Marvel Comics - Thor reclassification

[Ragnarok189]

So after reading the Avengers (2018) and Thor (2020), it's become really unclear as to what Thor's lineage is. For a while, it was Aesir-Elder God hybrid, but now the Pheonix Force claims him as his son and he has shown abilities from both lineages. Should we change his classification on his page to unclear?

Here's him using abilities from the PF and an alt Thor claiming the Pheonix Force as their mother.

Then, there's Freyja claiming Gaea as his mother and Thor praying to Gaea and thanking her.

There's multiple other instances of Thor having conflicting origins too, I can find them.

 

[Ragnarok189]

Bump.

 

[SaberPhantasy9]

the phoenix force stated that gaea being thor's mother was a lie, and that's more recent, so that should be put on the page, maybe a note to explain that his story varies

 

[Ragnarok189]

Technically, Freyja saying Gaea is his mother is more recent, due to the time situation Cates and Aaron have right now.

Cates' 2020 run is set in the future, while Aaron's is the current day? It's confusing since Aaron is taking events happening in Cates' 2020 run and placing them in his 2018 run, even though Thor is a retired hero for Cates.

 

[SaberPhantasy9]

comics. i guess just list them both and make a note of it?

 

[Firestorm808]

I would say to write the progression of his origin from the first to last.

 

[NaturalDestroyer]

Has the comic finally been published?

 

[Marvel_Champion_07]

Has the comic finally been published?

Avengers: 1,000,000 B.C. Vol 1 1

 

[Firestorm808]

Basic summary:

Not until many centuries later did Thor learn the purported truth that Jord was his birth mother,[53] though the Phoenix has asserted that Odin had lied about Thor's parentage and that it was his birth mother through Firehair, an ancient human mutant and avatar of the Phoenix Force,[33] claiming that Gaea was a lie to ensure that Thor would dedicate himself to protecting the Earth.[2] In truth, Gaea was Thor's birth mother, with the Phoenix acting as her midwife, but when the newborn Thor was assassinated by King Laufey the Phoenix resurrected him, leaving him permanently imbued with some of her power.[39]

 

[NaturalDestroyer]

I hope they use that as an excuse to give him some permanent new abilities or amps, then