "They're going to the Shadow Realm." They are already there, in color.
At timestamp 43:31, the children also are on a large floating rock in outer space, which is definitely under Gorr's control. This proves Gorr can move large amounts of matter through outer space.
---
IMPORTANT:
It does not matter whether Gorr directly moved the star and the moon to the Gate of Eternity, or whether Gorr only moved the moon while the star somehow orbits the moon on its own.
Why? At timestamp 33:57 Love & Thunder explicitly shows onscreen in the movie that the laws of centripetal force (F=mv^2/r) and Newton's law of universal gravitation (F=G*Mm/r^2) apply to actions in the MCU. Jane, an in-universe astrophysicist, teaches a lecture with both formulas on her whiteboard. She can only teach what she perceives, and she clearly perceives these laws of physics in that universe.
NASA says the laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation apply to objects such as our own Sun's pull on the Earth, and that both forces are equivalent to each other when also accounting for velocity.
https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/features/yba/CygX1_mass/gravity/sun_mass.html
Therefore, applying these laws and formulas to Gorr and/or the star-moon relationship of the Shadow Realm, this means that either the moon itself has much more mass than the star in order to keep the star orbiting the moon, or Gorr himself must generate enough centripetal force / gravitational attraction to simulate that greater mass ... as they all move from the place of battle at timestamp 1:21:10 to the center of the universe at timestamp 1:28:40.
The laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation also mean that even if we take a low mass for a real star, 3% of the sun's mass, either Gorr himself or the moon itself must generate at least 9.79x10^37 Newtons of force to keep it orbing the moon, if we assume 1 orbital rotation per minute velocity (onscreen approximation) at a distance of 1 astronomical unit (Earth to Sun). Increasing the velocity, and/or decreasing the distance, increases the force needed.
Mass of our sun = 1.989x10^30 kilograms
3% mass of our sun = 5.9x10^28 kilograms = M
r = 1 astronomical unit = 1.495x10^11 meters
v = 1 orbital rotation per minute at 1 astronomical unit = 1.56x10^10 meters per second
Centripetal force = F=Mv^2/r = (5.9x10^28 kilograms x (1.56x10^10 meters per second squared)) / 1.495x10^11 meters = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
Mass of the moon = m =v^2r/G = ((1.56x10^10 meters per second squared) x 1.495x10^11 meters) / Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 = 5.5x10^41 kilograms = m
Gravitational attraction = F=G(Mm/r^2) = Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 x ((5.9x10^28 kilograms x 5.5x10^41 kilograms) / 1.495x10^11 meters^2) = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
---
In a universe with Infinity Stones and weapons forged from neutron star material, a building-sized moon with large star-level mass would be very possible.
Damn bro, nice job with all this research
- 2,304
- 2,734
I found proof for upgrading MCU Thor and Gorr to at least 4-C star level based solely on the star-moon relationship of the Shadow Realm in Love & Thunder.
The new wording for Gorr would be:
"At least Star Level (Empowered by the Necrosword, whose power moved both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe"
The wording for Thor's attack potency and durability would remain the same:
AP: "Fought evenly against Gorr the God Butcher on multiple occasions"
Durability: "Tanked a direct hit from Gorr's All-Black the Necrosword and endured a beating from him)
---
The Proof:
The Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:14:30 says "Light from a blazing sun revealed behind the celestial body washes over Jane's awed face just before the Goat Boat crashes into the surface of the moon."
Then the Disney+ official English [Audio Description] of Love & Thunder at timestamp 1:28:40 says "In the Shadow Realm, the silhouette forms of the children can be seen against the bright glow of the sun as giant boulders float together to form pillars. With Stormbreaker slung across his back, Gorr stands at the front of the children and watches as chunks of the moon form the cracked stone floor of the structure around them."
This means Gorr generated the force necessary to move the mass of both the star and moon of the Shadow Realm from its previous position to the Gate of Eternity at the center of the universe.
We know this because the very previous scene is Thor and Valkyrie discussing directions to Eternity at the center of the universe, so Thor would not get lost. This discussion would be unnecessary if the previous position of the star and moon of the Shadow Realm had already been at the Gate of Eternity in the center of the universe, since Thor already knew how to reach the moon of the Shadow Realm and in fact had just been there a few minutes ago onscreen.
We also know that, at timestamp 1:28:40, the star and moon of the Shadow Realm are clearly in a different position than during Gorr's previous battle with Thor, Jane and Valkyrie at timestamp 1:21:10, because at timestamp 1:28:40 Gorr, the children, and outer space are in color instead of the black-white-gray of the previous battle.
Note that the Shadow Realm itself has areas of color, as proven at timestamp 43:31, when Thor first identifies that this is where the caged children are located. Thor, the children, and outer space are in color at timestamp 43:31, yet Thor says "I know where you are" and then a few seconds later "They're in the Shadow Realm." He does not say "I know where you're going" and he does not say "They're going to the Shadow Realm." They are already there, in color.
At timestamp 43:31, the children also are on a large floating rock in outer space, which is definitely under Gorr's control. This proves Gorr can move large amounts of matter through outer space.
---
IMPORTANT:
It does not matter whether Gorr directly moved the star and the moon to the Gate of Eternity, or whether Gorr only moved the moon while the star somehow orbits the moon on its own.
Why? At timestamp 33:57 Love & Thunder explicitly shows onscreen in the movie that the laws of centripetal force (F=mv^2/r) and Newton's law of universal gravitation (F=G*Mm/r^2) apply to actions in the MCU. Jane, an in-universe astrophysicist, teaches a lecture with both formulas on her whiteboard. She can only teach what she perceives, and she clearly perceives these laws of physics in that universe.
NASA says the laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation apply to objects such as our own Sun's pull on the Earth, and that both forces are equivalent to each other when also accounting for velocity.
https://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/features/yba/CygX1_mass/gravity/sun_mass.html
Therefore, applying these laws and formulas to Gorr and/or the star-moon relationship of the Shadow Realm, this means that either the moon itself has much more mass than the star in order to keep the star orbiting the moon, or Gorr himself must generate enough centripetal force / gravitational attraction to simulate that greater mass ... as they all move from the place of battle at timestamp 1:21:10 to the center of the universe at timestamp 1:28:40.
The laws of centripetal force and Newton's law of universal gravitation also mean that even if we take a low mass for a real star, 3% of the sun's mass, either Gorr himself or the moon itself must generate at least 9.79x10^37 Newtons of force to keep it orbing the moon, if we assume 1 orbital rotation per minute velocity (onscreen approximation) at a distance of 1 astronomical unit (Earth to Sun). Increasing the velocity, and/or decreasing the distance, increases the force needed.
Mass of our sun = 1.989x10^30 kilograms
3% mass of our sun = 5.9x10^28 kilograms = M
r = 1 astronomical unit = 1.495x10^11 meters
v = 1 orbital rotation per minute at 1 astronomical unit = 1.56x10^10 meters per second
Centripetal force = F=Mv^2/r = (5.9x10^28 kilograms x (1.56x10^10 meters per second squared)) / 1.495x10^11 meters = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
Mass of the moon = m =v^2r/G = ((1.56x10^10 meters per second squared) x 1.495x10^11 meters) / Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 = 5.5x10^41 kilograms = m
Gravitational attraction = F=G(Mm/r^2) = Gravitational constant 6.67x10^-11 x ((5.9x10^28 kilograms x 5.5x10^41 kilograms) / 1.495x10^11 meters^2) = 9.79x10^37 Newtons
---
In a universe with Infinity Stones and weapons forged from neutron star material, a building-sized moon with large star-level mass would be very possible.
- 2,304
- 2,734
Make it a CRT
- 32,835
- 38,108
He already did once, it went nowhere.
- 189
- 76
That CRT began with a different argument. However I did add this current line of argument there recently as well. And nobody has yet to provide any definitive proof against the current argument.
