- 77
- 24
Hello everyone.
I would like to propose removing the Pre-Stellar Lifting Strength ratings for Thor and Gorr in the MCU.
The reason is simple: the current justification appears to be circular.
Thor’s Love and Thunder key currently has “At least Pre-Stellar” Lifting Strength because he evenly matched Gorr.
Gorr, meanwhile, has “At least Pre-Stellar” Lifting Strength because he evenly matched Thor.
So the scaling effectively becomes:
That is not a proper lifting strength justification.
Neither character has an actual Pre-Stellar lifting feat, nor do they scale from a character with an independently established Pre-Stellar lifting value. As such, this rating does not seem properly supported.
By contrast, Thor’s earlier Class P rating is at least feat-backed through moving the rings of Nidavellir, which is a direct lifting justification.
Proposed changes
Thor:
Remove “At least Pre-Stellar” Lifting Strength and keep him at Class P unless a better direct justification is provided.
Gorr:
Remove “At least Pre-Stellar” Lifting Strength and replace it with a more conservative rating until a proper feat or scaling chain is found.
Conclusion
The current Pre-Stellar ratings for Thor and Gorr seem to rely on circular scaling rather than an independent feat or a valid lifting chain, so I believe they should be removed.
I would like to propose removing the Pre-Stellar Lifting Strength ratings for Thor and Gorr in the MCU.
The reason is simple: the current justification appears to be circular.
Thor’s Love and Thunder key currently has “At least Pre-Stellar” Lifting Strength because he evenly matched Gorr.
Gorr, meanwhile, has “At least Pre-Stellar” Lifting Strength because he evenly matched Thor.
So the scaling effectively becomes:
- Thor gets Pre-Stellar from Gorr
- Gorr gets Pre-Stellar from Thor
That is not a proper lifting strength justification.
Neither character has an actual Pre-Stellar lifting feat, nor do they scale from a character with an independently established Pre-Stellar lifting value. As such, this rating does not seem properly supported.
By contrast, Thor’s earlier Class P rating is at least feat-backed through moving the rings of Nidavellir, which is a direct lifting justification.
Proposed changes
Thor:
Remove “At least Pre-Stellar” Lifting Strength and keep him at Class P unless a better direct justification is provided.
Gorr:
Remove “At least Pre-Stellar” Lifting Strength and replace it with a more conservative rating until a proper feat or scaling chain is found.
Conclusion
The current Pre-Stellar ratings for Thor and Gorr seem to rely on circular scaling rather than an independent feat or a valid lifting chain, so I believe they should be removed.
